It’s not the ISP’s responsibility to ensure the customers’ have adequate HA designs for their own systems.
I await the results of all the inquiries into this to find out what took place here.
Edit: Oh and "But $ISP doesn't offer traditional phone service, they sell VoIP", is as of 2005 no longer a valid excuse for non-compliance: https://www.fcc.gov/document/commission-requires-interconnec...