HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwaway23838

1 karma · joined September 9, 2020

submissionscomments
throwaway23838··on The Humiliating Practice of Sex-Testing Female Athletes
You can still follow and appreciate lower tiers in the leagues if you want to.

You could still say 'Serena Williams is killing it this year in Level 14 tennis' if you wanted to.

What is so special about these people that means we should know about them compared to someone of another gender, or no gender, that plays better?

throwaway23838··on The Humiliating Practice of Sex-Testing Female Athletes
Well... why not?

If I'm a terrible player at the moment who can I play against? If I could play against the 14-year-olds I might be able to get a game.

Why not let everyone play according to their ability, not matter what their age or 'gender' or whatever other discriminations we can think of?

throwaway23838··on The Humiliating Practice of Sex-Testing Female Athletes
> With that in mind, how could you possibly arrange a soccer league, arranged by performance level, in which women were able to compete in meaningful numbers?

I don't really understand your question. We can have as many levels to our leagues as we want. As many women can play as they want. Maybe all the women will be in lower tier leagues, maybe some will be in the higher tiers. Why's that a problem? They're still getting to play the sport with opponents around their level.

Isn't that the point of playing a sport? Playing a game with people who can challenge you. You can still play at the highest tier your ability will support. We can televise a lower tier if we want to. You can still support and follow a lower tier. What's missing from this model in your mind?

throwaway23838··on The Humiliating Practice of Sex-Testing Female Athletes
If people really want to differentiate between men and women for some reason I can't understand they could still say themselves 'top person identifying as a woman'. Just don't make it part of the official system so other people can ignore it if they want.

You could be the 'only woman in level 4 sprinting'.

And wouldn't it be better for women - if they're able to push beyond other women and also compete with men? There would certainly be men in lower tiers than the top tier women.

throwaway23838··on The Humiliating Practice of Sex-Testing Female Athletes
Maybe it's time to stop separating sports competitors into binary genders.

We already separate people into performance levels - why not do that irrespective of 'gender'? People would still be able to be 'top' of their performance level, it just wouldn't be called a 'woman' level or 'man' level anymore.