HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Radix

618 karma · joined December 7, 2008

Hi :) I am at benjamin serrato at gmail.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=840652

submissionscomments
Radix··on Why most people don't like jazz
Most detractors don't want to know that this world exists and sure as hell don't want to have anything to do with it.

I just can't relate to it at all. It isn't so much that I don't want to hear it exists as I don't know how to believe it exists. To me it sounds like a culture self inflicting damage. I've looked a little for something I really like in hip-hop, but can't find anything I really like. Radio hip-hop causes me discomfort. I don't like t-pain (how I wish for the death of auto-tune). I can't listen to lyrical music without listening to the lyrics and I can't relate to hip-hop. (Actually I really like Lupe Fiasco, don't always relate, but with him it's okay.)

Also, ob-la-di-ob-la-da isn't non-sensical in the same way 'my sharona' is. It's a non-sense phrase that gives weight to the light hearted music and simple message of "life goes on" leaving the listener to imply the 'just keep going's and 'life is good's.

Radix··on Why most people don't like jazz
I'm not convinced. The melody sounds simple and repetitious, and the verses, mostly sung by tPain, are similar. The rest is just a fleshing out of these ideas, though, there is rythm and lyrics. I think you'll disagree with me, but I believe that's more because you disagree with me and the authors definitions of music than because I'm wrong.

Having said that, would you like to try to send me to some hip-hop I'll like. I've been looking, but when listening to music that has lyrics I have to listen to them, and I don't like these, or most rap for that matter. I've yet to find any particular artist I really like yet.

Jack White puts it well. On whether he does or does not particularly like hip-hop: "Not particularly. I find OutKast and Wu-Tang Clan interesting. But I consider music to be storytelling, melody and rhythm. A lot of hip-hop has broken music down. There are no instruments and no songwriting. So you're left with just storytelling and rhythm. And the storytelling can be so braggadocious, you're just left with rhythm. I don't find much emotion in that."

Radix··on Ayn Rand Mike Wallace Interview 1959
She really really did. I have read up to that last long (very long) speach by Atlas, which is plenty to note: most of the worst characters are business men. One of the most disfavorable characters in the entire book is Dagny's brother James, who unlike her grasps at the government for support.

Also, she anchors her book in America. Imagining how America could go wrong, but uses the socialism in Argentina and Mexico as a backdrop. She spends quite a lot of time giving examples of good selfish capitalism and bad selfish "capitalism"

Radix··on Poor Teen Sleeping Due To Lack Of Blue Light?
How much do you find effective? The standard dosage, or more? I should have been sleeping 6 hours ago.
Radix··on Newbie Fashion Tips for Grown-up Men
Thanks for filling out the casual side of the article. I like the Express example, I believe because it is pocketless and a solid color. It seems at the root of all this advice is the idea that clothes should fit so there are no folds, bends, or creases when standing straight, clothes should follow the shape of the body as much as possible, and pants at the natural waist.

The 1MX shirt is nice, and I've been convinced $40 is an acceptable price for a single shirt, and want two, but isn't this a bit much? Where is the room for the industrial Dickies and wallmart boots? The dickies are only baggy if they're purchased oversized, but they look okay with bulky footware if fit properly. And track jackets should be equivalent to hoodies.

Radix··on Newbie Fashion Tips for Grown-up Men
There were some comments on the blog asking about tucking in your shirt without a belt. I believe it's okay if you do not have belt loops. My brother has an old suit from the 80s which has no belt loops and as long as the shirt is tapered it looks good.

Of course you have to walk like you intended to wear a suit from the 80s.

Radix··on 5 million Dropboxes
I think you are missing a certain perspective that some of the commentators here are sharing. If you take Swombat's perspective as an entrepreneur that both greatly appreciates Dropbox as a utility, but also sees how it's ease of use makes the company potentially very lucrative and wants the same level of craftsmanship for his own company. Then these things blend to make and awesome product. Similarly, the ipod was awesome for those who love music.

I don't know Swombat, so I don't mean to misattribute thoughts to him, but I believe there is truth to the perspective I described. Also, I am not suggesting you "just don't get startups" or anything dumb like that.

Radix··on Bill Gates pledges $10bn for a 'decade of vaccine'
You've misunderstood Matt. When he says "This may increase productivity..." he means vaccines preventing disease will increase productivity, not that his mothers death will increase productivity. He assumes people will take care of their mothers and thus lower their productivity.

He's making the same point. This is why you will probably be down voted.

Radix··on Hacker defaces 49 congressional websites
True, but the word has been reclaimed more than I thought it would be when I first read some screed (ESR?) on the difference between the two. Remember the breathless news reports in the late 90s showing green on black websites of "hacker groups"? It's only natural that the word Hacker has these connotations since the first crackers were hackers. Now people talk about this or that hack without worrying that they'll be arrested or kicked out of school.
Radix··on [dead]
Probably since I've always understood it as a word play on phrase "grass roots", playing off of the fake astroturf grass used on American football fields.
Radix··on A new approach to China
That is a perfect quote. Please tell me who it is attributed to. I tried to give you a point, but failed.
Radix··on [dead]
+1

  *(a) Hmm, I think you're right.  And I share the general fear 
  this forum will become too general, and am not a fan of acrobatics 
  to define every post as 'for hackers'.  
  So I will delete this 
  posting.  I hope you've flagged it.
  (b) Age of content doesn't directly matter, so much as relevancy. 
  I believe this talk is still relevant... but not to HN.
  (c) I only saw it recently.
  (d) Maybe somewhat, I'd like to hear grellas thoughts on it.  It was 
  certainly entertaining.
edit: Ah, it was killed by the time I went to delete it.
Radix··on A new approach to China
On top of a profitable business in China, Google now has some ability to leverage some change in China. At the least, other corporations and governments will reconsider their relationships or expectations of China. Google had no influence before they opened google.cn, and as netcan pointed out, it wouldn't have been very useful to show sites not viewable through the Great Firewall anyway.

Business and an opportunity they didn't have before. Be charitable, this looks like a better outcome than had they stayed out of China altogether.

Radix··on Ask HN for comments: Popular math article: Sailing Hydrofoils
Is this related to your post from several months ago? I've been wondering what you would end up putting together, and watching for it.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=672067

Radix··on [dead]
Periodic hit on it when they said "the service men and women will be there fighting regardless of whether it was right or wrong because the cost of missing the right call is too high."

I believe those who hold that logic, myself included, have different expectations of the responsibilities of the soldier and the henchman. The soldier is in a strict hierarchical organization that demands its members follow orders for the organization to continue operating. Members lower in the organization are expected to begin working before they understand why, so they aren't held responsible for everything they do. The henchman may also be a part of an organization like that, but he is just another citizen, working for his organization and own betterment, and is expected to be responsible for his actions. Also, he can hardly say that his organization is working on behalf of his entire nation, as the soldier can.

edit: I should add, that this perspective does eventually reach a breaking point as time passes servicemen begin to see what the goals of their leaders are, and if they disagree with them then they may be obligated, morally or otherwise, to excuse themselves or switch sides.

Looking back at your comment I see that you're speaking of henchman and mob bosses only, but as a proxy for state leaders and the military. But my point is that people don't see them the same.

Radix··on Ask HN: Is it just me, or are HN comments becoming more and more negative?
I really liked your first comment. It appears you have a good point about the medical comment, that is, that comment would have been better with a more complete commentary. Now, this graph says more to me than the short paragraph you wrote, it also suggests that hn's comment quality is cyclical and it's just tmporarily in a downturn. There's an implication that the average quality is trending down, but it hasn't been long enough to know, so it isn't worth worrying about. It's just how it is.

Come christmas break some of the college kids will drop some ineresting academic stuff and things will look up.

Radix··on I Was Told I Was Very Smart
If she can see that what she looks like doesn't matter to you one iota, odds are she will not see any real value in any guy that mentions how pretty she is. You can't be swept off your feet by somebody calling you pretty when being pretty isn't how you define your worth.

Very well said. The next step is that she should see that attractiveness is not the most important trait to me (or her father). With this perspective, the thing to do is not to vaccinate her, but to praise her abilities and values so she never associates her worth with physical appearance. Thus, she can skip the whole trouble altogether.

So, this generalizes not to attractiveness, but what people tie their worth to.

Radix··on I Was Told I Was Very Smart
I realize you're in the big brother department and would like to protect her. But allow me to ask: would she be any less in need of your protection if she were [very]* plain-looking? or homely?*

No, but a helpful response might be more straightforward and wouldn't be helpful until well into adolescence.

You're probably right all around, but family isn't the only influence, and depending on the family, friends are a greater influence on a person. Junior high and high schools have weird social hierarchy that frequently stresses physical appearance. Some girls seem to have a need for male approval. I just want her feel no need for that. And there probably isn't anything I can do better than spending time with her. For some girls, with different families, I doubt this is the case.

And I absolutely agree that it is a risky proposition and probably not worth playing.

Radix··on I Was Told I Was Very Smart
Do you have a daughter? Since this article is still on the front page I would like to ask HN how does one deal with the similar issue of letting a young girl know she's pretty without suggesting it's of central importance? The problem is physical attractiveness is more inate than intelligence. I think the best course is to suggest innate attractivness is happy chance to be taken advantage of, generally it should be treated with indifference. I don't want my little sister to be swept off her feet by the first boy who gives her flowers, but you don't want her to ignore any advantages she may have. It may also be useful to point out how much attractivness depends on cultural assumptions of beauty.
Radix··on Applause For Finland: First Country To Make Broadband Access A Legal Right
Let me play devil's advocate for the difference between this and your other examples. The difference is that internet is infrastructure. It allows other systems to exist, and allows the government to require citizens to interact with it online. Thus it is most like a postal system, rather than instruments, or sports equipment.

Having said that, I agree with you, and taking into account my above thoughts, I still think it is out of place as I like the positive-negative rights theory.

Radix··on Ask HN: Please name two of your most favorite books.
To give an alternate opinion. You should read through the first dialogue and the following chapter, then decide for yourself. Maybe skip ahead a bit. I read half of it sitting in a library when I didn't really have time to read it, it presented ideas I hadn't thought before. I hadn't heard of figure and ground, at least not generalized, so I enjoyed noticing that my conversations jumped around the subject rather than being on the subject. I also hadn't heard about recursion before, so...

If the writing engages you then you and presents interesting ideas, to you, in a non-obvious way, then it is worth reading.

Radix··on Ask HN: Please name two of your most favorite books.
"Les Miserables", I hated Thenardier, Javert too until I learned to pity him... The book rambles a bit, but it's wonderful. In parts uplifting and crushing. I don't communicate well enough to express how much I think of it.

"Where the Red Fern Grows", I believe it was the first book of quality writing and compelling characters I read. A perfect book for a seven or eight year old boy.

Radix··on You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try to restrain yourself.
Somehow I hadn't noticed 'intensive purposes', so thanks. Recently I have found the use of 'practically' as a replacement for 'pretty much' irksome. We have plenty of words for that and no more to indicate 'for practical purposes'.

As others have pointed out: language is meant to be understood. It would be enough to always take the meaning from a speaker, except if we do that chronically, we begin to lose words. Which will make communication more difficult when you need those specialized meanings.

Bother.

Radix··on Reason as memetic immune disorder
Anyhow, I just wanted to point out that when I think back about my life so far, the part of it that scares me, was when I took my religion and decided that I had to take it seriously and do something.

I'm not sure you'll see this, but bringing this up should be fine now the thread has died.

Why do you feel that way about that time of your life? My experience has been exactly the opposite. When I was in high school I began questioning God. I attended a small church school with poor academics and being average and not knowing how to study in school I spent a good deal of time questioning the moral instruction I was given. (There were better reasons, caused a crisis regarding gods existence at 10. Fun.) The only difference is that I didn't accept that the reading the Bible was necessary. What bothered me most, and still does, was the apparent hypocrisy. Plenty of people in church, but none of them seemed to hold the traditional beliefs my family did. It was the little things, as well as boyfriend/girlfriend sort of things.

But, even now, after rejecting Christianity, I still have the greatest respect for those who really do believe. My grandfather who took his family to Argentina to teach college as a missionary and founded a chain of christian radio stations is probably the finest man I have ever met; my grandmother is similar. My ex-girlfriend spent last year teaching children in India. A sweetheart I wish I was with.

Due to my experiences I don't see why you were scared of the time when you sincerely followed your beliefs. To me this should be lauded, even, if I believe it is a false belief.

So, why do you feel that way?

Radix··on Experiment: No Comment Scores
That would only solve one of the problems. Some of the users here are skilled enough that the average user doesn't know enough to keep up a disagreement. It's easier if the user names stay.

For instance, the ggp is a security professional. I give more credence to his opinions than others.

Radix··on Found This Comment Discussionworthy - On Memes and HN's Future
I did too, and tried to get a discussion going again nine ours later, believing you had failed because of the time at posting, but no one upvoted mine either. It makes me think: worse than the constant discussion of the shape of HN is too much apathy to even discuss it.
Radix··on 4chan vs Scientology: really?
Which memes do you recognize as appearing on HN? The only one I can think of is Erlang references. I like the idea of labeling poor arguments against pg's disagreement hierarchy would make a useful meme, though I'm probably wrong and can't see it.

e.g. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=829337

Radix··on Study Gives High Marks To Retailers' Clinics
Great, thank you for that link. I look forward to listening to him during breakfast tomorrow.

I agree that concierge practices sound like a better approach, at least as a primary source for health care. It would be the same as insurance for the smaller things. Leaving insurance to cover larger things. As far as I can tell the worst of the problem is caused by insurances and the related need for medical billers. Another interesting group are the Ideal Medical Practice Doctors. They work with minimal staff and use cheaper technology so they can lower the cost per patient and spend more time with the patients. One doctor I have heard has zero staff.

Radix··on Study Gives High Marks To Retailers' Clinics
Walmart has a deal with RediClinic. The Walmart RediClinics are apparently using eClinicalWorks, the rest might be Athena Health. I expect these clinics use technology as much as possible. I don't think they can lower cost much more by using more, and if they did I expect any profits would be kept with no change in price.

http://ecwblog.blogspot.com/2008/02/walmart-rediclinic-eclin...

http://www.redorbit.com/news/health/1501613/rediclinic_to_le...

Radix··on How to Defend India
His comments read as very general to me, but the intro commenting on the trigger for his thoughts was good and it made a strong closing. His thoughts felt like they had been abstracted from any one specific case.

From you're perspective, maybe that's right. Maybe India is similar to where the US was before the civil rights movement. Ostensibly free for everybody, but not quite. Of course the civil rights movement couldn't come quickly enough and there are still problems today, so it is right that someone should love their culture and wish the flaws to be mended. As things continue maybe they will improve naturally. I don't know enough to feel sure, but it will be interesting. (Though I am not familiar with India and so my comparison is meant only very loosely.)

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →