HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TobyTheDog123

584 karma · joined March 1, 2022

submissionscomments
TobyTheDog123··on Don't build AI products the way everyone else is doing it
I don't really understand your hostile response nor foaming-at-the-mouth hatred of blockchain technology (I'm guessing it came from a bad interaction with a crypto bro on Twitter or something), however I think OP is just saying that both were popular technological trends that people tries to exploit to solve problems that society didn't really have.

One technology is obviously more helpful than the other, but that doesn't mean either are the right choice for the business you're building.

TobyTheDog123··on Htmx, Rust and Shuttle: A New Rapid Prototyping Stack
HTMX/Rust seem like great choices for making good architectural decisions, having long-term scalability, and having great performance, but certainly not for rapid prototyping.

If I'm validating a business idea / building a proof of concept, I'm using something like SvelteKit or even NextJS. Going the middle-of-the-road seems to me like either a waste of resources or a waste of time depending on your goals.

TobyTheDog123··on Microfrontends should be a last resort
I was on an MFE team earlier this year. It was sold to higher-ups as being for both, but I think in most cases it's bad for both. IME, it was sold in terms of code code-reuse by providing things like shared navigation bars, shared authentication logic, etc.

My team, at least, did not have the necessary support structures in place to help others who wanted to maintain their own UI. I see this mostly when crossing framework/language boundaries (mixing React + Angular in a SPA, as it was in my case). They declare microfrontends, but then all the component libraries were all React-based anyways.

It just ended up being a mess of N deployment processes, N build systems, N storage buckets, zero standardization whatsoever, and mountains of technical debt, all without much benefit.

...but if you're all working in the same language/framework where that component/style-lock-in is acceptable, why would someone use a microfrontend to begin with? Can the organization not set up a single repository with different teams contributing to it? One deployment, one build system, one storage bucket, and standardization?

IMO CODEOWNERS is the original and best "microfrontend" solution for small-to-medium-sized teams working on a single product. If you have hundreds or thousands of engineers (think FAANG) working on a single experience that just HAS to be a SPA, then maybe you have the resources to build out those support structures and actually get MFEs to work on an organizational level.

In the vast majority of cases, however, I see it as a bandaid on an organizational problem that's eaten up because it's an interesting technical challenge for senior engineers to think about (someone made a great comment about "drawing the perfect box"), and because management thinks it's a cool trend with benefits they can grok.

TobyTheDog123··on Google Docs adds tracking to links in document exports
>Surely google.com is as 'surprising' to the user as any other page.

The metric isn't how surprising it is, but how potentially malicious it is. The entire point of the redirect is so the user can make a conscious decision not to visit a potentially-malicious page.

Google.com and Youtube.com, operated by the same people who made the docs tool, make the entirely-fair assumption that neither contain malware.

That being said, I also think it's the wrong argument to make. It makes very little sense that an exported document needs these interstitials. It would make more sense if it applied them to hosted Google Docs, but not things that are self-hosted by an end-user.

TobyTheDog123··on Meta Quest 3
>The main difference seems to be the micro OLED and eye tracking on the Vision Pro vs. the Quest’s inclusion of controllers.

Both of which are complete dealbreakers.

AR/VR/Spatial is defined completely by immersion and lack-of-nausea, where less resolution and the inclusion of controllers demolish.

You're right, both probably won't reach mass-market appeal, but the two certainly aren't comparable in any metric other than reach.

TobyTheDog123··on Meta Quest 3
After I lost all of my purchases after deleting my Facebook account (not that I used my old Quest anyways), I decided I would never purchase another Meta product (even though that's probably the LEAST abusive thing they do).
TobyTheDog123··on IPFS support got merged into curl
I'm not that familiar with IPFS I must admit (though it looks great conceptually), but if using the curl CLI tool, why would the operator not just curl the public gateway address?

I'm confused on why such a shallow abstraction was put into something present on every device, and why this seems to be such a big deal to the decentralized community.

Even with it's automatic gateway detection it's purely used to rewrite the URL, which seems like something the operator could easily do themselves.

I could easily be missing something here though.

TobyTheDog123··on Authentication on meet.jit.si
Well on the bright side, hopefully this incentivizes Jitsi to finally put first-class OIDC support into the codebase, which it still lacks.

I don't want to set up an entire LDAP server when I already have Authelia running.

TobyTheDog123··on Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features
>So people should not have the option of paying less of paying less for less features?

They should, it's called buying a different car without those features installed.

>Everyone must pay for features that only a subset of customers use?

You are already paying for those features upfront as part of buying the car - there is no recurring expense to the manufacturer. If you do not want or are unable to pay for those features, you buy a different car without them installed.

What you're arguing for is for everyone to have to pay another monthly subscription, and conflating "paying more for a car" with "paying monthly for non-consumable resources for a car".

TobyTheDog123··on Disables WebEnvironmentIntegrity feature and origin trials
I would be surprised if politicians and regulators even know what a web browser is, so this might be a tough sell to them.
TobyTheDog123··on ProtonMail Rewrites Your Emails
I'm in the process of doing this now, using Postmark's SMTP relay. Hopefully one day I'll meet their requirements for not retaining logs:

1. Account must be Approved and in good standing for at least 6 months

2. Account must be on a paid monthly plan for 6 consecutive months (or have purchase credits)

3. Account must have a lifetime sending volume of over 10,000 messages

https://postmarkapp.com/smtp-service

https://postmarkapp.com/support/article/1139-can-i-hide-or-d...

TobyTheDog123··on Threads, an Instagram app
I could not disagree more. I really don't think people are going to trust Meta that much more over Twitter. I'm a pretty avid Twitter lurker and I don't even plan on trying out the app.

I'm also a very happy Lemmy and Mastodon user, but going from Twitter to Threads is just trading Elon for Zuckerberg - a useless lateral move.

TobyTheDog123··on Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear
Also push everything up to GitHub before deplaning starts :^)

(or always bring a large USB)

TobyTheDog123··on Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear
OP is saying that the policy of the luggage being held by the FAA is stupid, not that preventing people from taking their luggage in an emergency is stupid. The emergency is over: the plane landed. Everyone got off the plane. Give them back their luggage.

He’s saying that because of policies like those (the FAA holding the plane), people are going to want to take their bags in an emergency situation.

TobyTheDog123··on The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)
The reason for this (unjustified IMO) is bot/scraping prevention. On most VPNs you cannot browse profiles unless you're logged in.

TikTok has a much more elegant solution to this problem (while still being a nightmare for bots/scrapers), with ByteDacne moving bot checks to the client with a mixture of proof of work and fingerprinting.

TobyTheDog123··on Revolt: FOSS Discord Alternative
Different strokes for different folks.

And by "strokes" I mean use-cases, design preferences, integration needs, etc.

Personally I'd use RevoltChat if they offered SSO/SAML/OpenID support - I like the UX and the Discord-esque vibe as opposed to the Slack-esque vibe the alternatives you listed carry.

TobyTheDog123··on Mullvad Leta: A search engine used in the Mullvad Browser
I very much doubt many good actors left the service over it. I assume their popularity comes from a battle-tested no-logs claim, a good UI/UX, and a general consensus that they're trustworthy.
TobyTheDog123··on Show HN: Slint – A declarative UI toolkit for embedded and desktop
Oh it's certainly not for me, no question about it.

Yet, it's curious that you compare Slint to LVGL/Flutter/Electron (I don't know about Qt) when none of them have this intrusive requirement.

--- >What's intrusive about it?

(a) Display the AboutSlint widget in an "About" screen or dialog that is accessible from the top level menu of the Application.

(b) Display the Slint attribution badge on a public webpage, where the binaries of your Application can be downloaded from, in such a way that it can be easily found by any visitor to that page.

(c) You may not remove or alter any license notices (including copyright notices, disclaimers of warranty, or limitations of liability) contained within the source code form of the Software.

(d) You allow SixtyFPS to use your Application on the website and in advertising materials of SixtyFPS as a reference and to display your logo and trademark for this purpose.

---

Please don't pretend like a/b/d aren't big asks by saying "you wont even provide attribution?"

TobyTheDog123··on Show HN: Slint – A declarative UI toolkit for embedded and desktop
>Attribution to Slint

Mmmm no thanks, I'll pass.

While I'm looking for a Flutter alternative, this seems like a trap.

TobyTheDog123··on Spezless – A Reddit clone without u/Spez
Yeah that 48 hour limit really was a misstep.

There were a handful of times today I wanted to research something and hit the private wall, surprising me each time.

It showed me that if this protest was indefinite, it could have a real impact on the platform. Yet, on Wednesday all will be back to normal.

I'm also very skeptical of something like this - it's the Twitter effect: people will complain all they like, but at the end of the day - Twitter and Reddit are where people are and will remain. As for the Digg comparison, tolerance for corporate greed in the services we use has skyrocketed in the past 13 years, so I dont think it's an apt comparison.

TobyTheDog123··on Don't use custom CSS scrollbars
Not to be an asshole, but --- well, I guess I'll be an asshole.

This is good, thoroughly-researched advice with just enough condescension that I walked away from it kinda wanting to style my own CSS scrollbars.

Additionally, there's a comment on this post replying to someone with "You'll live" which really isn't helping the case presented in the article.

I won't, I don't have a good reason to, but I had a nice nostalgia trip to w3schools: https://www.w3schools.com/howto/howto_css_custom_scrollbar.a...

TobyTheDog123··on Addressing the community about changes to our API
Why is Spez so insistent on becoming public enemy #1? He's so obviously in the wrong here, yet is doubling, tripling, and quadrupling down on what is an obvious screw-up.

Frankly I think this might be a worse PR move than what Elon did when he did this with Twitter's API.

Is it someone in panic over a potential large impact on the IPO? I dont even think it would have that much of an effect if he hadn't gone on the platform to make the problem worse.

TobyTheDog123··on Apollo will close down on June 30th
Just imagine what'll happen when sideloading eventually makes its way to the US - the less-illegal sister of piracy, scraping, is going to make a huge resurgence.
TobyTheDog123··on Launch HN: Fastgen (YC W23) – Visual Low-Code Backend Builder
I got really excited for a second thinking this was infrastructure orchestration.

Like AI, I want my no-code tools to enhance my current setup, not replace it. If I could visually build CDNs that connect to APIs that connect to databases, with end-to-end type-safety, authentication, validation, etc etc etc built-in -- that's super compelling. But in terms of the trade-offs between a no-code logic tool like this (price, lock-in) and writing code, this doesn't really fit the bill.

I mean maybe the use-case here is prototyping and MVPs for non-technical founders? I don't know if tech companies would want to be locked into something like this though.

TobyTheDog123··on Apple Vision
>Skepticism is not doomerism— and in fact should be praised.

Assuming something is going to fail, like many are across Hacker News since the announcement dropped (perhaps not in this thread), is doomerism. There's a difference between that and expressing concern over Apple's claims.

>Their marketing demos looked just as compelling.

I could not disagree more. I could have not been less interested in Oculus nor Google Glass from their advertisements. But an AR experience (as opposed to VR) that integrates with my Mac and iPhone? It has my attention.

>why should we trust companies who’s best interest is not to give us the truth on what their product is but rather the best possible vision for what it will be

Because Apple has delivered high quality products the vast majority of the time (butterfly keyboards and App Store limitations notwithstanding). Why would we assume they're suddenly dropping the ball on this, when they're on stage calling it the future of computing?

> This might certainly be different, but until it’s proven that it is, why should people believe it?

It all comes down to the company producing it - Apple hasn't made a device like this before, and comparing Apple's products to Meta's and Google's is a terrible metric to go by. It's like eating gas station sushi, getting sick, then going to an upscale sushi bar, and saying "Ohhh I've had terrible experience with Sushi in the past"

Even if you aren't willing to give the benefit of the doubt to a company that consistently produces high quality products and building a brand new product line, express that very healthy skepticism by trying it out at an Apple Store before purchasing - at that price tag, I sure am.

TobyTheDog123··on Apple Vision
This is why I dont understand all the doomerism. If Apple is totally bullshitting here, we're going to find out extremely quickly, which will undoubtedly harm their reputation in the space when it comes to the next generations.

If they weren't confident it works almost as magically as its described, it would not have been shown.

TobyTheDog123··on Conservative Americans are building a parallel economy?
The issue is so many of these brands are labelling themselves as conservative and are therefore unpalatable to not only those on the left, but to those who lean towards the center or aren't politically minded.

If these companies began being subtle ("normal") about their policies, even if they're more conservative than the YouTubes or Metas of the world, the conservative parallel economy might gain some traction.

In addition, I've been under the impression that conservatives just can't do tech - the vast majority of people who create beautiful user experiences and interfaces fall on the left. Perhaps its an empathy thing (not to say conservatives aren't empathetic, but perhaps the left is overly-so). The one exception being, strangely, Truth Social, which I thought had a pretty good UI/UX given the space they occupy.

TobyTheDog123··on An open-source alternative to QuickBooks
Your take doesn't make sense at all to me.

It's an open source project - their customers are going to be small businesses with small teams of technical people to maintain it. I don't think they're competing with QuickBooks at all. Why is Discord not a viable method of communication for these users?

TobyTheDog123··on HBO Max new Captcha system
>HBO doesn’t want people doing this without paying.

But why (from their perspective)?

They don't make their money from metadata, they make it from content. Every piece of real monkey-making content is going to get a torrent regardless of if it's protected behind a captcha.

TobyTheDog123··on HBO Max new Captcha system
I was cracking up when it started playing the bagpipes.

I don't think its too much of an exaggeration to say this is what happens when security teams don't receive enough pushback from the higher ups or from other teams. I see this all the time in large big tech companies.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →