HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zehaeva

482 karma · joined March 19, 2019

submissionscomments
zehaeva··on Nick Cave on ChatGPT and the creative process
If AI generated art, stablediffustion, midjourney, et. al., isn't copyrightable[0] then wouldn't anything generated by ChatGPT not be copyrightable?

Would that not mean that record label can ignore him when asking to be paid for songwriting royalties? Seems like a recipe to make yourself penniless.

[0] https://builtin.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-copyright

zehaeva··on The gamification of reading is changing how we approach books
I know it's weird, but go to your local library. Walk the stacks of a subjects/section that appeals to you and then just pick books up and check them out a little, maybe even take one home!

Slight snark aside, I think you have the the idea right, to go for the person, human, connection.

zehaeva··on Modern action films fetishize the body even as they desexualize it (2021)
Sure, there are widely accepted traits that are associated with attractiveness. Where did I say that is not the case?

Where did I call anyone with a perspective I disagree with an incel?

I literally said that this reads like something that one would find in an incel forum, and compared the idea that specific measurements of the human body being deterministic of their behavior with debunked science of Phrenology.

I think you're reading too much into my perspective and what I agree, or disagree, with.

zehaeva··on Modern action films fetishize the body even as they desexualize it (2021)
This reads like something from an incel forum. Shoulder to Hip Ratios? Are we going to start feeling the bumps on people skulls again?
zehaeva··on Former intel officer says 'non-human biologics’ found at alleged UFO crash sites
You mean our nuclear weapons where the secrets were leaked[0] to other governments repeatedly? Those secrets? The secrets that we executed both of the Rosenbergs over?

No our government has not demonstrated their ability to keep secrets over the span of a few years, let alone decades.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_spies

zehaeva··on Age of universe at 26.7B years, nearly twice as old as previously believed
That is an awful lot of "mights" and "maybes" stacked on top of an extension hypothesis of an hypothesis
zehaeva··on Who cares about the Ivy League?
He certainly was brilliant. But compared to his contemporaries he died really young, at age 32.

He did also go to school and even tried to go to college, he even got a scholarship! He had a lot of issues with the non math coursework however and did not finish any degree that I am aware of.

The reality of his life is a bit more complex than "oh a poor boy found a basic math text book and taught himself to be one of the greatest mathematicians in history"

What is more interesting here is to imagine if he grew up with wealth and formal training, would he have died at 32? Would he been given the time and resources to actually become one of the greatest math geniuses out there?

Ramanujan had a lot of raw talent, but it wasn't honed, and ultimately it was cut extremely short and wasted.

zehaeva··on It's weird that people get mocked for changing their minds
It'd be easier to take moral panics even a little bit seriously if one actually turned out to be true.

Has there ever been a moral panic that turned out to be true? The closest I can think of is maybe the teetotaler/prohibition movement. Alcohol truly does cause a great deal of harm to society.

Not having been alive in the late 1800s and early 1900s I can't speak to if it was really viewed as a moral panic similar to the Satanic Panic of the 1980s that I got to experience.

zehaeva··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
Strangely that's not what Finland[0] has found to be the case. By using a housing first approach they've been able to severely decrease the number of homeless people.

You are absolutely correct that other interdictions are needed as well.

[0]https://world-habitat.org/news/our-blog/helsinki-is-still-le...

zehaeva··on Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has been lost
I'm sure all of those VHS tapes are still perfectly viewable today!
zehaeva··on If we lose the Internet Archive, we’re screwed
One would think that this should be in the hands of our elected officials, however historically they have been more sympathetic to the idea that we need longer and stronger copyright than weaker.

To speak to why we need this sort of thing I would have to harken back to a fun talk that Paul Heald gave back in 2012[0] where he showed this fantastic chart[1] that shows the number of titles for sale on amazon by publish year.

The only thing I can assume from the chart is that either the publishing industry in the mid 1900s suddenly found itself publishing the same amount of books as they did in the 1830, no one cares about the books written between 1920 and 1990, or copyright has caused the loss of an enormous amount culture. According to the chart, and the talk, there are 7 times as many books published in the 1910s than are available from 1930s-1950s.

[0]: https://youtu.be/-DpfZcftI00 [1]: https://cdn.theatlantic.com/media/mt/science/Amazon%20pub%20...

zehaeva··on The Waluigi Effect
I know I am in the minority out there but when I do math, calculus, diff eq, whatever, the answer just comes to me. There's no internal dialogue, the answer just, for the lack of a better phrase, rises from the deep and is known to me.

When I am in an discussion I will look up and off the my left when I am thinking, but no words are happening in my "inner dialogue", it's just nothing and then I start speaking whatever I paused for.

Similar things happen to me while I am programming at work, I stare at the problem and the answer just comes.

zehaeva··on The Offshore Networks of Oligarchs
What's entertaining about this line of thought, that corporations will only treat your data without care and you really need to worry about the government because they'll kill you is that there is a long history in the US of corporations straight up murdering people.

And I'm not even talking "accidentally", or though neglect. I'm thinking of the union busting efforts of the railroad and mining companies in the late 1800s and early 1900s where the corporations straight up murdered folks.

zehaeva··on Earth’s innermost layer is a 644 kilometer wide ball of iron, new study finds
This is a confusion between the gravitational force that the core feels from the layers above, and the pressure that the layers above push down onto the core.

That is, the core doesn't feel gravitational pull towards the outside, because it's balanced on that other side, but the outside is being pulling in towards the core, which pushes on the core.

It might be easier to simplify the mental image by picturing just a slice of the whole thing.

zehaeva··on AI chatbots are having their “tulip mania” moment
It can explain things, but it gets a ton of things wrong, very wrong.

Using this is college would be a recipe for disaster, you'd ask chatgpt to explain a thing to you and you, being a student, don't know if it's getting the explanation correct or wrong. You don't know if it's reasoning is correct.

ChatGPT isn't telling you the truth or how the world is, it's just spitting out the statistically more likely next word.

It's far enough on this side of the uncanny valley so you think it's a conscious human unless you know enough about the subject to realize that it's not.

zehaeva··on Fewer than 40% of New Yorkers earn a living wage
The fun part of your example is that the top line numbers they talk about are for NYS, not for NYC.

In fact they call out NYC for having

  Manhattan boasts the state’s highest percentage of residents – more than 80% – earning a living wage.
Which seems to not line up with your assessment
zehaeva··on Did insurance fire brigades let uninsured buildings burn?
This actually hasn't always been the case.

In fact Hospitals were not required to treat you until 1986, which was part of the COBRA act.

Prior to that there was a large practice of "Patient Dumping" where a hospital would kick you out if they found out they you couldn't pay for your treatment. Hospitals in the US would literally let you die out side the ER doors.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Medical_Treatment_an...

zehaeva··on Mom handcuffed, jailed for 8-year-old son walking half a mile
Maybe we should remind everyone about this when they cry about cashless bail.
zehaeva··on Show HN: Get conversational practice in over 20 languages by talking to an AI
Maybe, but it's something that I've observed while teaching, and learning, anything that requires another human's time and effort.

People don't want to bother someone else when their problem seems "elementary" or too low on the "beginner level".

I've observed the same when tutoring others in math, programming, or physics. Even though we have an existing relationship where I will help them work through school work people tend to be very anxious about asking for that help.

I've seen it with new coworkers who spend waaaay too much time trying to figure something out by themselves when they could have just walked over and just asked for the answer.

"I didn't want to bother you" is a refrain I've heard a lot from others in a large number of situations, teaching Go is one where it's more directly analogous to learning a language through speaking, because it requires another human's time, and the resources are extremely easy to access.

zehaeva··on Show HN: Get conversational practice in over 20 languages by talking to an AI
Bear with me, I'm going to start with an analogous situation, and then tie it to this one.

I play Go (the board game) at a fairly high level and have been participating in clubs and teaching Go for the better part of 15 years. The simplest and easiest way to get better is to play the game a lot, hopefully against someone a little bit better than you are. You don't even have to spend a ton of time on it, just play and once you're done think about the moves you made and maybe a place or two where you could have done better. There's several websites where you can make a free account and just click up button to say "hey, I'd like to play now!" and within minutes (or longer, this depends on the server and the level that you're playing at) you'll have a game you can get done in 30minutes.

It's crazy how hard it is to get people to play other people.

Most recently I've taught 5 people at my current workplace how to play. I've gotten them to play me, and, sometimes, each other. They've all made accounts on various sites to play, I've played them on those sites! They'll even sometimes play a robot on those sites (playing a bot isn't the best, but it is a little helpful).

Not a single one of them are willing to start a game with a stranger.

I'm sure nerves are part of it. But the reasoning I've heard time and time again, and not just with these 5, but with the dozens of people I've taught over the years, is some variation of "I don't want to waste their(my opponents) time".

They seriously feel like because they are still so new to the game, and still so unskilled that they would not be worth playing, that they would be "wasting" their opponent's time.

Take this to language learners, a lot of people do feel like as a beginner, talking to someone who is fluent is wasting the time of the fluent person. You're not paying them in the language exchange, you're just babbling to them like a 3 year old, a grown up who can't even carry on a whole conversation beyond "donde esta la biblioteca?".

You are right, language exchanges and just speaking with someone _is_ the best way to learn! It's super hard to break through the fear, embarrassment, and feelings of wasting another person's time with your own drivel.

Something like this, like the bots that play Go, are a way to bridge the gap.

zehaeva··on ‘Why Am I Not Rich and Famous?’ The Delusion of Our Times
That's the equivalent of ~$240k in today's dollars!
zehaeva··on Orcas are breaking rudders off boats in Europe
I can head this in my head.
zehaeva··on Why wasn't the steam engine invented earlier? Part II
You might be interested in James Burke's TV Show Connections!

Which does this sort of thing for like 8 episodes. Go and learn why you can't have cars without swamp gasses!

zehaeva··on I disagree with Turing and Kahneman regarding statistical evidence (2014)
"No, but maybe for various definitions of the word" is a hilarious take.

Maybe letting people know for what definitions he might qualify?

zehaeva··on Ask HN: What's your favorite board game?
Zero is a very manageable number, well done!
zehaeva··on Why America can’t build
Great Idea!

We just tell the teacher that "hey you'll get a bonus if everyone in your class gets an A"!

Who's in charge of giving their students grades again?

zehaeva··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
Maybe something like Planetside 2 would work for this?
zehaeva··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
IIRC Workers & Resources has realistic build times for infrastructure https://store.steampowered.com/app/784150/Workers__Resources...
zehaeva··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
There's Radio Commander https://store.steampowered.com/app/871530/Radio_Commander/

And I think the Ultimate General series of games also does some of this, but that's second hand.

zehaeva··on Ranked-Choice Voting Is More Democratic, Not Less
Sortition like this is an interesting idea, but you have forgotten that people who meet those criteria can be emotionally disturbed, mentally compromised, in a coma, physically unable to perform.

Also, what level of a criminal record? Only Felonies (i.e. "serious crimes") and above? Misdemeanors? Even a traffic ticket?

I'll also point out that not all HS diplomas are equal, HS in a few states like NY, Cali, Michigan, are far more rigorous/difficult than schools in say Alabama or Mississippi.

I'm reminded of efforts that most people put forth in limiting suffrage, any criteria you come up with tends to be very blind.

I've personally thought that Sortition is a great idea, but I thought using a system more like Jury duty would be better. Grab your random candidates and then have them interviewed by a few bipartisan lawyers and judges to make sure they're not obviously horrific people.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →