HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thawaway1837

1,099 karma · joined September 24, 2019

submissionscomments
thawaway1837··on It’s Time to Get Back to RSS
Mozilla should be focusing on RSS within Thunderbird, because that was the original location for RSS functionality, and is a much better fit anyways (due to the expected presence of an almost always open left hand sidebar.

Unfortunately Mozilla has dropped thunderbird almost completely so that’s not been a real option either.

thawaway1837··on How Etsy became America’s unlikeliest breadbasket
I’ve never heard of any company that has fired someone (which usually implies that it was with cause, as opposed to a lay-off, which does not imply a cause, but rather that the company needed to do cost cutting) giving them a severance package.

And I really doubt Etsy has the clout to blackball anyone in the technology industry.

thawaway1837··on Show HN: New UI pattern for file manager type apps
Because casual users are exploring Github looking for new UI patterns for file manager apps?

The audience is clearly not casual users.

And why does the README have to be a pitch?

thawaway1837··on US blocks shipments of semiconductors to Huawei
Yes, Trump did something about China.

He got rid of the most effective global efforts to contain China’s growth through the TPP. I know HN hates the TPP because of amorphous claims about IP, but flouting IP norms forms the entire basis of these actions by Trump, and the whole point of TPP’a IP protections (which HN hated, apparently) was to make sure China’s neighbors would not flout IP protections the way China did, giving private companies incentives to move manufacturing and research from China to the neighboring countries instead.

That would have been a broad ranging global effort to ensure China followed rules, that would have cost the US nothing (in fact other countries were making concessions to the US for it), and would not have required 2-3 years of barely legal efforts to contain 1 Chinese company and even there only in the US market, but would have instead affected all Chinese companies, non Chinese companies manufacturing in China, and not just the US market but also eastern Asian and Australasian markets.

So yeah, if by Trump did something you mean he dismantled an effort that would have been more effective by orders of magnitude and cost the US nothing but actually won it more friends in favor of a barely legal effort that is pissing off even allies that are not friendly to China and has taken 3 years to maybe impact 1 Chinese company, then sure.

thawaway1837··on The economic devastation of the pandemic could kill more people than the virus
Not having a lockdown would not have avoided economic devastation.

As pretty much every data point shows, in the US, the drastic drop off of economic activity happened well before the actual lockdowns. States saw drops in economic activity in the days leading to lockdowns that was 80-90% as much as the drop that happened during the lockdown.

So the trade off wasn’t COVID deaths and a better economy, vs fewer COVID deaths and a worse economy. The trade off was a lot of COVID deaths, potentially triggering devastating cliffs, and a terrible economy, or fewer COVID deaths, and a slightly more terrible economy.

thawaway1837··on Comparing Ember Octane and React
To be fair, JavaScript is also an extremely bad OOP language.

And I’m not complaining about its prototypical inheritance either (I actually like it), but the fact that it tries to hide its prototypical nature under a Java like veneer.

thawaway1837··on Comparing Ember Octane and React
It’s hardly JS developers who think functional programming is cool. Scala became huge in the JVM world because of its functional nature. Kotlin includes a lot of functional programming, and Java itself continues to add functional capabilities.

And if you look at the .Net side of things, C# has basically been on a path to look increasingly like F# with every release. And of course, LINQ, one of C#’s most popular features, is little more than a functional subset of C#.

Arguably its backend developers moving to the front end who have been trying to bring functional concepts to front end programming.

thawaway1837··on Comparing Ember Octane and React
This was my favorite part about Ember, and what I miss the most.

The Ember team is one of the least dogmatic teams that I have come across, and has been willing to change their entire strategy when presented with a better idea (while providing a well defined and fairly convenient upgrade path).

I still remember when React first came out, and showed how one way binding was so much better than 2 way bindings, and the Ember team was able to quickly switch to this new philosophy via DDAU, while still providing an easy upgrade path for our code. And all this was before 1.0 if I remember correctly.

thawaway1837··on Comparing Ember Octane and React
I don’t think that’s what he is talking about here though. And note, his point about the multiple files isnt even a complaint.

As someone who worked with Ember in the past (our company inherited a new product with an acquisition so we were forced to change tech stacks), this comment really comes from the fact that Ember has a very comprehensive file layout system. And one of the major criticisms about Ember classic was how different core pieces for the same component, were located in so many distant folders (hence the comment about colocation of component code, which seems trivial, but is a huge usability gain IMO).

I think that sentence should be read more as a reflection on Ember, than suggesting the author does not think React components can be broken into multiple files, and hence an indication of their knowledge of react.

thawaway1837··on Comparing Ember Octane and React
I dislike convention over configuration big time. It’s the reason I could never do RoR as much as I tried to learn it when moving from C/C++ dev to more web dev.

But it’s definitely not the worst idea. People who like that approach seem to be extremely productive with it.

It’s definitely not my cup of tea though.

thawaway1837··on Comparing Ember Octane and React
Having interacted with Core Ember devs I would be very surprised if the author didn’t know anything about React. I’d wager that he indeed knows a lot about React.

At least the ones I interacted with did not only know React, they knew it well enough to identify its pitfalls, and be able to translate what they believed to be its best parts to EmberJs.

Also, the comment about different files is a thing even outside this example (and is one reason I prefer react over Ember personally). React has no defined file system, and strongly encourages components are written in a single file. Ember, OTOH, does a lot of file separation, and a lot of convention over configuration.

thawaway1837··on Elon Musk reopening Tesla factory despite Alameda County order
Trying to pass off CPAP machines as ventilators, promising that there will be no cases in middle April, and promoting conspiracy theories that the number of deaths have been inflated, when they are almost certainly understated. Yeah, Musk is definitely the guy I wanna be taking advice from in this crisis.

And that’s before we even get to promising to send a submarine to save some trapped kids, and when the person who actually helped save them instead of the mythical submarine says it wouldn’t work calling him a paedophile.

thawaway1837··on Elon Musk reopening Tesla factory despite Alameda County order
Is Elon Musk gonna be working in the factory and traveling to and from it possibly using public transport, or even just a regular car, but having to pick up coffee from the drive thru on the way?

It’s not civil disobedience if you’re getting a bunch of other people to do it on your behalf.

Elon Musk is no Rosa Parks.

thawaway1837··on Scraping Recipe Websites
“Why doesn’t everyone who is putting information out there for free not cater to exactly my needs”.

What an utter load of bollocks. These are people who are creating something that they enjoy doing and giving you information you apparently need for free. I don’t understand why anyone would trash their desire to write something that is personal and/or interesting to them about it.

And that’s setting aside that these usually make the recipes far more readable and interesting to the vast majority of people.

thawaway1837··on Wuhan lab phone records show 'possible shutdown' in October
So the whole 5 eyes report has basically been exposed as likely a fabrication at best, and they are coming up with some other nonsense now.

It’s clear FUD.

And all this does not change the fact that whether it escaped a lab or not is completely irrelevant (other than the fact that it makes the Trump admins decision to pull US researchers from the lab even worse, since if they hadn’t pulled them to save peanuts, and it did escape from a lab, the US and the world would have been aware of this in October).

There is no reason to believe Western countries, many of which did not start acting until late March although information about the CoronaVirus has existed since the beginning of the year at the latest, and Asian countries had already started acting on it in mid Jan to Feb, would have behaved any differently.

thawaway1837··on Apple Leaks Reveal Radical New MacBook Pro
How is there no substance to it?

I heard people say the same stuff about Apple slowing down performance on iOS. People complained about it for months and years, and Apple fans and “Geniuses” gaslighted everybody by saying they were just imagining it, until we found out that Apple was actually doing it. The reason they did it was not bad, but the lack of transparency was.

We also saw the same thing with the keyboards. People complained about the terrible reliability and how it was overall just worse for years, and not until later, esp when Casey Johnston I believe documented her keyboard experience, people kept telling others it was a matter of preference and anecdote != data, to the point that Apple, after 3 revisions, basically went back to the earlier design.

The anti-Apple sentiment can be tiring, but a lot of it is driven by the rabid pro Apple sentiment that assumes nothing Apple does can be wrong.

Specifically, even if x86 is not more open than ARM, if you believe that Apples implementation of ARM would be more open than what they have right now, then you are clearly relying on faith that is not backed up by any evidence at all. Apple for the past decade or so has been on a steady and consistent path of locking things down on both iOS and MacOS and they will proudly tell you about it as well.

Again, I don’t even entirely disagree with their locking things down (I’ve seen how much more comfortable novices can be with iOS than MacOS, although, at the same time, I’ve seen the same novices grow with MacOS in terms of stuff they can do in ways I haven’t with iOS), but that doesn’t change the fact that it is entirely reasonable to assume that if Apple changes from 3rd party processors to in house ones they will likely lock things down further.

thawaway1837··on GeckoView for Android
It makes a difference though. The fact that Chromium is Electron’s backend is why MS picked Chromium to base Edge off. It’s likely they would have chosen something else if that wasn’t the case (or maybe continued with their own web tech).
thawaway1837··on A look at modern PHP
For a more or less static website, what’s probably the best bet, and has been the standard for many years, largely because it allows the non technical restaurant owner to easily update and make changes, is Wordpress.

In which case you’re back again in PHP land.

thawaway1837··on Juul Is Moving Base From San Francisco to Washington, D.C.
Juul is a huge opportunity for big tobacco.

