HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

M2Ys4U

5,046 karma · joined June 2, 2013

submissionscomments
M2Ys4U··on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine
The GDPR is incredibly easy to read, what are you on about?
M2Ys4U··on You did this with an AI and you do not understand what you're doing here
>but there needs to be a human in the loop.

More than that - there needs to be a competent human in the loop.

M2Ys4U··on Are we decentralized yet?
Mastodon (the company) is building one: https://www.fediscovery.org/
M2Ys4U··on Are we decentralized yet?
They're against opt-out discovery, not discovery in general.
M2Ys4U··on Temporary suspension of acceptance of mail to the United States
Is he really concerned about it, or is he using concern about it as a political tool?
M2Ys4U··on Open hardware desktop 3D printing is dead?
Not just the third world. Plenty of first-world countries too.
M2Ys4U··on Can small AI models think as well as large ones?
Yes, but only because neither of them actually think.
M2Ys4U··on EU Eyes Ditching Microsoft Azure for France's OVHcloud
There are pros and cons to both approaches... and it's not a mutually-exclusive position.

Having some on-prem compute and some cloud compute is entirely viable.

M2Ys4U··on Start your own Internet Resiliency Club
In a word, no.
M2Ys4U··on Ask HN: Why does EU institutions and member gov. websites have cookie banners?
It's not about first vs third party, or tracking or non-tracking cookies, or adverts.

Any data storage on the end user's device (cookies, local storage etc.) that is not strictly necessary to provide the service requires consent. So even basic and (relatively) privacy-friendly analytics cookies are covered by this.

When the new ePrivacy regulation is finally adopted[0] the rules will be relaxed a little to allow things like analytics cookies to be used without consent.

This is the full text of the law:

"Member States shall ensure that the storing of information, or the gaining of access to information already stored, in the terminal equipment of a subscriber or user is only allowed on condition that the subscriber or user concerned has given his or her consent, having been provided with clear and comprehensive information, in accordance with Directive 95/46/EC,[1] inter alia, about the purposes of the processing. This shall not prevent any technical storage or access for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network, or as strictly necessary in order for the provider of an information society service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user to provide the service."

[0] it was originally going to be adopted in 2017/8 and come in to force a year or two later but that whole process has been a mess

[1] That's the Data Protection Directive, which has been repealed and replaced by the GDPR.

M2Ys4U··on Coventry Very Light Rail
Well it depends on where you're trying to go.

As a means to get to the airport from the city centre? Yeah, heavy rail is probably better.

But that's not the only reason for the line. It's used to get to and from other points on the route too.

M2Ys4U··on Coventry Very Light Rail
Manchester's Metrolink should also be used as a benchmark.

The Airport line extension cost £368m with 15 stops over 14.5km of track (which shakes out at roughly £25m/km), and was completed more than a year ahead of schedule and under budget.

M2Ys4U··on RedHat censored me on freedesktop.org – Xlibre fork release coming in few days
yup: https://www.theregister.com/2021/06/11/linus_torvalds_vaccin...
M2Ys4U··on Ancient law requires a bale of straw to hang from Charing Cross rail bridge
According to the Bank of England's inflation calculator, £80 in 1242 is worth £119,600 today.
M2Ys4U··on AWS European Sovereign Cloud
(2023)
M2Ys4U··on Apple's AI isn't a letdown. AI is the letdown
>Mastodon is a successful decentralized "web3" social media network.

No, that's not what "web3" means. Web3 is all about the blockchain (or you can call it "distributed ledger technology" if you want to distance it from cryptocurrency scams).

There's nothing blockchain-y about Mastodon or the ActivityPub protocol.

M2Ys4U··on EU looks to hit Big Tech in crackdown on US services exports
The EU's budget is about €190bn. Fines for Big Tech companies last year totalled €8bn.

So that's ~4%. It’s not insignificant, but I wouldn't exactly call it a primary revenue stream. VAT brings in 3x as much money. Import duties bring in about 5x that. And about half of the budget comes directly from the member states.

M2Ys4U··on Brotli Compression for the Web
(2015)
M2Ys4U··on Why the EU Is Failing
>If we look at the structural underpinnings of a stable Federal Republic, like the United States

lol, lmao.

M2Ys4U··on Ecosia is teaming up with Qwant to build a European search index
This isn't a civil law vs common law thing.

It's a US vs sensible countries thing.

M2Ys4U··on Ask HN: Dot EU domain instead of dot com?
Well if you're an EU/EEA citizen it doesn't matter where your address is, but if you're relying on the residency requirement as a non-EU/EEA citizen it might.
M2Ys4U··on Ask HN: Dot EU domain instead of dot com?
Bare in mind that in order to regiser a .eu domain you must be an EU citizen, resident in the EU or your organisation must be established in the EU. (or the EEA - Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway)

And yes, they will take away domains if you don't continue to meet the requirements - it happened to me (thanks, Brexit).

M2Ys4U··on The Iconic 3DBenchy Enters the Public Domain
>I'm actually very curious now what led you to the line of thinking that it isn't possible?

The public domain is the set of all works in which no copyright subsists. Copyright automatically subsists in a work from its creation until it expires. Copyright is a property right. All property must have an owner.

Therefore a work cannot enter the public domain unless the copyright subsisting in it has expired.

(This is from the perspective of the law of England and Wales, at least. Other jurisdictions have similar legal axioms that produce the same result, though)

M2Ys4U··on UK Online Safety Act may not be safe for bloggers
Section 12 would indicate otherwise.

Subsection (3):

>A duty to operate a service using proportionate systems and processes designed to—

>(a) prevent children of any age from encountering, by means of the service, primary priority content that is harmful to children

Pornography is included in "primary priority content".

Subsection (4) then goes on to say

>The duty set out in subsection (3)(a) requires a provider to use age verification or age estimation (or both) to prevent children of any age from encountering primary priority content that is harmful to children which the provider identifies on the service.

Subsection (5):

>That requirement applies to a provider in relation to a particular kind of primary priority content that is harmful to children in every case except where—

>(a)a term of service indicates (in whatever words) that the presence of that kind of primary priority content that is harmful to children is prohibited on the service, and

>(b)that policy applies in relation to all users of the service.

Or, on other words, if there is the possibility of people posting anything that can be considered pornographic, you must implement strong age verification.

And it's also not only targeted services. Yes, Section 12 says only applies to services "likely to be accessed by children", but if you read Ofcom's guidance that is incredibly, ridiculously broad.

To quote from their "Children's access assessments guidance":

>Even if your service does not actively target children or seeks to limit access to children below a certain minimum age, it may still be of a kind likely to attract a significant number of children.

And some examples of content types from that document that suggests you might attract a significant number of children:

* Art, music, singing, photography, videography, drawing, painting, cooking, drama and acting, crafts, creative writing, beauty and makeup and fashion.

* Content about future careers and finance.

* Content about wellness, health and fitness

* Content enabling the development of new skills.

* Informal political commentary

M2Ys4U··on UK Online Safety Act may not be safe for bloggers
The OSA goes way beyond CSAM detection. It also goes beyond report-and-takedown.

If there is the possibility of people posting anything that can be considered pornographic you must implement strong age verification. And you might have to do that age verification every time somebody logs in - though Ofcom won't say where that threshold is.

Ofcom themselves has said that it is "a huge amount of work to come into compliance" (direct quote from a webinar earlier in the week).

M2Ys4U··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
>Vance came from Venture Capital, not big tech.

There's a difference?

(I'm joking... but only half joking)

M2Ys4U··on Ask HN: Anyone else find LLM related posts causing them to lose interest in HN
And if this doesn't prove that valuations are bullshit, nothing will.
M2Ys4U··on Mastodon announces new European non-profit, change of CEO
>Given that single user instances are largely nonviable due to the abundance of blocking in the 'verse

Yeah, that's nonsense. I've been running my own single-user instance since 2018 and server blocks by other instance administrators have never caused any problems for my use of the Fediverse.

I also follow a bunch of other people who run their own and never see any comments suggesting it's a problem for them either.

M2Ys4U··on Mastodon announces new European non-profit, change of CEO
Well Rochko is stepping down as CEO as part of the restructuring, which is a fairly big development.
M2Ys4U··on OpenERV
No, it's not. Files are available under the CC BY-NC-SA licence which, because it does not allow commercial usage, is not open source.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →