Hacker News Reader

True in broad, general sense.

But basically off the page as regards to the specific UX patterns under discussion in this thread.

The UX pattern I'm talking about it the one at the top of this comment thread.

This one:

"when someone tried to leave the site, bring up a popup to offer them a deal or otherwise encourage them not to leave"

Right - which is an extremely narrow subset of "changing your offer during the course of a negotiation". Meanwhile it has other intent-blocking attributes for which the "deceitful" label quite justly applies.

In other words: in the Venn diagram of the two buckets - the measure of overlap is quite small.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com