HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yarg

3,102 karma · joined August 26, 2016

submissionscomments
yarg··on I discovered mysterious hidden signals on a public radio channel (2013) [video]
This makes me wonder, how do you reliably and securely encode steganographic content for distribution within a noisy medium?
yarg··on Goodhart’s law isn’t as useful as you might think (2023)
Goodhart's law can diagnose an issue, but it prescribes no solutions.

However, it's still better to recognise a problem, so you can at least look into ways of improving the situation.

yarg··on The weak science behind psychedelics
> The science behind this stuff has always been weak and subjective or due to placebo effects. Give someone a sugar pill and tell them it's psychedelic , and some may actually feel something.

(Replying to the comment that you made before completely rewriting it.)

You're completely wrong about the sugar pill (or at least whether or not it matters) - it's one of the issues with psychedelic medicines: there's no viable placebo at higher doses, and it's the higher doses that seem to have the deepest and longest lasting impact on depression.

yarg··on The weak science behind psychedelics
Bullshit. The reason that psychedelics are under-researched is that the corrupt medico-governmental chimera has a vested interest in blocking the substances and preventing the research that should have taken place decades ago.

I know, from repeated personal experience, that psychedelics (or mushrooms at least) can be highly effective against even severe depression.

They have been the single most effective anti-depressant that I have ever taken.

Now, I haven't had the depression curing wonder of an experience that some people claim;

It never pulled me out right out of it - but it pulled me back from suicide (on multiple occasions) and a single (rather large) dose is effective for 3 or 4 months before I find myself spiraling back down.

And if we're gonna have a conversation about anti-depressants that are being used despite scant evidence in their favour, perhaps we should start with SSRIs - which not only made my depression worse, but also left me almost asexual for ~20 years.

yarg··on Meta Bans Accounts Tracking Private Jets for Zuckerberg, Musk
No - they think there's a palpable disconnect between the public environmental statements made by men like Zuck, and the way that they themselves behave.

It's to illustrate the hypocrisy.

yarg··on Megastudy testing 25 ways to reduce antidemocratic attitudes, partisan animosity
Ranked choice voting seems like the most reasonable choice - the current FPP system lends itself to strategic voting and a two-party system with increasingly polarised parties.

Ranked choice allows for a middle ground to form independently of the parties at the outer fringes - it doesn't necessarily mean the centre wins, but it does exist and have a chance.

yarg··on Once You Try a Four-Day Workweek, It's Hard to Go Back
Oh no man - that's just regular exhaustion.

Burnout's more insidious and pernicious than that - and it takes far more than a few days of rest to get over it.

yarg··on Once You Try a Four-Day Workweek, It's Hard to Go Back
It won't be every employer - but it will come to cover large swaths of companies in industries where performance takes precedence over presence.

And you're right, it would eventually go away - but only if and when late adopters find themselves being punished by the market.

yarg··on Once You Try a Four-Day Workweek, It's Hard to Go Back
This sort of snarky response fails to consider the actual benefits - for both the employer and the employee.

Often by the end of the week, people in complex positions are well past the point of diminishing returns - pushing them harder may work in the short-term, but it's a recipe for burnout.

It's better to have someone operating closer to their peek performance for longer - even if you sacrifice a day overall.

yarg··on Software engineer titles have almost lost all their meaning
I worked for a company where what you said was entirely true - for all offices except the one in Gurgaon.

Those guys had some ridiculous job titles.

yarg··on Time is a dimension, but not like space
Read the formula: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_factor
yarg··on Language is not essential for the cognitive processes that underlie thought
100% deeper thought - and to a large extent the capacity for linguistic categorisation of objects is incredibly helpful in developing a deeper cognitive understanding of the world around us...

But the most fundamental boon that it offered was in terms of planning and organisation. Before language we'd point and grunt and go there and do the thing that we were gesturing that we were going to do.

But that's a very crude form of planning - you're pretty much just going all in on Leeroy Jenkins.

But actually (and horrifically) I think it's the gift of Kane that speaking and planning permitted; well organised humans (the smartest things on the planet) have been figuring out increasingly better ways to both kill each other and not to die themselves in a brutal feedback loop for a very long time now.

It's brutal as fuck, but it's Darwinian gold.

yarg··on Microsoft is basically discontinuing Windows. What will happen, then?
WINE gets a final version of its interface, and Gaben has a happy day.
yarg··on Language is not essential for the cognitive processes that underlie thought
> What this tells us for AI is that we need something else besides LLMs.

Perhaps, but the relative success of trained LLMs acting with apparent generalised understanding may indicate that it is simply the interface that is really an LLM post training;

That the deeper into the network you go (the further from the linguistic context), the less things become about words and linguist structure specifically and the more it becomes about things and relations in general.

(This also means that multiple interfaces can be integrated, sometimes making translation possible, e.g.: image <=> tree<string>)

yarg··on Regarding our Cease and Desist letter to Automattic
"Advanced Custom Fields" is a trademarkable term?

Beyond the point that custom fields are pretty much always advanced, there has to be a point at which a term is so fundamentally non-specific that it cannot be subject to trademark.

I just think it's bloody madness sometimes.

yarg··on Former Intel engineer says Intel x86-64 was suppressed before AMD's success
The aim of the game was Intel getting a 64 bit CPU without having to share the instruction set with AMD.

Intel was crossing many lines in terms of the anti-competitive practices they were willing to engage in, of which hobbling their own internal development was probably the least damaging to the market overall.

yarg··on Language is not essential for the cognitive processes that underlie thought
There's a major difference - the phone network takes in prerequisite constraints on the nature of the information that it's encoding; it is forced by its functionality to be a reflection of spoken language.

The internal communications of the mind have no need for such constraints (and evolved hundreds of millions of years beforehand).

Anyway, I don't know what you were actually trying to argue here: you just built a simulated brain out of people, and the massively multi-agent distributed nature of the language of that machine is (emergently) incomparable with vocalised language.

yarg··on Language is not essential for the cognitive processes that underlie thought
Yes it is.

Language is designed to be expressible with low fidelity vibrating strings - it is very clear that the available bandwidth is in the order of bytes per second.

Verses a fucking neural network with ~100 billion neurons.

Come on man, seriously - the two communication modalities are completely incomparable.

yarg··on Language is not essential for the cognitive processes that underlie thought
Is this not obvious?

Language is a very poor substitute for freely flowing electrical information - it is evolved to compensate for the bottlenecks to external communication - bottlenecks that are lacking an internal analogue.

It's also a highly advanced feature - something as heavily optiimised as evolved life would not allow something as vital as cognition to be hampered by a lack of means for high fidelity external expression.

yarg··on On the Nature of Time
I think that time isn't what we think it is - but I don't think it's all already set; rather I think that the past can be constrained by the future just as the future is constrained by the past.

I don't think that there's spooky action at a distance (it's fundamentally equivalent to retrocausality, and the consequences of the distant foreign event cannot outpace its light cone anyway).

I think its a superposition of states of a closed time-like curve thing being fleshed out as its contradictions are resolved and interactions are permitted between its colocated non-contradictory aspects.

But I'm not a physicist, so that's probably all just bullshit anyway.

yarg··on Rust needs a web framework
I consider myself a lazy developer: I like to write code that minimises the amount of code I'll need to write to incorporate new features in the future.

Laziness isn't necessarily a bad thing, depending on how it's implemented.

yarg··on Starlink direct-to-cell enabled for hurricane helene emergency messaging
There a plenty of men who would be content to be kings of the ashes;

Don't consider this from the perspective of a reasonable person - ask yourself: what would psychopaths do?

yarg··on We need a real GNU/Linux (not Android) smartphone ecosystem
The unforgivable part for me was Google prohibiting Android forks in their vendor licensing agreements for their add-on software.

It was a deeply cynical way of doing an end-run around the GPL, and I've held them in utter contempt ever since.

yarg··on Cloudflare beats patent troll so badly it basically gives up
Yes it is.

It converts a regular rent payment into a one time fee, and scares the crap out of anyone thinking to do something similar.

yarg··on How were 70s versions of games like Pong built without a programmable computer?
How do you debug it?

I'm guessing you'd need to solder on your debugging tools (oscilloscopes?) in parallel, since anything else would completely invalidate anything that you were trying to do.

It honestly sounds like a recipe for Heisenbugs.

yarg··on Show HN: kew – A Terminal Music Player for Linux
Yeah, to fix that you'd need to add support for media metadata, which I imagine is a little further than you'd want to go.
yarg··on Show HN: kew – A Terminal Music Player for Linux
I'm thinking {-s, -l, -a, -p} for {song, album, artist, playlist}.

Unlike the -e solution, it wouldn't make the command significantly more verbose than the default option.

You could also print a list of commands for the specific options (or allow for index based selection) in cases where there were collisions.

yarg··on Show HN: kew – A Terminal Music Player for Linux
Does it accept flags to deal with ambiguities?

Defaulting to the only result in your library is perfectly reasonable, but it the case of a collision, what does it do?

My guess is that it runs through in a loop (I haven't looked at the code) and simply goes with the first result that it finds, but that doesn't cover all possible use cases.

yarg··on The other British invasion: how UK lingo conquered the US
I know that - the only time I use the American spelling is when I use it as a suffix.

(I often consider it shorthand for "I'm not an American".)

yarg··on How were 70s versions of games like Pong built without a programmable computer?
> If anything, the point of the post is the fact that it's very easy to understand, despite how counterintuitive it may be.

Much like he seemed to have missed the point of the post, you seem to have missed my point about him seeming to miss the point of the post.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →