Comment by kabdib | Hacker News Reader

Comment by kabdib | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Microsoft used to make some really good keyboards. But about 8 years ago they started making junk. The last MS keyboard I could actually type on was the Wireless Multimedia one (now discontinued).

Keyboards in the last few years have had:

- Mushy key feel. I can't tell when I've actually done a keystroke.

- Keys that are hard to strike (need to press on them just right, or they hang up or don't register). This is particularly bad on the wider keys.

- Keytops too close together; I mash multiple keys.

- Embarrassingly bad features: Function-key lock is the classic one here. Let's not talk about the 'diamond' arrow keys that have occasionally appeared.

I'd buy half a dozen "Natural" keyboards with decent Cherry hardware running the show, ESC in the right spot, and no wacky features. I don't even need a numeric keypad. I'd pay more money for some remapping (though just about any 20 cent microcontroller will have enough EEPROM to do this).

Whaddya say, Microsoft? Care to make a good keyboard again?

If you like laptop style chicklet keys (you may not), Microsoft's new sculpt ergonomic keyboard is pretty nice. I replaced my natural 4000 with it recently and found it much nicer on the mushiness scale. It's pleasantly clicky, but not cherry clicky. It even fits in a bag much better due to the detached numeric keypad. The mouse seems a lot better than the one that came with the 4000, enough for me to overlook the lack of extra buttons compared to my logitech G500. My one gripe is the positioning of the period key seems just a little off, something that has taken a few months to get used to hitting without miskeying.

Edit: incidentally, this keyboard, despite being fairly new, only gets 5 or 6 keys on the rollover test at the top of the article

I see this comment quite a bit, with regard to not being able to detect a keystroke, and I honestly don't understand it.

For one, I type far too quickly for auditory feedback to be of any meaningful use. Second, a combination muscle memory and spring feedback usually catch situations where I've missed a key (I can feel that I hit it too lightly). Third, I find some of the mechanical keyboards to be too stiff and require more force to fully press each key, leaving my arms more fatigued at the end of the day.

I suppose it's individual preference, but the soft clicking I get from my laptop or Microsoft ergo keyboard (low-travel laptop style keys) are more than enough for me.

To add to your list of keyboard gripes though:

- Keys with sloped sides (an extension of "keytops too close together") that cause me to hit adjacent keys when I slightly miss

- "Fn" and Ctrl keys swapped. I was working with keyboard in a seldom-used office yesterday that caused me to repeatedly clear lines when I meant to hit Ctrl+C. I will be replacing that hunk o' junk.

- Absolutely no separation between Function keys and numeric keys.

Makes me want to bust out my Northgate keyboard w fn keys on the left and top, two full keypads, Reboot button and detachable coil cable. Weighs almost as much as an IBM kbd.

Why make good stuff when you can over-engineer and over-sell garbage?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com