HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

brolover

74 karma · joined May 9, 2018

submissionscomments
brolover··on The World Wants More Camel Milk
Soy milk is the only milk I drink. Any other plant milk is too much water and too little nutrients.
brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
It's not negatively correlated, they have not measured the effects of >1 egg/day. It doesn't change anything. Saying that the food is healthy is vacuous.

Eating 1 egg per day for the average member of the measured population seems to be healthy. It does not mean eggs by themselves are healthy or unhealthy.

brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
It's not inversely correlated. The relationship is non-linear, how does that bear on their healthiness?

Unlike strawberries where relationship is linear, unlike many other vegetables. Put a healthy exercising population and the correlation disappears, I guess foods are no longer healthy in that case.

brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
I do not understand what the study contradicts? It mentions no particular food.
brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
Here's the study saying that alcohol has protective effects: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28818200

Not the first one of its kind but pretty large sample.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20636661

Here's a study showing that drinking a little alcohol lowers your chance of having liver cirrhosis compared to drinking no alcohol.

https://sci-hub.tw/10.1111/add.13627

Here's the criticism.

> We would like to add to her discussion of the significance of former and occasional drinker biases in this literature and highlight how they can cause both overestimation of cardioprotection and underestimation of cancer risks across the whole drinking continuum. The underlying theory here is that, as a population ages, a selection bias operates whereby individuals with poorer health are more likely to cut down or stop drinking completely. Such individuals are often still classified as ‘abstainers’ and used as a reference against which all current drinkers are compared. In simple terms, they make drinkers at all levels of consumption ‘look good’ by comparison.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26997174

Guys above then adjust for the mistake. The benefits disappear. Mortality risk grows as alcohol consumption increases. Yeah, there are people with protective genes, but on a population scale, recommending to go from 0 to N glasses of alcoholic beverage a day is insane.

I have personally increased my alcohol consumption, which was obviously dumb, given that the data was flawed. After this study I don't think I'll have more than couple of drinks per year.

brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
I do not understand how the study you've given supports what you're telling me.

You cannot say that strawberries are the healthiest food, just like you cannot say eggs are not healthy.

brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
The assertion is not in contradiction to the study. Study makes no claims on healthiness of eggs.

Scientifically, healthy-unhealthy food does not exist. There's no health scale. Everything depends on the context.

If your blood results and other health information is stable, whatever you're eating isn't doing you any harm, then that's a healthy lifestyle.

Trying to divide foods into healthy and unhealthy is impossible.

brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
https://sydney.edu.au/news-opinion/news/2018/05/07/-eggs-not...

Well, according to this study, eggs do not do anything for diabetics.

I'm pretty sure all of those observational studies (including the one I cite) are severely flawed.

brolover··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
This might suffer from the same issue the alcohol consumption study lacked.

People that aren't consuming eggs might do so because of health issues. Meaning that they are more prone to feel the side effects.

Similar effect happened in the alcohol study, where moderate consumption had a lower mortality than those consuming nothing. It turned out that those abstaining from alcohol were more prone to get side effects immediately. After adjusting for these errors in data reporting, the u-curve disappeared and the relationship was linear (more alcohol you consumed higher the mortality).

I was also, embarrassingly, citing the alcohol study, since then I've realized the first reaction to a paper should be doubt and I'll definitely abstain from acknowledging epidemiological diet studies in the future. Even meta-analyses taking them into account.

One of the best examples is that many meta-analyses conclude that dietary cholesterol does not increase serum cholesterol (proven risk in CVD). Disregarding the fact that many of the aggregated studies do not measure baseline cholesterol, and it is assumed that there's a linear response on serum cholesterol to dietary cholesterol when it's a 20 year old information that response is non-linear.

brolover··on Show HN: Vuido builds desktop apps using Vue.js without Electron
That's what Vuido is for, now there's no Electron.
brolover··on Show HN: Vuido builds desktop apps using Vue.js without Electron
ES6 (or 7) is a much better language than a bunch. Adding in the types through flow or typescript, and now it's a pragmatist's heaven.
brolover··on The fifth hyperfactorial: 5⁵×4⁴×3³×2²×1¹=86400000 milliseconds is exactly 1 day
10 factorial seconds is 42 days.
brolover··on Google employees reportedly quit over military drone AI project
I'm not surprised. After finishing my degree, I went to optimize a couple of production lines. I didn't get much detail and thought it was for plastic/glass bottles (filling liquids and moving them around - many tiny grabbers, simple movement, not that wide tracks).

After about 2 months of work, and after the production line got parallelized and speed drastically increased I went to see it work.

What I saw shocked me and I immediatelly quit. It was a production line for handling of female and male young and grown chicks. Debeaking, throat slitting. I was absolutely shocked how none of the superiors told me exactly which product was being handled.

After seeing the horrific product of my work I quit.

Since then, I'm not surprised, given what horrors we do to living animals, that we are ready to do them to each other.

I doubted the meaning of my work at university, what did I do? Spend 4 years at college to create killing machines? I didn't think I'd ever do that.

brolover··on Grid-Cell Like Deep Layers in Navigation AI
I've noticed that DeepMind completely ignores imitation learning area of research. I never saw them citing any of the fundamental papers, despite a bunch of their reinforcement learning ideas explicitly match those ideas that are now 8+ years old.
brolover··on The environmental impact of technology devices is getting worse
I'm using xperia mini st15i, personally optimized ROM. Yet still, no industry comes no where close to heating and cooling.

Let's optimize the slowest functions not tiny percentages.

brolover··on Firefox 60 released
It's quite a nice approach. It's practically optimizing the list of related websites to increase click through rates.
brolover··on The environmental impact of technology devices is getting worse
Exactly. The amount of energy spent on heating and cooling is huge. Then it's transportation and agriculture. Then somewhere far behind is the whole Internet and efficient electronic devices.

I use the same argument when it comes to bitcoin. That stuff is so tiny in our profiler. Sane thing to do is to optimize the slowest functions.