Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by ranger_danger | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

ranger_danger·

Why would they have to comply anyway if they have no presence in the EU?

View on HN

EU citizen might register in which case they could be forced to comply or suffer fines

Fines enforced by who? They are not EU citizens or corporations.

The EU of course, there are international agreements, frameworks and even extraditions for such scenarios.If the US can extradite Ukrainians for hosting a torrent tracker, surely the US would extradite people refusing to follow EU law and violate user privacy and consent (joking of course, that would never happen).

So you're saying people can be punished simply for ONLY following their own country's rules for a website hosted solely within that country? Can you cite any precedent for this especially in the US?

No website is "hosted solely in a country" by default. When your website is available to the world, apparently according to the US, you're liable under any jurisdiction out there:

https://www.theverge.com/2016/7/20/12243592/kickass-torrents...

That's why there are so many shitty american middle-of-nowhere Daily Star Gazettes that block EU visitors with a laughable "our EU visitors are important for us". It seems that they agree with GDPR that it covers them if they serve anything to EU citizens.

Any self-respecting nation would ignore treaties requiring them to enforce the laws of foreign nations on citizens who never leave their soil.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com