HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

untilHellbanned

908 karma · joined July 18, 2013

submissionscomments
untilHellbanned··on The Empty Promise of Data Moats
Pretty interesting. Thanks. Is this relevant to all sectors of the economy? I can see it being relevant in e-commerce but how about in a field where the company has lots of data but also a proprietary technology? For example, a medical device or pharma company.
untilHellbanned··on Getting Featured on Hacker News
Im aware. I’m skeptical of what Dang said that it should take more time to decide what they like.
untilHellbanned··on The Empty Promise of Data Moats
I was with you at the beginning. Can you ELI5?
untilHellbanned··on The Peculiar Blindness of Experts
Experts are all about output. If you don’t learn and take in input regularly I’d argue you stop being an expert.
untilHellbanned··on Getting Featured on Hacker News
You have time to decide what to bump, but not to decide what you like? Makes no sense.
untilHellbanned··on The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested
What’s neurotrophic computation and substrate independence?
untilHellbanned··on Scandals suggest standards have slipped in corporate America
“Slipped” implies unintentional. A better headline is corporate America is getting away with more.
untilHellbanned··on Alzheimer’s Drug Failure Leaves Scientists Seeking New Direction
As someone with firsthand experience in this space, it’s hard to get buy-in even in research world for neuroprotective agents. First, this word neuroprotective gets thrown around a lot. Lots of complex efficacy endpoints. Lots of biases about safety. It’s unfortunately tough sledding.
untilHellbanned··on Be: Fundraising Misadventures
Without more context, this reads as failing upwards/humble bragging. All these powerful people helping something that seems so tenuous? That’s not a common outcome.
untilHellbanned··on The money, job, marriage myth: are you happy yet?
It's not a choice.
untilHellbanned··on Why Are We Still So Fat?
It is a matter of definitions. Here is a review: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6234835/.

"The FA framework for understanding obesity is the notion that highly processed 'hyperpalatable' foods have hijacked the reward centers in the brain thus impairing the decision-making process, similar to drugs of abuse."

"Finally, there is strong evidence of the existence of sugar addiction, both at preclinical and clinical level. Our model has demonstrated that five out of eleven criteria for SUD are met, specifically: use of larger amounts and for longer than intended, craving, hazardous use, tolerance, and withdrawal. From an evolutionary perspective, we must consider addiction as a normal trait that permitted humans to survive primitive conditions when food was scarce. As we evolved culturally, the neural circuits involved in addictive behaviors became dysfunctional and instead of helping us survive they are in fact compromising our health."

untilHellbanned··on Why Are We Still So Fat?
> Some people choose not to be disciplined. Their choice I guess.

Empathy goes a long way. I think as a society we will get to the solution faster with the view that some people might have stronger urges to overeat then you. Congratulations you worked hard. Don't discount what others face.

untilHellbanned··on Why Are We Still So Fat?
Random commenter #2, but I'm a genetics professor at a med school FWIW. Sugar is a major factor. The genetics of obesity point to a strong link to behavior. Sugar is addictive. Alcohol and nicotine are drugs, and so is sugar. There needs to be regulations on sugar content of foods. If you say it's not possible, I point to the low-fat craze years of the 1980s-1990s, where ironically we basically proved that swapping fat with sugar made our obesity problem worse.
untilHellbanned··on How an outsider bucked prevailing Alzheimer's theory, clawed for validation
Holds true for biomedical sciences, which is what hhmi focuses on.
untilHellbanned··on How an outsider bucked prevailing Alzheimer's theory, clawed for validation
Disagree vehemently. HHMI funds what’s fashionable. Find me a HHMI investigator without a recent CNS paper. As with Nobel prizes, the true innovators always seem to make their discoveries outside the power circle.
untilHellbanned··on Tech Workers Now Want to Know: What Are We Building This For?
Not a generous interpretation of their argument. I’m in biomedical research which also wasn’t mentioned explicitly but I read it as a more general argument about finding something that is future-looking and helpful to many vs a few.
untilHellbanned··on How Boston Got Its ‘T’
Ionic compared to what
untilHellbanned··on Radical open-access plan could spell end to journal subscriptions
> so why is so much money going to the middle men?

Because the scientific community hasn't put forth an alternative.

untilHellbanned··on Sci Hub repository torrents of scientific papers
Same exact reasons for me at a big US university.
untilHellbanned··on What we've learned from building Ghost after 5 years and $3M
The Ghost website borrows alot from Stripe's.
untilHellbanned··on Do adult human brains renew their neurons?
More relevant: Does it matter if human brains renew their neurons?

We know that there is lots of redundant networks and plasticity, so if one cell goes down does it matter whether the gap gets filled by and old vs. new cell?

With 100 billion neurons we seem fine with what we have. The bigger question seems to be how to protect these 100 billion cells from degenerating.

untilHellbanned··on Before cancer kills, it cheats
Professor at a med school here.

Regardless of whether you think the specifics presented in this article (e.g., NSAIDS-esophageal cancer) are right, it’s great to see this kind of philosophical approach to biomedical research. We need more people like this professor.

That she started with a plant and that made her think about humans was a great insight. She rightly recognizes the key role of cell autonomous vs. cell non-autonomous processes in how multicellular organisms work.

That she is a woman and someone not at an Ivy League school is also very refreshing to see getting publicized by Harvard. There are so many great scientists aground the world doing great stuff. Let’s keep finding them and reporting on them!

Please media, more of these types of stories and less clickbait please! I loved this article. My faith in humanity was restored just a touch here.

untilHellbanned··on Time to talk about why so many postgrads have poor mental health
Just because what you say is historically true doesn’t mean it will always be true. One would have thought the #metoo movement should have happened decades ago with women’s lib movement but here it is 2018.

Information is massively more knowable now and bad behavior isnt hiding very well anymore. I’m putting my money on a-holes not winning like they use to.

untilHellbanned··on Time to talk about why so many postgrads have poor mental health
Agreed. I think academia is up for its #metoo moment. Not sexual abuse, but emotional abuse. Many professors particularly the most prestigious ones (man or woman) are collosal a-holes.

Though most would say I’m flourishing in the ivory tower now as a professor at a top tier med school, my training experiences have been terrible. For example, I’d be rich if I had a dollar for every time I heard my former boss say “I don’t care about this {thing that you spent 5+ years on that I didn’t really allow you to work on anything else}”.

untilHellbanned··on Simple, Upstream, and Decisive: A Heuristic for Medical Progress
> the scientific community systematically favors the unsuccessful approaches

The scientific community doesn't systematically favor unsuccessful approaches. Again, if the author was in the field they would know that's not true.

untilHellbanned··on Simple, Upstream, and Decisive: A Heuristic for Medical Progress
Molecular biologist professor at a med school here. This is what people are already doing. This reads as someone who doesn't know the field very well.
untilHellbanned··on Boosting teeth’s healing ability by mobilizing stem cells in dental pulp
A GSK3 antagonist, lithium, treats bipolar disorder. It's a small world in drug development.
untilHellbanned··on The Neuroscience of Changing Your Mind
> "Lead author Kitty Xu, formerly a Johns Hopkins graduate student and now a researcher at the social media site Pinterest"

Well that's depressing.

untilHellbanned··on Michael Moritz: Silicon Valley Would Be Wise to Follow China's Lead
Multiplying by 0 is still 0.
untilHellbanned··on Michael Moritz: Silicon Valley Would Be Wise to Follow China's Lead
This guy has never created anything.
← PreviousPage 2 of 22Next →