HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ImAnAmateur

383 karma · joined May 24, 2023

I've learned about tech all my life primarily to understand the world at large. I don't work in the industry. Born in the 90s.
submissionscomments
ImAnAmateur··on Nearsightedness is at epidemic levels – and the problem begins in childhood
In all seriousness: Can you provide proof of that? Because nothing I've read on the subject is definitive about methods that prevent it.
ImAnAmateur··on The failure of the Domino's 30-minute delivery guarantee
This mirrors my experience in retail. Anything less than the top score is counted as a negative, often counting the 1-9 score as a 0 with the 10 as a 1. The heat lands on a local manager when corporate comes to town. What ends up happening is that the customer-facing employees train the customers to put down 10s.

It's ultimately a metric that's been gamified by everyone involved. I think the cynics keep it around because it gives customers a voice.

ImAnAmateur··on T-Mobile employees across the country receive cash offers to illegally swap SIMs
You're right about it not being a strawman. I used the wrong word.
ImAnAmateur··on US releases sealed Brazil orders to X, shedding light on account suspensions
Mind sharing the source on that report? Where was the link to it published?
ImAnAmateur··on This is a teenager
Do you remember the age ranges of those foster kids?
ImAnAmateur··on T-Mobile employees across the country receive cash offers to illegally swap SIMs
Talking about it being the "mark of the beast" is a strawman. What you should talk about instead to win support among those same groups of people is to explain how it isn't/wouldn't be a means of government abuse. They're worried about it backdooring personal financial freedom the same way you would worry about the government backdooring encryption.
ImAnAmateur··on T-Mobile employees across the country receive cash offers to illegally swap SIMs
The minnow security model is bad at protecting one fish, it's good at protecting 10000.

What would you say is an advantage unique to SMS that would be lost if text messages were switched to another model? I'm asking sincerely. There aren't many people arguing in favor of SMS here, so you seem like the right person to ask.

ImAnAmateur··on T-Mobile employees across the country receive cash offers to illegally swap SIMs
That is a very convincing argument for why SMS should be replaced entirely for everyone.
ImAnAmateur··on Government of the NIMBY, for the NIMBY, by the NIMBY
This is a huge useless strawman. Talk specifics and we can get somewhere. Talk specifics and we can begin to understand the problems with X in Y because Z. It sounds like the author is trying and failing to understand why some specific group of people he does not like do not agree with his ideals.

If there is some context I'm missing, then I wish the author had included it. I don't like having a conversation about guessing what the author is upset about.

ImAnAmateur··on Allegations of criminality by Boeing in deceased whistleblower complaint
It may be because it's an ongoing investigation. There's a big difference between "not now" and "never". If it's what you say it is, then it might be very definitive and graphic. Out of respect for the family they might choose not to.
ImAnAmateur··on I'm Begging the Courts to Stop Citing My Work on Bite Mark Identification
>The Nevada Supreme Court rejected all of those arguments, reasoning that Collman would likely have been convicted on other evidence. And they also again refused to specifically rule on the challenges to bite-mark identification, and to Rawson.

This, to me, seems to be the hurdle to clear. These cases are complex and have lots of evidence. The Nevada Supreme Court essentially said that the bite mark evidence in his case is not needed to convict him. The author of the article is seemingly only knowledgeable of the use of teeth "evidence".

I don't even know where to go from here. I'm from Arizona, not Nevada so I don't know their laws. I assume that the effort needed will involve going over this individual's court case, arguing the details in front of a court, traveling to the court, filing and responding to court documents... The whole 9 yards. The biggest hurdle is that freeing this man requires a lot of effort from another man. Who's going to go to bat for this man when maybe there's an easier way to free someone else?

The alternative solution is to campaign for Nevada to change their laws. Or perhaps shame/punish the court for this hypocrisy. The judges are surely accountable to someone else.

ImAnAmateur··on Why so many people in Hacker News do not use their real names?
Because it's the internet. Anyone in the world can see a post, decide to do something, and then try and seek me (or my family, job, etc) out. I grew up watching YouTubers struggle under the weight of popularity without the professional teams that celebrities employ. I've also seen a mob of thousands harass an individual for a few days because of something that was false. I'd like to be able to walk away from the computer for some peace if I get upset over something online.

I also like the ability to be wrong. I am serious about behaving appropriately so that I don't have to fear being revealed online, but there are some previous posts of mine (even here) that I feel embarassed about because they didn't come across right or I was wrong about something. If one person confronts me about that, I'll live with it. If the internet does, then what if I always have to defend myself because there's ten thousand plus people who ask?

Online, it's hard to have a one-on-one conversation. I may speak to one person, but anyone may reply. I'm sure one day the me online will be 1:1, but until then I like the peace and calm.

Here's the best metaphor I can think of on short notice: John moved to a new city recently and he was looking at the houses along his block. He noticed they all had something on their doors. Curious, he asks a neighbor, Alice, what it was for.

Alice replies, "When it rains."

John is confused. "We had a lovely sprinkle just yesterday." He says with an eyebrow raised. "I think you're too worried."

"No," Alice shakes her head. "When it pours. The water can reach up to your waist."

ImAnAmateur··on The U.S. just sold its helium stockpile
So where is the problem? The rate of the mining? The efficiency? I would assume that helium baloons wouldn't be the culprit in a shortage because they'll be the first to go in a shortage. I assumed it was because the money made from helium baloons is responsible for higher rates of helium mining.

I'm genuinely not going to know what you think the actual problem is if you don't tell me. I promise I tried looking it up before responding.

Edit: I hadn't thought about purity requirements. Helium baloons do require significantly lower purity than medical uses. So how that lower grade stuff is treated as a whole is the part to consider, rather than helium baloon revenue.

ImAnAmateur··on The U.S. just sold its helium stockpile
It's up to those of us living today to decide to make the common rising baloon extinct. It's going to happen one day regardless. If we do it sooner, we get to use helium for medicine longer.

I'm in favor, though sad, of a government ban. It should probably happen slowly so that no one's job is to empty canisters into the open air. Opinions?

ImAnAmateur··on What are elliptic curve pairings?
Pictures or demonstrations would make this easier to digest.
ImAnAmateur··on Elites Cause Crime by Acing Marshmallow Tests
This was an extremely long read. If I had the energy and time to discuss it then it would make for great conversation.

I suppose there is one thing I want to say the most. It's not often that I read something that makes me reflect back on the lens of Christianity that I view the world through. There are two points that this article raises about widely practiced Christianity that tap on that glass rather well.

The first is "the monkey dance" and what my response should be. There is no computer logic for this-- something I only say for the computer-minded. I am expected to make the best judgement call as I see it, then to reflect on if what I did was right, then make another judgement call. Here is a short list of Christian teachings that crossed my mind: Turn the other cheek, offer your shirt if they take your jacket; Jesus had his deciples buy swords, but later tells them not to live by the sword lest they die by the sword; do not act out in anger; the tongue can be a whip, can kill, and spew evil, but can also heal and lift up; the strongman wins until a greater strongman comes along and binds him; give to Ceasar what is Ceasar's, and to god what is god's; god does not need to be in power to do his will.

The other is this idea of being superior and more self-righteous by not taking revenge. That's not in the Bible. That's looking down on others in contempt and allowing fellow citizens to experience harm out of a desire to let the unjust be unjust. The law is for the lawless! There are many ways to strike a balance when it comes to how a place is policed. Countries all over the world do it differently and there are pros and cons. California has the money to do a better job is my opinion. It's a hard question to solve and I won't discuss it further without keeping the conversation to specifics. God looks at the heart. If the "right thing" is done for the wrong reasons then that is something the Christian is directly asked to confront within themselves. I'm reminded of two Christian pieces specifically: God loves a cheerful giver; & The people honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me.

I hope this adds to the discussion. I won't take offense to an athiest retort.

ImAnAmateur··on Bottled water contains 100x more plastic nanoparticles than previously thought
If you don't like that philosophical abstraction then let me phrase it another way: "How much of our cancer rates and fetal anomalies are a natural result of our genes, and how much are they a result of things we humans have done to our environment?"
ImAnAmateur··on Valve asked Portal 64 developer to take the project down
Take the project down... from Steam. After the Dolphin Emulator situation this seems like a completely expected result. The HN title should be fixed.
ImAnAmateur··on Bottled water contains 100x more plastic nanoparticles than previously thought
And this is in addition to the regular known risk of plastic leeching into water over time as the water bottle breaks down or hot/freezing temperatures that can also cause the water bottle to break down.

I spoke to a 70 year old co-worker yesterday. They talked about a time when plastic wasn't used anywhere beyond Saran Wrap. How much of our modern plastic use is youthful folly? I grew up with it being normal so I didn't question it. Changing away from it would be abnormal! I suspect there will be a sharp turn away from plastics in several years, but I can't really fathom what that will be to instead. Paper? Metals? Wax? Glass?

ImAnAmateur··on iPhone that fell from hole in Alaska 737 MAX flight is found, still open to Mail
The person who found it said in a Tiktok video linked in the Twitter replies below that the phone didn't have a lock on it so he opened it up to that mail page.

I'm not gonna quibble about him changing his story, but it's notable.

ImAnAmateur··on How Japan Airlines crew led 367 passengers to safety from a burning plane
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroflot_Flight_1492

https://www.flightglobal.com/analysis/analysis-superjet-fire...

