HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Veen

9,773 karma · joined August 16, 2016

submissionscomments
Veen··on Building better AI tools
As a technical writer, I don't use Deep Research because it makes me worse at my job. Research, note-taking, and summarization are how I develop an understanding of a topic so I can write knowledgeably about it. The resulting notes are almost incidental. If I let an AI do that work for me, I get the notes but no understanding. Reading the document produced by the AI is not a substitute for doing the work.
Veen··on The United States withdraws from UNESCO
> False. Americans taught for liberty from oppression. Same for Irish. Calling them terrorists is the slander of colonialists.

The Americans were the colonialists. They fought to evade taxes and to be free to steal land from its indigenous inhabitants, in pursuit of which they committed a genocide. The latter, in particular, was strongly opposed by the British government. A 1763 Royal Proclamation prohibited settlement west of the Appalachian Mountains, reserving lands for indigenous peoples. After alleviating themselves of those restrictions, the freedom-loving Americans then practiced a brutal form of chattel slavery for many decades after it had been outlawed by more civilized nations, including the Empire they had fought to be free of.

Veen··on Compression culture is making you stupid and uninteresting
Yes. Because a "trustworthy person" is one who has demonstrated their authority, who has experienced the work in its full form, who has the taste and experience to make a determination as to its quality and usefulness, and who is capable of presenting reasoned arguments that support their opinion. Such people exist.

In the current climate, it may seem odd to trust the opinion of a fellow human instead of AI summaries and your personal predilections, but that is exactly what I am arguing we should do.

Veen··on Compression culture is making you stupid and uninteresting
The alternative is to find people you trust, or who are widely considered trustworthy, and read what they recommend. The canon was invented to solve this problem.
Veen··on The United States withdraws from UNESCO
We described it as tax avoidance and treasonous collaboration with the enemy we really cared about — the French.
Veen··on Compression culture is making you stupid and uninteresting
But the summary rarely captures what makes the book worth reading in the first place, so your decision is based on inadequate information.
Veen··on The United States withdraws from UNESCO
You can acknowledge Palestinians exist without giving the terrorist Palestinian state equal status with other members of the community of nations.
Veen··on CBA hiring Indian ICT workers after firing Australians
Resistance to free market economics is not necessarily Marxist. Old-fashioned one-nation conservatives also find offshoring of this sort objectionable. If you consider the job of the state to be to cultivate a stable, cohesive society, you're going to favour regulation of actions that undermine that objective, including business strategies that erode the local skill base and economy.
Veen··on UK backing down on Apple encryption backdoor after pressure from US
That’s a specifically US interpretation based on US case law. It doesn’t apply in the UK or anywhere else.
Veen··on AGI Is Mathematically Impossible (3): Kolmogorov Complexity
That's one possible inference. However, it would also be consistent to claim that there is a fundamentally uncomputable and impossible-to-artificially-replicate "mechanism" underlying human intelligence.
Veen··on AGI Is Mathematically Impossible (3): Kolmogorov Complexity
What examples are there of the possibility of artificial general intelligence?
Veen··on Grok: Searching X for "From:Elonmusk (Israel or Palestine or Hamas or Gaza)"
Simon would be less engaging if he caveated every generalisation in that way. It’s one of the main reasons academic writing is often tedious to read.
Veen··on Adding a feature because ChatGPT incorrectly thinks it exists
I always like to share this when the passive voice comes up:

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLNRhI4Cc_QmsihIjUtqro3uBk...

Veen··on A non-anthropomorphized view of LLMs
Some models are useful in some contexts but wrong enough to be harmful in others.
Veen··on As a Labrador swam by me out to sea his owner said I hope he doesn't meet a seal
It is not polite to assume that you, after a brief amount of thinking with no background knowledge, have overturned centuries of empirical and scientific knowledge of canine behavioural heredity. It is astonishingly presumptuous. And it is, indeed, peak HN arrogance to make that assumption.
Veen··on The wanton destruction of a creative-tech era
Why did they buy it in the first place, then?
Veen··on The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million
Counting is very time-consuming, important to get right, and easy to get wrong. I expect quite a few businesses are happy to pay that for fast, accurate counting.
Veen··on More on Apple's Trust-Eroding 'F1 the Movie' Wallet Ad
Risk isn’t an absolute. Open systems may be verifiable, but they are also more difficult to use, inconvenient, and lack the features users want. So most people won’t use them or will use them badly. Apple reduces privacy risk relative to open solutions used by non-expert users. The purist approach to privacy increases risk to ordinary users. It’s better to be pragmatic; Apple isn’t ideal, but it’s better than the realistic alternatives.
Veen··on More on Apple's Trust-Eroding 'F1 the Movie' Wallet Ad
It’s not a dichotomy, but an observation about how data privacy tends to work in the real world. You can easily refute it with practical examples of how openness has actually improved privacy for the average user relative to Apple’s closed, managed privacy programs. Would an average non-technical Apple user be exposed to higher or lower security and privacy risk if they moved from Apple platforms to open platforms?
Veen··on More on Apple's Trust-Eroding 'F1 the Movie' Wallet Ad
Lack of openness means a lack of privacy in theory, but in practice, openness often results in less privacy. The average user lacks the knowledge, time, and motivation to install and configure open systems to maximize privacy. They're likely to make mistakes that expose private data.

A closed system that prioritizes privacy will result in more users benefiting from greater privacy overall, even if it does give the platform more control than is ideal. And that's the issue with the wallet ads: Apple makes users more secure on average, but it depends on user trust, which it just betrayed.

Those who can take advantage of total control are a minority, and they are not really the people Apple cares about.

Veen··on I deleted my second brain
It’s not knowledge unless they actually know it. It’s just a collection of information.
Veen··on I deleted my second brain
The rule of threes is a widely known rhetorical guideline. Some people do take it a bit far, though.
Veen··on Apple Research unearthed forgotten AI technique and using it to generate images
It reads like the work of a professional writer who uses a handful of variant sentence structures and conventions to quickly write an article. That’s what professional writers are trained to do.
Veen··on Why Engineers Hate Their Managers (and What to Do About It)
Things might get done, but would they be the things that the company's upper management and investors want done?
Veen··on Man 'refused entry into US' as border control catch him with bald JD Vance meme
You may be right, anal_reactor.
Veen··on Man 'refused entry into US' as border control catch him with bald JD Vance meme
Most morally mature people practice that sort of reasoning. They take into account intentions, likely consequences, the state of knowledge of those involved, and other complicating factors before coming to a conclusion.
Veen··on Man 'refused entry into US' as border control catch him with bald JD Vance meme
Because people of all political persuasions tell lies for attention and to support their political agenda. It is sensible to withhold judgment until there is sufficient information to make a reasonable determination on the balance of probabilities. That may mean witholding your righteous indignation for a day or two, but that's a price worth paying.
Veen··on The Gender Attractiveness Gap
It’s about a subjective phenomenon.
Veen··on Microsoft suspended the email account of an ICC prosecutor at The Hague
The Hague Conventions and the Kellogg-Briand Pact. Although, in reality, it was a matter of the winners deciding on a suitable punishment for the losers. They did, however, go to considerable lengths to find legal justification in international law for the prosecutions and punishments of Nazi leaders. They could have just shot them: Churchill and Stalin both supported summary execution, although Churchill later changed his mind.
Veen··on Harper – an open-source alternative to Grammarly
People are bad at proofreading their own work. Professional writers often use third-party copy editors and proofreaders for that reason.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →