906 karma · joined February 11, 2021
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/633f0603fdaa7311ba384...
Here's the 2023 study:
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/633f0603fdaa7311ba384...
So really, I can get behind the author.
This is such a massive understatement. the relay is the single most important piece in the entire Bluesky stack.
Let me ask you this, is it possible for me to connect to a PDS directly, right now, via the bluesky app? or is this something that will be possible in the future?
>ATProto works like the web does. People publish information on their servers, and then relays crawl them and emit their crawl through a firehose.
>ActivityPub doesn't do large scale aggregated views of the activity.
So are relays really just an optimization or an integral part of how ATProtocol is supposed to work? ActivityPub doesn't require relays to function properly. This is why I say it's real federation. You can't truly be federated if you require centralization.
The core of the issue is, Bluesky's current model is unsustainable. The cost of running the main relay is going to keep rising. The barrier to discovery keeps getting higher and higher. It might cost 150$/month now to mirror the relay, but what's going to happen when it's 1000$?
That is good, but it's still a centralized source of truth.
>If you want large scale social networks, you need to work with a large scale of data. Since federated open queries aren’t feasible, you need big machines.
Thats just simply not true. ActivityPub does perfectly without the need of any bulky machine or node acting as a relay for the rest of the network. Every single ActivityPub service only ever interacts with other discovered services. Messages aren't broadcast through a central firehose, they're sent directly to who needs to receive them. This is a fundamental difference with how both protocols work. With ATProto you NEED to connect to some centralized relay that will broker your messages for you. With ActivityPub, there is no middle man, Instances just talk directly to each other. This is why ActivityPub has a discovery problem by the way, but it's just a symptom of real federation.
>and is how ActivityPub works by nature.
It's not. See Above.
>Jetstream is a streaming service that consumes an AT Proto com.atproto.sync.subscribeRepos stream and converts it into lightweight, friendly JSON.
So let me get this straight. if you did want to run Jetstream yourself you'd still need to be able to handle the 232 GB/day of bandwidth?
This always has been my issue with Bluesky/AT Protocol, For all the talk about their protocol being federated, It really doesn't seem realistic for anyone to run any of the infrastructure themselves. You're always going to be reliant on a big player that has the capital to keep everything running smoothly. At this point I don't really see how it's any different then being on any of the old centralized social media.
Imagine being able to create an accurate enough 3D rendering of any interior with just a bunch of snapshots anyone can take with their phone.
That's actually really funny to read. Just last night I was watching my brother cook and he asked Alexa to set a timer (It's pretty much the only thing he uses it for...) I jokingly said "You know, that's a really expensive timer."
If you're curious about Peertube. A friend and I have created an hosting service for fediverse applications. We provide fully managed hosting for Peertube which you can try free for 7 days. Check it out here https://fedihost.co
I can't help but find this extremely funny. you mean to tell me that massive operations trying to use your service didn't actually gain anything from using your service?
OpenAI wasting time and resources shutting them down and the bad actors wasting time and resources using chatGPT no benefit.
It just reads like a massive waste of time for everyone involved.
for those not in the loop, Vanguard is the anti-cheat Riot Games created for Valorant, their competitive first person shooter. The issue with Vanguard is that it's quite an aggressive anti-cheat, it runs on Ring 0 as a windows kernel driver. Hence, why some people call it a "rootkit".
Makes you wonder if the goal of their captcha system was ever really to stop people from botting.