Made for interesting reading. I think that it's possible that one more life could have been saved without those carry-on bags. That's a responsibility the passangers and crew both share.

ImAnAmateur··on FTC Continues to Wade into Copyright Issues in AI Without Understanding Anything
The angry tone is making the details harder to grasp. The first thing the article does is point to an older article about a previous FTC statement. In it, TechDirt seems to disagree about what fair use is and then uses that disagreement to say that the FTC is saying that fair use itself is bad.

Am I reading this right? That posturing is frustrating.

Still... The argument that developing these tools under the assumption that publicly available data is fair use is what allows upstarts to develop LLM AI tools instead of giant companies is very astute. I think it's 100% correct. It makes me understand why LLMs are a battleground for copyright reform.

I appreciate that the article makes the stance of both sides understandable. It's enough to make me begrudgingly say that I'm glad for having read it.

ImAnAmateur··on Almost half of British teens feel addicted to social media – study
> “Social media research has largely assumed that [so-called] social media addiction is going to follow the same framework as drug addiction,” said Turner. Orben’s team and others argue that this is likely to be oversimplistic and are investigating whether the teenagers cluster into groups whose behaviour can be predicted by other personality traits.

> It could be that, for some, their relationship is akin to a behavioural addiction, but for others their use could be driven by compulsive checking, others may be relying on it to cope with negative life experiences, and others may simply be responding to negative social perceptions about “wasting time” on social media.

Finally! I feel less smart for not having thought of this myself!

I was unable to meaningfully change my own phone habits (despite serious effort and roadblocks) until it clicked that I was coping for something. What that was and what I was doing to cope highlighted parts of my life like nothing else. Instead of simply abstaining from using my phone, I put time into activities that benefited the withered branches of my life. Old habits still die hard, but knowing that I'm coping as I'm coping helped me separate the good social media use from the bad.

ImAnAmateur··on Farmland practices are driving bird population decline across Europe (2023)
Three of the 51 authors are from Poland. There are breakdowns by country and also comparisons of forest cover, urbanization, and temperature. There's a button that lets you look at the pictures if you want an easy country overview.
ImAnAmateur··on In L.A., a new vision of incarceration proves rehabilitation works
Good eye. Missed that. I immediately want to question why it mentions the first year only when, I believe, that it's been running for at least over six years.

Even if all the statistics are put in front of us, interpreting them might require understanding the distribution of the types of crime they were imprisoned for or other factors local to that city, county, or state.

Perhaps after the first year there are other factors that the graduates struggle with that push them towards prison again? Could be as simple as losing hope. I'd expect it to be bad influences in their daily lives or becoming homeless after failing without a safety net.

ImAnAmateur··on Nobel laureate Yunus sentenced to jail in Bangladesh
This is very light on details for those who know nothing about it.
ImAnAmateur··on In L.A., a new vision of incarceration proves rehabilitation works
This article has a strange tone. It fails to prove anything by the end other than that X amount of people graduate the program without stating what amount of people enter. What the program is doing sounds like it has helped, but the article's argument leaves itself wide (Wide!) open to anyone wanting to say that it doesn't actually work.

What's missing is an interview with someone who has graduated the program and the long-term statistics for all people who enter the program.

> “When they get a job, we ask them simple questions. ‘Hey, how’s it going?’ And they’re just like, ‘Oh, my gosh, do we actually care?’ They are so surprised that we’re asking,” she said.

> But it has to be authentic. If Mrs. C and her partner, Michael Contreras, were just playing a role, he said, the incarcerated men would “read right through everything.”

> “They’re going pick out who really wants them to change and who’s just here for a paycheck,” he said.

There's no substitute for someone genuinely caring, or genuinely trying to care, for someone else. :)

ImAnAmateur··on Generative AI flooding online crocheting spaces with unrealistic amigurumi pics
> There was this poor lady on a board who crocheted this damn homunculus when it was supposed to be this elaborate picture and she just got totally scammed! Waste of material and time and money!

I would love to see this. Both the instructions and the outcome. I have no clue what it would-- could!-- look like.

ImAnAmateur··on Japan's 18-year-olds at record-low 1.06 million
That critical mass may be online now. And the internet is so silo'd that it may not form or may not be noticed.
ImAnAmateur··on Japan's 18-year-olds at record-low 1.06 million
I don't see it, in the United States, as being that severe. The housing and economic squeeze is going to change the locations that people live and may change the ways in which people live together, but I don't expect it to become a wound so long as the corrective curve is round. I expect new laws which are likely to act as a pressure valve towards this issue.

If something cannot continue forever, then it won't. Population decrease may be inevitable and if so then handling it with less panic is smart.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →