HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xp84

9,374 karma · joined March 23, 2011

submissionscomments
xp84··on Pirating the Pirates
Yup. Daria is one of the most tragic ones, given how it was an MTV show and thus featured music iconic to the era and familiar to the audience. Replaced with muzak in the DVD releases, and a bunch of pirates have cobbled together best-effort mash-ups based on audio from TV rips, which sometimes were of very low quality, but for some episodes, all that had survived in the piracy scene was like, a RealVideo file with a 64kbps audio stream.
xp84··on Show HN: HN.watch – Videos of all Hacker News posts
To me, the use case is to go from an often opaque headline ("Using Nix and containerd with Jev on macOS") to a paragraph which hopefully gives some strong hints as to what those things are and why it's interesting, because the articles often are written for an audience already deeply into all the topics. Because often a few of those terms I might have no clue about and thus scroll on by, but with a brief "why you should care" explanation, I might realize it's actually something cool.
xp84··on Show HN: HN.watch – Videos of all Hacker News posts
For most articles these days, we'd have to first have a separate bot get the archive.is link for it!

But I'm skeptical that people would embrace it. It's more about the optics, and it also relates to the old principle of "Read the article -- don't start opining based only on the headline." Many would probably say that you shouldn't offer an opinion if you've only read an AI distillation.

It could be wrong - or more likely, the article acknowledges likely objections and refutes them well, but that part didn't make it into the summary, so everyone starts raising very un-insightful points as though the author was oblivious to them.

xp84··on Show HN: HN.watch – Videos of all Hacker News posts
All of what you said is great, and I especially detest the proliferation of slop videos on YouTube, where it makes no sense to drown out the ample supply of such personalities and insights with AI voices summarizing wikipedia or Reddit threads over AI imagery slideshows.

But given how good a job this seemed to do at giving me more than just headlines, I'd love to have maybe even just an audio podcast feed of the top 10 stories like this compiled a few times a day. I would listen while I'm doing things when reading isn't practical.

tl;dr agree that we don't need this to replace reading, but I see that it can be a useful tool.

xp84··on What heraldry and Japanese mon can teach about visual-identity generators
Nice. I was craving more examples of this, as I'm not familiar with this tradition. "Cranes with Pine Branch" is my favorite on this list.
xp84··on What Heraldry and Mon Can Teach Us About Building Visual-Identity Generators
Heh. I guess one could have some fun with a ::before {content: "Side" or "Foot" } inside each breakpoint's media query.
xp84··on What heraldry and Japanese mon can teach about visual-identity generators
Tangent, but I deeply appreciate the treatment of footnotes on this article, just floating alongside the text in the right gutter instead of at the bottom of the article. It seems so obvious (at least on desktop) but I haven't seen it before. It's so nice to be able to see whether it's something I want to read, or just a citation, without clicking and losing my place (yes, I know there's usually a link back to the article flow, but especially in the "sticky header" era we've been in for decades, that rarely works well).
xp84··on When did Google get so weird?
This is the key part I think most “normies” miss, and it drives me absolutely mad. People take the “first thing on the SERP” as absolute gospel, always have. It went from being a reputable site (Wikipedia was generally top for a long time) to being an extracted verbatim answer (probably from either Wikipedia, IMDB, etc.) to “AI Overview” - the dumbest model ever trained. And people treat its answers as ground truth. I want to tell them “Look, I know it’s rough out there on the net and a lot of the search results are spammy, barely-coherent AI slop anyway. It’s okay if you want to ask AI for an answer instead. So do that! Please ask ChatGPT or Gemini (and ask it to cite the source for its results so you can verify). It will always do better than AI Overviews will. Don’t even use Google Search at this point unless you have to, and if you do, scroll past that slop.”
xp84··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
> When landlords threaten to raise rents in response to a future land value tax, why don’t they just raise the rents right now? Why do they have to wait until the tax is enacted?

I think the answer to this is because a tax increase is something they know every other landlord they’re competing with will be subject to as well. Raising it right now makes yours an oddly expensive apartment. Once the law passes though, even before implementation date, every landlord knows every other landlord will want to preserve the same cash flow they had before, by raising the rent by roughly the amount of the tax.

Unless of course you have mass vacancy rates already, and those rent raises would be more than the market can bear. But decent rentals in desirable cities have been in shortage for decades which is why rent steadily rises already. Even if your current tenants refuse to renew at a raised rent, someone else will come along, trading slightly down if necessary in terms of quality/amenities.

xp84··on Video CDs Break Windows Explorer
Reading the first half or so made me think, "Wow, they should really fix this."

The second half made me think, "Wow, what a gross format. Really glad we have no use for these anymore!" (Not that they should leave the Explorer crash unfixed, of course).

It's bananas to me that a CD-ROM cost like $400 in 1990s money at one point; then I spent $150 on my first CD burner around 2002, and now you can buy a USB Blu-Ray/DVD/CD recorder drive for under $40.

xp84··on Ten lines of code that changed my world
yeah i get the utility for the 'making new file' use case, but aliasing this as touch if you're used to touch for both uses scares me!
xp84··on Replacing the old battery on rechargeable bike lights
" b) If you've got the money, consider a radar instead."

Can you explain this? What is this and how does it replace a taillight?

xp84··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
It’s nuts to me that anyone doesn’t see it. Unlimited money, just declare your victims “too rich.”
xp84··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
They won't BE in California to be taxed, which will only accelerate all our turns.
xp84··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
On a 2M house the current property tax burden in california is $20,000 a year. More if you have Mello-Roos taxes in that subdivision.
xp84··on Allow babywearing carriers on planes
On landing would be the less useful time to resist anyway because you've only got 15 minutes before you start a lot more activity that can easily wake them anyway. It's on takeoff that it's painful, since if baby is asleep they can sleep right through part of the flight.

> all these silly rules [tray tables and seat backs for instance, seat belts...]

Most of these rules are based in sound research, and were created to avoid repeats of things that exacerbated deadliness of previous air accidents. Calling them silly really makes one look like the sort of know-it-all who thinks that the whole aviation industry is dummies. Exactly the sort of person who bickers with FAs trying to inform you of the safety rules.

PS: I support the baby carriers myself. Argue it with the FAA, not with the FA on a plane.

xp84··on How we learned to stop worrying and love campus surveillance
> Lots of things have changed, the government, the politics

This reads like you're saying "When [Good Party] were in charge, they would have always done the right thing, but now [Bad Party] is in charge so we need to handicap the government (perhaps only temporarily, until we get in charge again).

More compelling would be "Doesn't matter if it's a Bernie Sanders Socialists supermajority or a Trump MAGA government, the government shouldn't be allowed to have such-and-such power."

xp84··on How we learned to stop worrying and love campus surveillance
> have set into motion a plan to cancel our subscriptions to 700+ academic journals integral to our research and teaching.

ehh, this part is a weak take. All universities should cancel their journal subscriptions because journal publishers are parasites. Lots of other things are done by universities in collaboration with each other, without allowing some random for-profit company to collect rents. Publications should be one of them.

xp84··on Allow Carriers on Planes
> It is extremely unlikely that this would lead to a felony conviction

Uh, you'd be surprised. Once you refuse, they are going to insist, and if you still refuse to comply, or they're going to return to the gate and have your ass removed. They don't pick and choose which rules to enforce.

And yes, they do enforce this rule. We experienced it all the time when my son was a baby.

xp84··on Allow Carriers on Planes
For real. For something like car seats, arguably the regulation was what we needed to get them adopted. This though, seems as necessary as government regulators deciding if I can babywear my child when walking down the street. The relative risks and benefits are impossible to fully compare with this issue, and the impact on other people is nil whether it's baby in lap or baby in carrier.
xp84··on Allow Carriers on Planes
Why doesn't the FAA usually implement the changes the NTSB raises after learning from crashes?
xp84··on Show HN: Make cursed fonts like Times New Bastard
If font humor is your thing, search for Elle Cordova’s videos on YouTube. They are absolute gems.
xp84··on Show HN: Make cursed fonts like Times New Bastard
This comment comes off as unnecessarily negative. They didn’t say they were mad that it didn’t get interest, and just shared it in case it may find an audience here. If you’re actually intending to give constructive advice rather than to discourage them or make them feel bad, there may have been a better way to say that.

Edit: such as amoss’s comment.

xp84··on Spymarks, not Watermarks
Literally nothing that happened 15 years ago could possibly be cited as a good reason for a business to make a decision today.

Like, a significant portion of the people who were involved in any screwups made in the 2000s -- especially the more senior people who should get most of the blame -- are now retired.

Make decisions based on today and on reality. Apple holding a grudge against Nvidia today, if true (as we have no proof that it factors in, of course), is downright childish.

xp84··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
> property owners who don't rent out their properties

The existence of property tax (which on a single house in some areas of the state is upwards of $15,000 a year already) already makes it absolutely ruinous to just sit on an extra house you don't need and not rent it out.

> or who don't make efficient use of land

A little more convincing. Though I suspect most empty land in places where anyone would be willing to live in California, is empty because our insane zoning laws don't allow what would otherwise make sense there (I don't care that it's like what most areas have -- it's insane to have laws that would make it illegal to build a place like San Francisco, Brooklyn, or Boston).

The funny thing about those zoning laws though is that they're held up by a rare case of bipartisanship:

- The MAGA Boomer set who doesn't want any more development near them because "it'll bring traffic" or noise or crime

- And most of the "progressives" who don't want any more development anywhere because "we hate greedy developers" and "Not enough of this proposed development is low-income housing for the government to dole out in lotteries to a few lucky families."

xp84··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
Not sure if anyone could get such a policy change made given that California politics is now just "Whatever the California Democratic Party Wants" and they are very rigid in the ideas they accept.

But I think the proposal being discussed is 1000% more consistent with the principles of a free, non-communist society than the crazy "wealth tax," which sets the precedent that if the government thinks you have "too much" stuff, they can just declare that to be so, and come and take it. Given that the people in charge of drawing the line between "so rich that we need to take your stuff" and "not that rich" will be the same people who have blown up the state budget, I don't see why anyone would trust them.

(No, I'm not Zuck's sock puppet account -- I expect it won't be my turn for "wealth" confiscation for at least 5 years, worst case.)

xp84··on California is chasing wealth that has feet
I do acknowledge that rent is a function of supply and demand in the big picture, at least. I don't think the whole foundation of economics is wrong.

Demand for apartments will be constant. Supply of apartments will be constant.

But I think what's going on here is that we are way off the equilibrium point. The supply of good places to rent is far outpaced by demand for them, at most price points, and especially so where all the value is (on the coast). So, this means if you're a landlord and you know you'll owe another $1200 tax to Sacramento this year, you should be very confident that if you raise rent by $100 a month, even if an individual tenant would rather move than pay it, someone who can afford $100 more exists and will almost certainly fill that vacancy promptly. It may represent a slight step down in what their buying power would buy. Like, they may have rented a $3000 apartment before, and they'll now rent what used to be a $2900 apartment from you for $3000.

xp84··on Fixing the Portobello Police Station Clock
To anyone other than a computer engineer, I would bet Morse code would be preferred at least 10 to 1. Most people who aren’t computer science majors could barely decode binary “10” correctly, whereas writing down the dots and dashes and googling “Morse code chart” is something I’d bet over 50% of non-engineers could do accurately.
xp84··on SAML: A fractal of bad design
Yeah, it never really got off the ground though because incentives weren’t aligned. Everyone wants you to sign up on their site for data hoarding reasons, not to use an identity from elsewhere.
xp84··on SAML: A fractal of bad design
I’d point out that it’s possible for SAML to be acknowledged as okay or “good for its time,” even, and also be acknowledged as today amounting to a steaming pile of crap that ought to be avoided and phased out wherever possible. Even if all its flaws were just the bad luck of existing before other things were invented.

We can’t change the past anyway, but ‘considering SAML harmful’ today may be the most reasonable position to take.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →