244 karma · joined March 7, 2009
I do agree that having tariffs on certain items to encourage domestic production definitely does work. The tariffs have to be consistent and on things that can actually be produced in the country.
The issue with Trump's approach is that its not consistent, has nothing to do with which products can be made domestically. Changing tariffs daily/weekly/monthly is not going to encourage domestic production.
Well its not like they have to individually lock each phone they sell by hand and your phone does not turn into a brick if its locked to a carrier. Yes definitely the functionality is drastically reduced but there are also people/services that will unlock your phone for you that don't work for the carrier. Maybe if the phone actually was unable to be used at all if it was locked and you didn't pay the bill, that would be a valid argument.
I can't really agree with just because they do it, it must work argument, I have, and I'm sure you have too, worked for a lot of companies that had policies or practices that did not work.
I worked in customer service for Rogers, a large telecom in Canada before unlocking was mandated. There were lots of customers that did not pay their phone bill despite their phone being locked. If people don't have the money (whether it be their fault or not) they aren't going to pay their phone bill no matter what sort of incentive you give them.
It's possible there are some obscure features that may not work properly but for general usage as far as phone calls, texting, data usage, I've never heard of anyone having any issues with their Canadian phone internationally, besides maybe the cost of roaming.If you have a source from recent times that says this, I'd like to see it.
As far as minimal competition goes, there is not an infinite amount of cellphone carriers in the US either that will give you a phone on credit, especially if you have bad credit. I'm sure there are existing ways you can scam phones out of carriers too if you are fine with being banned from the carrier and/or torching your credit.
I worked in customer support for Rogers(A Canadian phone carrier) for a very short period before it was mandated to have unlocked phones and people still stopped paying their bill even if the phone was locked. The vast majority of people want to pay their bills on time especially for something as critical as phone service. The people who don't, are going to not pay their bill no matter what sort of rules in place because they either simply don't have the money or they don't care.
I don't see why its different than a car really. While some dealerships are adding GPS trackers nowadays, there is nothing stopping you from buying a car on credit and driving it to Mexico and hiding it in a locked garage. It's going to be very difficult to buy another car if you do that though, and that's enough of a deterrence for most people as they have to continue living their lives and eventually buy a new car.
Also you can still get the phone unlocked without the carrier anyways if you really want to so it would not deter anyone who really wants to run off with the phone anyways.