Hacker News Reader

Comment by ipython | Hacker News Reader

also, yet another reason I don't trust (and don't use) any ISP provided equipment. Remote administration from my ISP? No thank you.

View on HN

I get the perspective, but I also like the fact that ISPs do take over some of the admin burden associated with running a piece of equipment like a router.

You, I and most of the HN crowd may be well capable of maintaining a reasonably secure state of our own hardware and troubleshoot our way through common errors. However, the average internet user isn’t that experienced nor are most people interested in learning those skills.

I have a feeling the OP ... has the skills to manage his router :)

but point well taken in general.

Even if you buy your own modem they can push firmware to it (and do). The config file your modem downloads includes a cert that allows the isp to do this. You can flash special firmware (used to be called force ware) to prohibit this.

Is it safe enough to buy a separate router and put the ISP modem on the "internet" side of it?

It depends. The tr069 managed devices are typically router wifi combo type devices. If you can get a dumb modem that would would likely remove any tr069 vulnerabilities.

The firmware on whatever is doing docsis is going to be updatable by the ISP generally.

Two different mechanisms. The tr069 management and snmp triggered firmware upgrade

I think the attack described in the article is still possible in this setting, where the modem is in the middle of your unencrypted http traffic. This is true of any equipment belonging to the isp

However, I would assume no unencrypted traffic is safe anyway, and the modem would indeed not have access to your internal network.

You're assuming DOCSIS. I'm on FTTP, where the demarcation point is a cat5 cable to my equipment. Granted, there could be chicanery on the optical terminal, but that still doesn't provide my ISP visibility into my internal network.

How about putting the ISP supplied modem in a DMZ? Then the ISP could admin it all they want but still never touch the LAN.

That's pretty much the way to go. Keep the ISP modem, but connect it to your own router/firewall and connect your devices to your hardware and not the ISP modem.

So open it up to anyone? DMZ is an open target, not what you want to be doing.

It’s more about protecting your network against a potentially malicious device rather than protecting the device from attackers on the Internet. From that position, placing the isp device on a “DMZ” aka outside your own router/firewall, makes perfect sense.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com