What idea to pursue really is the smallest problem. If you haven't passed that hurdle, don't even think about going all-in. Going all-in, doing what?
Ideas are cheap. It's implementation that matters. And marketing that.
So: come up with idea / market niche / potential product first. Then decide whether to pursue that, and/or start business while doing so.
> I do not have any niche skills, I’m your typical run-of-the-mill backend developer with no particular expertise.
That's not true. You're underestimating yourself.
Every person has unique experience, skill set & personality. As someone said: "every person you talk to, knows something that you don't". But the reverse is also true: you know some things (or have a specific combination of skills, or an idea / vision) that nobody else does. Even if ever-so-slightly different from one of your peers. Or may be in a unique position to take an idea & make it go places.
"Do only, what only you can do".
I think that was Edsger G. Dijkstra quote? You seem at least to have the means to do so.
P.S. Maybe you just need a change of scenery, to come up with fresh ideas? (vacation, hop jobs, move house, dive into unexplored online communities, start a new hobby, ..)
My thread is exactly about how to do this first step :-)
> Maybe you just need a change of scenery, to come up with fresh ideas? (vacation, hop jobs, move house, dive into unexplored online communities, start a new hobby, ..)
I have done all those things over the years, and I never had an idea come out of it. Perhaps there is something wrong with me, where I am just good at being a corporate cog.
* Bill Aulet, Disciplined entrepreneurship, 24 steps to a successful startup
* Bill Aulet, Disciplined Entrepreneurship Workbook