HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vmarsy

3,262 karma · joined June 26, 2013

https://twitter.com/vmarsy
submissionscomments
vmarsy··on The war between Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Apple
I wonder as well if you read the papers too? you may learn something from them as well.

"We investigate the idea that women’s flaunting of designer products functions as a signaling system directed at same-sex rivals who pose a threat to a woman’s relationship. We hypothesize that some women use pricey possessions to signal to other women that their romantic partner is especially devoted to them. In turn, flaunting designer handbags and shoes helps women deter romantic rivals from poaching their relationship partner"

Today iPhones and MacBook are mostly mass market for the middle class, as you can see from their presence in universities. Out of all the women owning an iPhone, and there's a lot, I've yet to meet one whose iPhone was bought by their 'devoted romantic partner'. They either bought it themselves, or their parents bought it in the family plan. And usually the phone itself is paid monthly with the plan.

Showing an iPhone does not have the same signalling effect as wearing "luxurious designer handbags", designer shoes, and "expensive jewelry".

vmarsy··on Do I really have to cite an arXiv paper?
It's a bit tougher when a paper hasn't been peer reviewed, although not too different from a good paper published in a low quality or unknown conference. I think you should cite any idea you pick from a paper when the said paper has some the following qualities:

- novelty

- technical correctness

- clarity

- good experimental evaluation

Novelty is the most important: if without the citation your paper looks like the original idea, this is plagiarism.

If the paper has big shortcomings that your paper adresses, it is fair to give yourself the credit you deserve of course, but it doesn't harm to cite the other paper, in fact it gives a way to give some sort of peer review: In [1], Foo and al. attempted to explore <subject> but the experiments were inconclusive/the technique sucked compare to state of the art/they didn't explain how they did it... In this paper we did this and that and it gives us awesome results (Said in a nicer way)

vmarsy··on Longest Lines of Sight on Earth
Interesting, I'm not sure how the list was created, it seems to be missing entries such as the one mentioned in that March 2015 comment at the end of the post.
vmarsy··on Ask Y Combinator: How often can YC companies post jobs to the front page of HN?
I think stackoverflow, reddit, etc. clearly know this is less effective, but they are probably simply following the law regarding "Native advertising" [1] which applies to "content that bears a similarity to the news, feature articles, product reviews, entertainment, and other material that surrounds it online"

[1] https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/nat...

vmarsy··on Should Community Colleges Abolish Algebra?
> Is it cheaper to buy 1 case of water for $2.50 or 3 cases of water for $9.00

Slightly off topic as I don't think this is college level algebra, in supermarkets in Europe they are required by law to put the "€/liter" price in small on the side, so you can compare easily. In the US it doesn't seem mandatory, or at least the unit is not mandatory because sometimes they use fl oz, sometimes gallons, or for pieces of meat sometimes oz, sometimes lbs, so when you want to compare the prices of 2 similar items, what would just take you 0.5 sec in Europe takes you much longer in the US since you need to add unit conversion in the mix. For example here your "cases" could be of different sizes, that 1 case of water could be 2L ,while those 3 cases could be a gallon each...

vmarsy··on VISA offers restaurants $10,000 to stop accepting cash
It seems that it would not be legal, unless announced upfront : http://www.news-leader.com/story/news/watchdog/2014/12/24/as...
vmarsy··on VISA offers restaurants $10,000 to stop accepting cash
The legal way might put pressure on Visa and MC, their attempt at a settlement failed last year [1]. I don't know what happened next.

> The settlement may now need to be renegotiated, or the case could go to trial.

> "Swipe fees are an improper and unnecessary hidden tax on consumers," said Jeffrey Shinder, a Constantine Cannon partner representing Amazon.com Inc (AMZN.O), Costco Wholesale Corp (COST.O), Wal-Mart Stores Inc (WMT.N) and other opponents of the accord. "The structure of swipe fees is back on the table."

Anyone knows if the case went to trial after that court of appeals decision?

To compare, in the E.U. [2], "the Regulation caps interchange fees for consumer debit cards to 0.2 % and consumer credit cards to 0.3 % of the value of the transaction.". In the U.S. the fees today seem to be 10x higher[3].

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/us-visa-mastercard-settlement...

[2] http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-16-2162_en.htm

[3] https://www.richmondfed.org/~/media/richmondfedorg/publicati...

vmarsy··on A Grand Unified Theory of Avocado Toast
In France we cut it in half, remove the pit, and in each half put a drizzle of olive oil and balsamic vinegar (2 olive oil : 1 balsamic vinegar ratio) in the hole where the pit used to be, and simply eat it with a spoon, it's delicious. The better the avocado and the better the balsamic vinegar, the better the final result :)
vmarsy··on Marc Andreessen answers questions from Stripe Atlas founders
> It is useful background knowledge here that American professionals culturally expect less vacation total than European professionals do (the norm is ~2 weeks) and expect it to be largely non-contiguous with the exception of the end-of-the-year holiday season.

The exception would be big tech companies where it's not unusual to see employees at all levels take 3 to 4 weeks vacations in the summer* , especially foreigners since they want to spend time to visit their families, and depending on their country of origin, were used to 7-8 weeks.

(* not every summer)

vmarsy··on Battle for the Internet
Do you think it's free for YouTube or Netflix to upload their content? Is bandwidth free for you when you host a VM on AWS? If you read about the economics of the internet backbone [1], while slightly old (2004), you can get a more informed view.

Netflix or YouTube, via their commercial internet providers (or the one used by AWS in Netflix's case) have to pay for the packets they exchange with other backbone providers, one way or another. If they sent too many bytes per second, the backbones providers would adjust their prices accordingly. Those 'backbone providers' have no way of enforcing non net-neutral behavior, they would simply be avoided by everyone else. But consumer-facing ISP would want to abuse their unique position between the consumers and the other ISPs and either take the consumers hostage, or the companies that are trying to reach those customers.

Big tech are starting to take measures to prevent themselves from being taken hostage that way (i.e. Google Fiber), but how do we know 20 years from now these companies wouldn't want to engage in the same behavior as the current consumer-facing ISPs want today. Title II classification would ensure this net neutrality stays.

> someone's grandma who only emails and very light browsing, so she's subsidizing my use of Youtube and Netflix already today.

If this was a big problem, providers could provide non-unlimited internet, where you pay per Gb/s used. But if those Gb come from me watching 4k videos, or someone's grandma downloading the entire Wikipedia pages for offline consumption shouldn't matter, they should all come at the same speed, untethered, for everyone.

[1] http://www.netinst.org/ECONOMICS_OF_THE_INTERNET_BACKBONE.pd...

vmarsy··on Battle for the Internet
I don't think your comparison is correct.

> Assuming you have 10mbit internet access for $N/month:

> * Paying +$20/m for 100mbit internet: OK

> * Paying +$20/m for 100mbit access to "Top 100 websites": Not OK

In your car comparison, it would be like :

Assuming you pay for a VW Golf $10000

* Paying +$200k for a Ferrari: OK

* Paying +$200k for a Lamborghini: OK

* Paying +$200k for a Ferrari but +$200k for an equivalent Lamborghini but with an added +$300k of fee just because the container ship company moving the car from Italy to the U.S. asked an extra $300k simply because the container is filled with Lamborghini instead of Ferrari: Not OK

Container companies would never do this because Lamborghini would simply put its containers on the container boat of a concurrent company, because there's competition. But for consumer-facing ISPs, there's plenty of documentation that shows that in many areas around the country, some ISPs have a monopoly, and so for many users, they cannot go to another ISP if they aren't satisfied with their only choice.

vmarsy··on In Blow to Tech Industry, Trump Shelves Startup Immigrant Rule
> Can you elaborate specifically on the rules of the USA startup visa that didn't make sense?

As someone pointed out a couple weeks ago [1]:

> From the article:

> "To qualify for the rule, entrepreneurs would have to meet high standards. A foreigner must demonstrate that he or she will contribute to economic growth or job creation and show that a reputable investor has put at least $250,000 into the company. Under this rule, they can stay in the U.S. for 30 months, with the possibility of a 30-month extension. They cannot apply for a green card during this period."

> This sounds like a pretty lame visa. How are you supposed to build a startup if you only have 30 months to do so? Why would investors risk $250k if the founder may be deported in 30 months? What happens after the extension period?

So from your link, that startup rule got wrong the 'Defining Success: Criteria for Permanent Residence' which states:

> Conditional entrepreneur visas can typically be renewed or converted to permanent residence after two to four years if the immigrant creates a successful business. (An exception is the Australian Venture Capital Entrepreneur program, which provides immediate permanent residence.)

But here the rule is simply: 'They cannot apply for a green card during this period.'. So even if your startup is successful, you're kicked out after 2.5 or 5 years.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14606478

vmarsy··on Seattle City Council unanimously approves income tax for the rich
What about 500k ? Because that's what the Seattle city council tax says [1]. So no, a family earning 200-250k will definitely not feel this tax

Even if the limit was 250k, how would a family earning less than 250k feel the tax? It would literally cost them $0 per year since only income above 250k are taxed.

From [2]:

    Tax Filing Status           Total Income                                                    Rate
    “single”	                Total income in the tax year up to $250,000	                0%
                                Amount of total income in the tax year in excess of $250,000	2.25%
                                
    “married filing jointly”    Total income in the tax year up to $500,000                     0%
                                Amount of total income in the tax year in excess of $500,000    2.25%




[1] http://council.seattle.gov/2017/07/10/council-approves-city-...

[2] http://seattle.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=308547...

vmarsy··on Trump plans to halt entrepreneur visas
As discussed previously [1], this is good given how unattractive the visa rules were in the first place :

> From the article:

> "To qualify for the rule, entrepreneurs would have to meet high standards. A foreigner must demonstrate that he or she will contribute to economic growth or job creation and show that a reputable investor has put at least $250,000 into the company. Under this rule, they can stay in the U.S. for 30 months, with the possibility of a 30-month extension. They cannot apply for a green card during this period."

> This sounds like a pretty lame visa. How are you supposed to build a startup if you only have 30 months to do so? Why would investors risk $250k if the founder may be deported in 30 months? What happens after the extension period?

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14606478

vmarsy··on Cicada – Unix shell written in Rust
Powershell is available on Linux these days, it was in 'alpha' version for a long time, apparently it's now 'beta'

https://github.com/PowerShell/PowerShell

vmarsy··on Why We Chose Typescript
I don't know, but the reddit blog post says:

> One of the worries we had with Flow was that it was built to solve specific needs at Facebook and that its future would be determined by that scope.

if you replace [Flow/Facebook] with [Dart/Google] , I guess you could make the same point.

vmarsy··on Sony plans to make vinyl records again
There is a quality aspect regarding the "loudness war" : http://www.soundmattersblog.com/vinyl-vs-cd-in-the-loudness-...

Making Vinyl sometimes better than CDs

vmarsy··on Amazon Prime Wardrobe lets you try on and return clothes free
Like food business must deal with the cold-chain, Clothes businesses have distinctive features other retail areas don't have, there's a reason fitting rooms exists in clothing brick & mortar stores.

How do you replicate the fitting room experience online? with colors you can see differently on a monitor, texture you can't feel, sizes for each body type that are different, etc. , the best way today is to order more and return.

> Why exactly is this unbelievably damaging to environment is an exercise left to the reader.

Well people need to find clothes that fits them. So they're either left with going to a brick & mortar store, or ordering online and returning items that don't fit.

Me and all other customers driving to the outlet malls (assuming that mall has all the stores we're interested in, otherwise drive to each store separately), and driving back in our cars is certainly more damaging to the environment than one extra shipping, given that UPS, USPS, Fedex and everybody involved in the transportation business is making sure they're wasting the least amount of gas.

vmarsy··on Startup School 2017 Presentations
Interesting concept, however assuming you become popular enough, then you could be victim of lawyers trying to game the metrics.

What happens if a lawyer choose to only defend a lot of easy to win cases to bump up their track record close to 100%. How do you identify how hard a case was in the first place, and find the lawyers who do go after hard cases successfully.

vmarsy··on Show HN: Snips is a AI Voice Assistant platform 100% on-device and private
In the links you provide, you compare the F1 score for snips with other major competitors on 70 queries.

Then you show the F1 score for snips on 2000 queries. Obviously you see improvements and that's good. What I don't understand is why don't you show the F1 score for the other competitors on 2000 queries? If you're able to generate 2000 input from the original 70, what prevents you from feeding those to the other NLP engines? Do they all get a 93% F1 score ?

vmarsy··on Emmanuel Macron presidency prompts French startup boom
Our comments are not incompatible, I'd say, given Google's and other companies recruiting standards, the difficulty of the immigration process, there must be a huge foreign engineers survivorship bias.

Despite a not-as-good-as-the-best-US-schools CS education, they managed to make it to Google.

Similarly, assuming each country has the same distribution of talent, and that the US is able to brain-drain from the top of the stack, the foreigners coming from smaller countries will look even more competent. I know very few Danish and Finnish programmers in the US, apart from Bjarne Stroustrup, Linus Torvalds, so I'm under the impression from that sample that Danish and Finnish are amazing programmers :)

vmarsy··on U.S. Invests $258M in Supercomputing Race with China
top500.org, which maintains the list of the 500 fatest supercomputers in the world also has more details on this [1]

> The PathForward program [...] address the four key challenges: parallelism, memory and storage, reliability and energy consumption

Energy consumption is becoming a very important challenge, as the article says, current petascale supercomputers consume "enough power to run a small town". Major efforts will need to be made to have Exascale supercomputers that don't consume the equivalent of 10^3 small towns.

[1] https://www.top500.org/news/doe-shells-out-258-million-to-si...

vmarsy··on Emmanuel Macron presidency prompts French startup boom
> But I also learned management (how to hold a meeting, how to manage conflict) and project management (Gantt-diagram, Agile and Scrum) and some basis of ITIL

> And even more related to the entrepreneur-ship world I had lessons about copyrights law, labor laws, patent laws , as well as finance course (what is an asset active/passive, what is the difference between giving yourself a salary and giving you shares etc.)

Oh interesting, I thought this was specific to the "Grandes Écoles". For entrepreneurship, this is good. Accounting basics also comes in handy.

But yeah, I make a difference between learning C, SQL, PHP and let's say taking a compiler class, OS class , programming language design, distributed systems, and a database class where you learn the intrinsic of a database.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but when such school 'teach you SQL', they teach you about how to operate a SQL database, and do efficient indexing/joins. That itself is very important, but the school makes no effort to demystify a database. Similar to how you demystified processor by building it from scratch (Electrical Engineering is another "old-school" discipline one I think French engineers are good at), I feel learning to demystify many key computer science concepts makes you a better software engineer. And while learning a new language is something you can do on your own time easily, going deep into a compiler creation isn't something easy to do on your own, especially after being out of school.

Some people would argue that lot of this is useless, but to me: Like a civil engineer, where doing matrices operations and second order derivatives by hand at school is never going to be useful later on the job, having the core skills gives you a better intuition on the job.

vmarsy··on Emmanuel Macron presidency prompts French startup boom
I can see those cuts in corporate tax being good to increase startup competition. Some of the other big remaining issues to see highly successful startups are salaries and lack of tech talent.

We could argue that startup salaries aren't the highest anyways, so if salary isn't too big of an issue if French startup can provide equity easily. It seems that when you exercise stock options in France, you don't need to pay tax on it until the options are actually sold[1][2], so that's a good thing for employee, no need to scratch your head with 83b elections and whatnot.

Regarding the lack of tech talent, there's still a lot to be done. France has incredible engineers, but those engineering schools are not focused enough on Computer Science, instead they excel in "old-school" engineering like Aerospace, Civil, Nuclear, ... . On the other hand, Free universities have Computer Science degrees, but they don't prepare the future graduates as much as the Engineering "Grandes Écoles" would in regard to core engineering knowledge. There are some attempts at schools focused more on Software Engineering, but I feel that they're more similar to longer bootcamps with a focus on projects, I think those who graduate such schools are trained to be good "monkey coders" (pardon the expression) but lack a growth-mindset.

[1] (in French) https://www.impots.gouv.fr/portail/particulier/questions/jai...

[2] (in French) https://www.impots.gouv.fr/portail/particulier/lactionnariat...

vmarsy··on Canadian Tech Is Having a Moment
A quick estimation [1] shows that a $130000 salary in the US is equivalent to around $105k / 139k CAD. There are some of the top companies in the SV who pays this as base salary, is is there 139k CAD companies in Montreal? What's the highest base salary for the local Netflix/Google/... of Canada?

[1] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=$130000+in+San+Francis...

vmarsy··on No correlation between headphone frequency response and retail price
In France a retailer similar to BestBuy has a "Lab"[1] that usually has objective reviews, using a set of standards to compare items of the same category. Here's an example: [2], you can scroll to the conclusion to see the grades, but you also have an explanation behind it.

[1] http://labo.fnac.com/

[2] http://labo.fnac.com/video-photo-numerique/appareil-photo-re...

vmarsy··on Europe mostly ends mobile roaming fees from today
How much is it exactly? I thought you can't beat Free's prices in France with 2€/mo for 1h phone and unlimited text, and 20€/mo for everything unlimited : phone/text/4G.

Since they showed up all other telcos in France had to adjust and offer around the same, around 25€ max instead of the usual 60€ to 80€ they'd offer before Free.

vmarsy··on It’s Probably Not Okay to Send Naked Pictures on LinkedIn
Most important part of the article is that the offender is a recruiter:

> Jane Doe alleged that a recruitment conversation on LinkedIn took a turn for the inappropriate when she received sexual messages from a banker—using his corporate account—who had been trying to recruit her. One of the messages included a photograph of his genitals.

So "It’s Probably Not Okay to Send Naked Pictures if you're a recruiter representing the company" would be a more accurate title, but it wouldn't be as interesting of an headline.

Similarly that if you're a recruiter calling someone or having a dinner with, you shouldn't attempt to seduce* the maybe-future-employee since that's clearly an abuse of power. Lawsuit or not, that recruiter should be fired.

I don't think the medium (phone company, restaurant you're at, or Linkedin) should be held responsible and Nowhere on this article it says the plaintiff is suing Linkedin, she's suing the company that recruiter works for.

* For some people apparently, sending a photograph of their genitals seem to be a "seduction" technique, but even if this was more tactful flirting, this is already not ok.

vmarsy··on Bankrupt Mt. Gox may soon be able to pay its creditors
It's a well known subject in Accounting : Depreciation [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depreciation

vmarsy··on Is Software Engineering Possible?
You can find papers more easily one "Google scholar", I found it there:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14528514

← PreviousPage 5 of 22Next →