Hacker News Reader

Comment by user5994461 | Hacker News Reader

COVID and Brexit have drastically reduced the amount of commuters, for the foreseeable decades.

Don't be surprised that $20B transportation projects are being reconsidered.

The best capital improvements are the ones that you can obviate away through cheap behavioral or societal adjustments (just as the best line of code is the one you can remove or didn’t have to write).

These words aren't necessarily wrong, but quite irrelevant here, since Brexit can be called many things but 'cheap' isn't one of them.

Was more directed at COVID pushing remote work, negating the need to shuffle bodies around via public transit to do knowledge work. I agree Brexit has been an expensive, unnecessary shit show.

COVID has not been cheap either - it has cost hundreds of billions [0]. You could fund twenty crossrails for this amount of money.

[0]: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/mar/22/a-year-of-c...

Brexit was a choice, while the fiscal, monetary, and societal response to COVID was necessary and unavoidable.

I disagree that it was unavoidable. I said to my family in February that the UK should stop all - absolutely all - flights into the country. The cost of this would have been miniscule compared to what ended up happening.

(Not just flights - everything except essential goods including via trains, ships and lorries. Certainly all people should have been disallowed entry.)

Ah, makes sense. My bad.

Although I do believe there is a great future for public transit in coordination with lighter ‘last mile’ solutions simply because cars are way too bulky for cities.

No worries at all. I agree that in most of Europe, cars are to be avoided considering density and robust existing connectivity. With that said, it makes sense to consider the New Future when making capex plans.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com