It’s a way to get the kids hooked and make them life long customers.

thawaway1837··on US unprepared for an electrical grid collapse, but it costs only $300M
A lot of people feel similarly.

And almost all those people are people whose lives will not be affected negatively by 4 more years of the terrible administration, so they get to enjoy moral outrage while others bear the burden of feeding their moral indignation.

On the other hand, people whose lives are actually getting destroyed don’t have the same luxury. On a personal note, I have colleagues whose entire lives have been upturned thanks to this administration, but fortunately they are extremely skilled so they were simply able to recall rate by building their lives elsewhere in a country where the administration is not trying to make their lives miserable. The same cannot be said for the many millions of others who are suffering negatively thanks to the admin (especially the many tens of thousands who will be dead due to COVID who wouldn’t have been in a bare minimum competent admin).

thawaway1837··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
Yeah, and this isn’t even an equivalent situation.

A more comparable situation is if Ford had requested his supplier send him a certain type of screw but the supplier sent him a completely different type of screw because it was “better”. It may be better. But it may also be absolutely the wrong thing to build Ford cars out of because they weren’t designed to use it.

And that’s what Canonical often seems to forget. Ubuntu isn’t just a product. It’s also infrastructure, and an individual (although critical) part in many other products and systems.

And AFAICT Ubuntu as a product is far less popular, and pays far less of the bill than Ubuntu as infrastructure, which is why their actions are doubly incomprehensible.

thawaway1837··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
The difference between systemd and snap is that systemd has been validated by almost all the major distro makers. The exceptions are largely people who don’t want systemd precisely because of systemd’s popularity, and they want to retain some diversity in the ecosystem.

Canonical could barely get its own users to prefer snaps over the alternatives, which is why they are forcing it onto them.

thawaway1837··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
Without commenting on the quality of snaps, I find Canonical replacing the App Store that supported all 3 distribution methods, with one that drops support for flatpak, and prioritizes snaps over .deb to the extent it will display a snap result over an exact matching .deb result in a search extremely user hostile.

And the fact that they first did it in an LTS release seriously jeopardises the trust is have in canonical. This is a deprecation which may have significant undetermined consequences. This is exactly the kind of change they should have introduced in 19.04 and then used the ensuing year to iron out any issues before 20.04 LTS.

What this tells me, however, is that for Canonical their business interests are placed above ensuring the stability of the LTS release, and that’s extremely disappointing to say the least.

thawaway1837··on Operating Systems Without Systemd
If someone is able to create something that is half as good as systemd then distros will switch time it.

The thing is that systemd solves a lot of problems for distros in a good enough way (frankly, currently in a way that is better than any existing alternative) that they are happy to have systemd deal with those issues while they focus on the stuff the distro makers are interested in.

thawaway1837··on Japan to subsidize 100% of salaries at small companies
Individual bankruptcies are not bad.

Mass bankruptcies are terrible.

thawaway1837··on Amazon AppFlow
The vast majority of successful tech companies definitely treat their code as assets.

I think you’re confusing 2 things. The technical and developmental side, where code is a liability that needs to be maintained, and the business/usage side, where code is definitely an asset that provides your company with additional leverage against competitors.

thawaway1837··on The epidemiologist behind Sweden’s controversial coronavirus strategy
The whole thing is clearly an attempt at a graceful exit.

The original strategy was herd immunity. The argument being made was that Sweden was gonna get infected anyways, so better to get it out of the way sooner rather than later, while protecting the at risk. And this would reduce economic harm as well.

However, the Swedish decision makers seemed completely unaware of asymptomatic carriers, which led to the at risk (largely old people) being heavily exposed anyways due to the asymptomatic younger workers around them infecting them.

Further, the Swedish people, reflecting normal human behavior, shut down economic activity anyways.

The result was a slight linear short term economic benefit but an exponential, potentially long term, downwards public health situation whose economic effects itself will likely dwarf the direct economic benefit anyways.

So now that their plan has failed both in concept and execution they are changing their story saying that it was a Swedish cultural thing, where they trusted individual Swedes to take personal responsibility, because of the exceptional Swedish character.

thawaway1837··on Lung damage in recovered Covid sufferers apparently permanent, research finds
Every single human being has preexisting conditions.
thawaway1837··on Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers
There’s a lot of confidence there for lack of hiring blacklists when Google, Apple, etc are known to have shared hiring data with each other to underpay new hires.
thawaway1837··on West’s incompetent response to pandemic will hasten the power-shift to the east
The US, today, has a whole horde of influential people (including the President, probably) who are attacking Dr Fauci.

At a time where the virus and its lethality is undeniable, and Fauci isn’t even just a random doctor, but probably one of the most decorated doctor in the past few decades.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →