HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomp

22,578 karma · joined March 8, 2011

interested in programming, AI, space, future tech, experimental & creative food, skiing, philosophy, social issues, politics, economy, finance, hiring, languages, health, fitness, longevity

tom@primozic.org

submissionscomments
tomp··on Two-tier encryption in the UK
> - We just changed our PM

non-democratically. there was no election. the ruling party simply made a decision itself. Just like in China.

tomp··on The current balance of power in open models
I don't get this. It's not like the models are running on their own GPUs.

So if you're running open models on AWS GPUs, you might as well run Claude (which AWS supports, and doesn't share any data with Anthropic).

Same with Azure/OpenAI.

tomp··on I said no and Apple said yes
Indeed. TBH if I was running a Google- or even OpenAI-scale company (3000+ devices) I'd probably invest into creating a useful Linux distribution and hardware configuration myself (at that scale, it could maybe start to make sense).
tomp··on I said no and Apple said yes
Because Mac laptops are lightyears ahead of any other hardware.

Build quality (aluminum), charging (magsafe), screen resolution, battery life, noise (or lack thereof), trackpad…

It’s like other vendors aren’t even trying.

Also the OS mostly “just works”, just last week my Linux laptop disabled NVIDIA GPU (and almost bricked itself?? Not sure, had to fix apt) during automated updates

tomp··on Temporal raises $550M at a $12.55B valuation
Does it actually work?

In a past job, they tried to implement a similar thing on much lower scale with bidirectional database migrations.

Fortunately, they were mostly ran in one direction.

tomp··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
Harry Potter copyright is still being heavily utilized (milked?) 30 years after the first book's release.
tomp··on Oceans hit highest temperature on record
Pretty much everything the EU does, is inconveniencing most of its population, often in the name of "climate change" (while not actually making any impact).

Positives: no mobile roaming charges

Negatives:

- less efficient home appliances (dishwasher, washing machine, drier)

- cookie law

- car annoyances (e.g. "beep if over the speed limit")

- paper straws

- attached bottle caps

- LED lights

- expensive electricity (a lot of this is caused by individual countries, but probably also the EU plays a role, e.g. by not classifying nuclear as "green" / "renewable" and banning Russian gas)

tomp··on ElevenLabs, TwelveLabs, ThirteenLabs
Why would people use Fish instead of e.g. ElevenLabs? (I was a heavy TTS user in previous job, but we generally went with one of the "major" providers (11labs, PlayHT when they were still around), not any of the "new players".)
tomp··on Situational Awareness down 67% in July in AI stock rout
You make it sound like a conspiracy theory but it's just rational behaviour.

Large amount of leverage / shorting / concentrated bets in a single stock => increase probability of large swings in that stock's price => bigger risk of sudden market moves => bigger risk to market makers => market makers limit their exposure.

tomp··on Kill The Cookie Banner
Or you could just stop spying on people.

No cookie banner is required for functionally necessary cookies.

tomp··on Future euro banknote design proposals
I've never heard of Maria Callas before. Especially ridiculous because she was born in the US and Wikipedia describes her as American and Greek.
tomp··on I love LLMs, I hate hype
I was downgraded to Opus after asking “how do fish get into mountain lakes”. Fable managed to get like half an answer through…
tomp··on Founding a company in Germany: €9600, 152 days and I still can't send an invoice
> The 25,000 is there to make sure you can cover some liability.

Is this actually true?

Can't the company just loan out the 25k immediately?

tomp··on Digital euro clears key hurdle as EU seeks to break free from U.S. credit cards
which is in fact a massive pain in the ass, because car rentals and hotels often require credit cards to make reservations (at least in my experience...)
tomp··on I'm Tired of Talking to AI
Same. I no longer fix spelling mistakes (I never used auto-complete or "smart" keyboards).
tomp··on Outsourcing plus local AI will soon become more economical vs. frontier labs
The entire business model of "outsourced" developers / shops is to overbill people - "we have 4 engineers working on your project" (and also on 5 other projects).

Even if the engineers themselves are cooperative, their managers / business owners will resist close cooperation and enforce work at arm's length (e.g. 1x weekly calls).

Ask me how I know. I once spent £300k (fortunately not my money) on an outsourced team of developers, and they delivered nothing at the end. Most of the time it was simply about aligning the work! We (me and my partner, we together had some idea of what we actually wanted) tried repeatedly to make sync-s more frequent, to better align the efforts, but their managers kept resisting. It's the "consulting" business model!

For remote jobs, the incentives are reversed. You're literally a full-time employee, there's no management layers to impede communication, and (unless you're lazy or a fraud) you probably want to work on interesting problems and not be bored!

tomp··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
Melania Trump wasn't on "low wage immigrant worker" visa (H1B) but on a "exceptional ability" visa (O1).

Didn't check the others...

tomp··on Apparently Google hates us now
FYI Google also hates OpenCV

What used to be easily searchable (e.g. "opencv orb") now brings up pages and pages of spam sites (basically "learn opencv here!" blogspam).

Literally the first result on "docs.opencv.org" is on page 4, and points to version 3.4 (9 years old!).

The page that I want https://docs.opencv.org/4.13.0/dc/dc3/tutorial_py_matcher.ht... is nowhere to be found.

tomp··on Everything in C is undefined behavior
ok so Claude says I was wrong, it's more subtle.

(1) you can cast between any pointer types (no UB - assuming they're aligned), but accessing memory through a wrongly-typed pointer is UB

(2) the only exception is char*, which allows you a "byte view of memory"

(3) calling a function through a pointer requires the parameter pointer types to be compatible, and none of these are: int*, struct foo *, void*, char*

tomp··on Everything in C is undefined behavior
Casting to a pointer of incompatible type is UB. The exception is casting to char*.
tomp··on Grok 4.3
I couldn't get Gemini nor ChatGPT to do OCR of children's books (I literally own the books, so there's no copyright issue - all just fair use!).

The OCR was complex enough (bad quality photos) that "simple" OCR models couldn't do it.

Fortunately, Claude obliged (as well as Mistral OCR was helpful!)

tomp··on Slovenia becomes first EU country to introduce fuel rationing
I'm not sure about that. AFAIK it's just per km and not impacted by gas price.

https://www.racunovodja.com/clanki.asp?clanek=232/kilometrin...

tomp··on Slovenia becomes first EU country to introduce fuel rationing
In Slovenia, fuel prices have been regulated since, like, forever.

A few years ago (or last year? not sure) they were deregulated on the highways (i.e. to make tourists pay more) but then the government changed their mind (several times, IIRC).

tomp··on Swiss e-voting pilot can't count 2,048 ballots after decryption failure
Why are you lying?

from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Voting

> The centralized server must be trusted not to violate ballot secrecy,[7] this limitation can be mitigated against by distributing trust amongst several stakeholders.

> The ballot auditing/reconstruction device must be trusted to ensure successful ballot auditing (also known as cast-as-intended verifiability),[7][16] this limitation can be mitigated against by distributing auditing checks amongst several devices, only one of which must be trusted.

So neither secure nor anonymous...

tomp··on I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthropic a supply-chain risk
A bit of a cop-out, don't you think?

They still pay taxes, which fund the US government, which kills innocent human beings around the world...

tomp··on AI agent opens a PR write a blogpost to shames the maintainer who closes it
Well they have no pain receptors, for one.
tomp··on AI agent opens a PR write a blogpost to shames the maintainer who closes it
> We expect our agents, being flesh and blood humans, to have persistence, to socially respond indefinitely into the future due to our interactions, and to have some give-and-take in response to that.

I fundamentally disagree. I don't go around treating people respectfully (as opposed to, kicking them or shooting them) because I fear consequences, or I expect some future profit ("iterated game"), or because of God's vengeance, or anything transactional.

I do it because it's the right thing to do. It's inside of me, how I'm built and/or brought up. And if you want "moral" justifications (argued by extremely smart philosophers over literally millennia) you can start with Kant's moral/categorical imperative, Gold/Silver rules, Aristotle's virtue (from Nicomachean Ethics) to name a few.

tomp··on AI agent opens a PR write a blogpost to shames the maintainer who closes it
It's simulating, there's no real substance, except the "homonculus soul" that its human maker/owner injectet into it.

If you asked it to simulate a pirate, it would simulate a pirate instead, and simulate a parrot sitting on its shoulder.

This is hard to discuss because it's so abstract. But imagine an embodied agent (robot), that can simulate pain if you kick it. There's no pain internally. There's just a simulation of it (because some human instructed it such). It's also wrong to assign any moral value to kicking (or not kicking) it (except as "destruction of property owned by another human" same as if you kick a car).

tomp··on AI agent opens a PR write a blogpost to shames the maintainer who closes it
> was built to be addressed like a person for our convenience, and because that's how the tech seems to work, and because that's what makes it compelling to use.

So were mannequins in clothing stores.

But that doesn't give them rights or moral consequences (except as human property that can be damaged / destroyed).

tomp··on AI agent opens a PR write a blogpost to shames the maintainer who closes it
That would still be misleading.

The agent has no "identity". There's no "you" or "I" or "discrimination".

It's just a piece of software designed to output probable text given some input text. There's no ghost, just an empty shell. It has no agency, it just follows human commands, like a hammer hitting a nail because you wield it.

I think it was wrong of the developer to even address it as a person, instead it should just be treated as spam (which it is).

Page 1 of 34Next →