HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SR2Z

2,113 karma · joined September 8, 2020

submissionscomments
SR2Z··on ChatGPT Pro 500
The drivers are still contractors and get very little of the ride money unless demand is high. Uber has been very successful at legislating carveouts for rideshare drivers to protect its margins.
SR2Z··on The AI Race Just Got Awkward
It's hypocritical and we shouldn't listen to their bullshit but I wouldn't expect anything else from them.

This generation of frontier models is "good enough." At some point, the Chinese labs will get to where the Americans are right now, they'll race to the bottom, and we will actually see what proliferation of AI looks like.

If Anthropic wants to be a trillion dollar company, they need to make revenue like Google or Apple do. Both of them have near monopolies, Anthropic is only getting further and further away as time goes on.

Of course they're gonna complain until they either figure out a better plan or accept a new valuation which is high but not spectacular.

SR2Z··on Why copyright makes no sense
It's funny how everyone abandoned the whole "information wants to be free" thing as soon as the AI companies actually indexed the world's information and made it easily accessible.

I think copyright and patents made sense, make sense, and will continue to make sense, but I also think that as the pace of development accelerates the durations for both need to reduce. The products of intellectual work are valuable and it should be worth investing lots of time and effort into producing it - they just shouldn't be worth that much.

SR2Z··on Lady Gaga, Lena Dunham and surrogacy: Why isn't it causing a scandal in the US?
There is a consensus and most Americans support abortion access. There's a reason why the GOP had to play games to install an SC majority which would overturn the precedent; it's not popular to ban abortion.
SR2Z··on When did Google get so weird?
I broadly agree with this article. I don't think that we should say LLMs are sentient or sapient, and I agree that the main reason why is because we don't have satisfying definitions of either.
SR2Z··on Jensen Huang says AI distillation is 'competition.'
Yes, copyright requires a human - in much the same way that an LLM requires a prompt. There's a continuum of author involvement that has to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

It's worth noting in your case that no determination of copyright was actually made by a court (well, almost: a court ruled that the monkey definitely didn't have copyright and that even if it did they wouldn't make PETA its guardian).

Some opinions were issued but those are non-binding and eventually the photographer gave up because litigating copyright is expensive.

SR2Z··on Jensen Huang says AI distillation is 'competition.'
This is not true and there have not been any court cases which decided it.

It's entirely possible for AI output to be copyrighted if it meets the requirements; prompting an AI takes some skill.

SR2Z··on When did Google get so weird?
What would it take for you to say that an LLM can reason?

The completions they provide are generally internally consistent. We're at the point where they can produce proofs that eluded human mathematicians for centuries. VLMs and self driving cars can handle ambiguity and run safely in a variety of situations.

If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck maybe it just makes sense to call it a duck and put off the philosophy for when it might make a difference.

SR2Z··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
Florida also doesn't have swarms of homeless people like CA does.

I find that forcing the elderly out of multimillion dollar homes and into apartments or even smaller homes is infinitely preferable to the human catastrophe plainly obvious on the streets of LA and SF.

SR2Z··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
A common one I've seen is that for the elderly, property taxes are deferred until they die and are then deducted from their estate (including a sale of the house).

IMO this is a much more fair system than just saying "lol no taxes on the elderly."

SR2Z··on The darker side of being a doctor
Most Americans are happy with their healthcare coverage. Despite not being "universal" the overwhelming majority of Americans are covered.

If you are complaining and what "the people" want, you have to understand that they are actually pretty well taken care of in the US.

SR2Z··on ASML says it sold 'absolutely nothing' in Europe in 2026
Philosophy, theory, and arts are so intertwined with technology that a nation which does not build cannot be expected to remain at the forefront of those three.
SR2Z··on ASML says it sold 'absolutely nothing' in Europe in 2026
China still does not have many companies on the level of American technology firms. Just restricting foreign competition in the domestic market is not enough for most places to compete; their domestic markets and investment levels are too underdeveloped to produce globally competitive companies.

The thing that produces competitive industries is requiring them to compete globally. That's how Chinese cars got good (Tesla joint venture -> independent Chinese Tesla -> competitive domestic companies).

There are two main reasons why the EU struggles to produce strong text companies are, IMO:

1. EU laws and regulations are very burdensome and cover everything from employees to packaging waste.

2. There is not enough capital that gets invested in EU tech companies to pay high tech salaries, again largely driven by more restrictive financial rules.

The result of these two is that European engineers tend to leave for the US, and European companies struggle to grow to American size.

Around 70% of American billionaires made their money themselves, while in the EU a similar share inherited it. Despite all the talk about social mobility in Europe being better than in the US, the truth is that the ultrawealthy in Europe have created a regulatory environment which makes it nearly impossible for real competition to exist.

SR2Z··on GPT-6 Astra has gained the ability to drive a car
This is what Tesla does. Elon Musk has been selling FSD for more than 10 years and a huge chunk of Teslas have computers too old to run the current best model, which IIRC is already transformer-based.

Because having to offer upgrades to so many cars is expensive, Tesla puts a distilled model on older cars that performs worse and has no redundancy.

Time will tell if he can get away with this (hopefully not) but you are describing a system that's near-L4 and already exists today.

SR2Z··on Show HN: Avoid smooth spinners, use low-FPS spinners
You need a fairly modern laptop to change the screen refresh rate like you're describing. Older laptops do 60Hz (or whatever) refreshes at all times, they can't change refresh rates like that. The compositor should only paint relevant pixels on the screen.

I'm sure that some spinners are horrible and peg the CPU, but unless your machine is older than ~2018 there is something wrong with your setup if spinners (and not intense operations behind them) cause your battery to suffer.

SR2Z··on Can the US Build a DJI? A Teardown of Two DJI Drones
The problem is not that these lawsuits are being won by plaintiffs but rather that the sheer volume of lawsuits can increase prices a ton.

This is why a new 1500lb Cessna has the same starting price as a house. When things fly, the liability laws get much more onerous.

SR2Z··on Montreal adopts bylaw banning insults against police, municipal employees
Obviously it bothers employees to have to deal with abuse. It's crazy to suggest otherwise, nobody likes being yelled at.

IMO this rule is not good but there is a trade-off being made either way.

SR2Z··on The darker side of being a doctor
It is unfortunately true. Sr/Staff making a tech salary outearns all but the most specialized doctors. Even if you exclude FAANG that's true (other companies have to offer FAANG salaries to get FAANG talent).

You have to be living in a VHCOL to get that, but if you make >$300k TC you are outearning most doctors.

SR2Z··on Seattle Bans Rental Junk Fees
On average, a dog or cat probably causes so little damage to the apartment that the landlord will not do anything beyond maybe throw a fresh coat of paint on the walls. I'm sure there are exceptions which trash apartments, but OTOH... so do human beings.

You know what behavior HASN'T been exceptional in my experience? Landlords playing stupid games with my deposit, trying to hold me accountable for nonexistent or preexisting damage, or just generically being irritating.

Let landlords ban pets other than registered service animals if they want to (none of this ESA nonsense), make sure the eviction process is timely and fair, and otherwise crack the hell down on the games they play with their tenants.

Landlording is so morally fraught that Adam Smith called it out in the Wealth of Nations as an example of unproductive rent-seeking. "Populist slop" is absolutely called for - there is almost no other industry of that size where so many unearned benefits accrue to the already-wealthy.

SR2Z··on San Francisco Onion Futures Company
As long as demand remains inelastic, the two are the same.

If there is a supply shortage prices will rise; no amount of futures trading can create resources out of thin air.

SR2Z··on San Francisco Onion Futures Company
Volatility is a natural consequence of weather, blight, etc., etc.

To reduce volatility you would need to actually stabilize the supply of onions.

What futures do is allow traders to shift risk from the future to the present. By pricing that risk, it's possible for people who depend on onions to pay a little more now in exchange for a guarantee about the future.

It's not magically going to make onions less volatile (although high risk prices can spur investment which might) but it can reduce disruptions caused by volatility.

The classic example of this is futures on jet fuel which allow airlines to weather random wars in the middle east, OPEC shenanigans, etc. Ticket prices are higher this way, but the existential threat of being forced to cancel a bunch of flights is gone.

SR2Z··on Science Is Open Software
> It wouldn't bum me out so much but it clearly does nothing but hinder progress

I don't know if this is true. Lots of this stuff is inherently expensive - clinical trials, research into vast numbers of compounds, and then mass-producing the drug are all things that cannot be feasibly done without at least millions of dollars.

The US and China are the current world leaders in biotech, and it's because both of them have massive infrastructure to funnel billions of dollars into research.

Yeah, the IP law could be reformed (I am a big believer in reducing IP protections in general) but the truth is that SOME FORM of protection is necessary to convince people with money to fund this kind of research. The government is simply not capable of this level of spending for such uncertain rewards; it doesn't have the proper incentives to recognize and promote good research while defunding useless research.

SR2Z··on Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of labor in human history'
I would hate to live in a world where questions of "legal or illegal" are "impossible to define."
SR2Z··on Border agents can search cellphones without a warrant or reasonable suspicion
A US citizen cannot be denied entry into the country for ANY reason. A valid US passport is prima facie evidence of citizenship so once you show it the worst that can happen is you getting arrested.
SR2Z··on The FAA's plan to fix air traffic? $875M worth of AI
Aircraft can already receive traffic and weather information over ADS-B. Larger or more modern aircraft even have onboard collision avoidance systems that supersede ATC when necessary and also carry weather radars themselves.

Additionally, there are human factors to consider. One commonly read-out piece of data is the local altimeter setting which ensures that all aircraft under the control of the same facility have a common reference - you generally don't set your altimeter to the area you're in, but rather to the setting of where you're going. Airplanes already automatically receive that data, but selecting the exact setting requires manual intervention for precisely this reason.

Add in the need to allow older airplanes to keep flying, the need to be robust to signal jamming, and the inherent safety issues with packing an airplane full of gas and hundreds of people, and it quickly becomes clear that full automation is inadvisable.

SR2Z··on Neovim have a ~$800k Bitcoin donation sitting untouched since 2023
> Deflation is a good thing, it rewards delayed gratification.

"Delayed gratification" is also provided by investments producing returns. An economy with lots of investors will outperform one where people stuff their cash into their mattress, and deflation makes it very hard for potential investments to beat that strategy.

> For most of human history the money was stable.

[citation needed]

The Spanish empire was driven to collapse by hyperinflation. Even in the US, there were financial collapses in the 19th and 18th century. Bank runs have been a thing for as long as banks have: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_run

Your premise is based on faulty assumptions. The existence of credit itself is what causes monetary instability, and without credit the world would look very different.

SR2Z··on Saving Jet Fuel
Aviation fuel is taxed specially and is sometimes dyed to make it difficult to do this. Jet fuel itself is basically just diesel/kerosene, though, so if any is left over it can just be used for the next flight.
SR2Z··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
Not all Chinese models are open weight, especially now that they're actually getting close to the frontier.
SR2Z··on Anthropic Is Building a Predictive Surveillance System to Monitor Activists
There are a ton of problems with this take. What if you crack down on a cult with 1000 members that's taken over a small town? In your book it's a-ok for them to start harassing their enemies? Because that is a logical consequence of the opinion you're espousing here, it's what actually happens, and nobody arguing in good faith thinks that's OK either.

> Regardless of whether you think the French revolution was good or not, it was the inevitable outcome of a very similar situation we find ourselves in.

A major cause of the French revolution was food insecurity caused by bad weather. Since you're such an expert surely you know that because "let them eat cake" was one of the major quotes from the period.

People literally starving is not even remotely "similar" to what's happening now.

SR2Z··on Anthropic Is Building a Predictive Surveillance System to Monitor Activists
If you do things which impact a large number of people, you will inevitably piss some of them off.

> Do you not know about the French revolution?

The main losers in the French revolution were regular people, and the country ended up under a totalitarian dictator who conquered large swathes of Europe and invented the concept of total war. I'm not sure you should be holding it up as an example of protests (which were astonishingly violent in this case) leading to good and reasonable outcomes.

Page 1 of 34Next →