Hacker News Reader

Comment by gambiting | Hacker News Reader

I mean, yes - but authorities realized very quickly how bad Chernobyl is, and started cleanup operations immediately. International knowledge of the incident had nothing to do with the starting the procedures. It's quite clear from Legasov's tapes that at least in the early days, Soviet Union and its leadership was genuienly interested in containment and cleanup.

So yes, I'm also interested in the same question as op - why has Chelabynsk-40 not caused the same reaction? Was it because it was a military installation?

View on HN

That is propably the worst factual error in the otherwise brilliant series about Chernobyl. The series made it look like the Soviets woupdn't uave done anything without international preasure. Truth is, Prypyat was evacuated before anyone in the West was aware what happened.

> The series made it look like the Soviets woupdn't uave done anything without international preasure

How else you show what Russkies - bad?

As I said, it is the one of the very few things the series kind of got wrong. It was unneeded, sure, but overall it showed everyone who helped the clean up in a "good" way. E.g. by having them speak without an accent to show they are Russian. Or by showing the efgort of the Liquidators on the ground. I can live with some dramatization, it is after all entertainment.

TIL, Wikipedia confirms this.

If you are interested, you can read the IAEA (?) incident report and the translation of the latest, not hiding anything, report from Soviet authorities. Both are available online, and both should be mandatory reading in any engineering studies. For both, how to investigate incidents and what to learn from incidents / how incidents can happen.

Because the final Soviet report (the series over dramatized in the last episode) is really good. For added fun, read the official incident reports on the 737 Max and compare both. Because the parallels are staggering.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com