HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stby

187 karma · joined December 21, 2020

submissionscomments
stby··on European crash tester says carmakers must bring back physical controls
Seems to be a US Navy thing (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655#Potential_...).

On a more serious note, there's a big difference between a vehicle like a car that is operated by one person, and a ship with a large crew with dedicated tasks.

stby··on American drivers even more distracted by phones. Pedestrian deaths are soaring
Nah, it's just good situational awareness.
stby··on American drivers even more distracted by phones. Pedestrian deaths are soaring
Story time. I find myself to be pushing a stroller around a lot these days, and the number of times where I have to wait behind some obstacles to make place for another stroller, kids, someone in a wheelchair, a blind person, old people with walkers, is much higher than I thought it would be when I was just my agile, young self. I'm sure they'd all love to dive bomb away from cars that are running into them.
stby··on American drivers even more distracted by phones. Pedestrian deaths are soaring
I don't think that's an unpopular opinion at all, but it's still just victim blaming. People are run over on sidewalks, cyclists on cycling paths or just standing at red lights. There's basically only one type of road user that is a danger to anyone else [0], the focus should be to make drivers less dangerous and not to make everyone else even more aware. Where I live people already wear high-viz clothing when riding a bike or even just going for a walk, but still get run over.

[0] https://transport.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2021-11/collisio...

stby··on EU right to repair: Sellers liable for 1 year after products are fixed
I haven't seen this before, that's awesome!

But even there I feel like the cookie banner at least offers some benefit to me, whereas all the other modals asking to send me notifications, subscribe to stuff, register here, follow us there, are completely superfluous and we should push back against those first.

stby··on Tens of thousands protest in Germany against the rise of the far right
Even the parties in power hardly share the same politics on most topics.
stby··on Tens of thousands protest in Germany against the rise of the far right
I am German without an immigration background and wonder about this, too.
stby··on [dead]
Something about correlation and causation comes to my mind. When you start an article listing all the known causes and they all relate to a high income (people in cities have more money, people in richer countries have more money, people with better education have more money, people with electricity have more money), why would you just dismiss this relation and claim that it's something else that seems to correlate nicely with high income as well (cities have more lights, richer countries have more lights, people with better education have more lights, people with electricity have more lights)? Surely a proof that high income is not the root cause is needed here.

Also, I don't really see the supposed collapse of birth rates after 2015, at least it doesn't seem half as drastic as those in the 70s (which can be explained by people having more money) or the ones caused by war.

stby··on Are roads the biggest driver of ecological destruction?
About flying cars, I don't think they are a solution to almost anything.

First of all, they'd always need more energy because staying in the air doesn't come free. Lifting a whole car for the usual 1.2 people in it seems wasteful.

Secondly, the noise problem would be huge. I don't see how flying cars could ever be more quiet than road-using cars (again, more power needed to overcome the drag that's generated by the lift, and propellers, jet engines or whatever aren't exactly quiet on their own). They'd also produce their noise up in the air where it can spread over a much larger area compared to land-based transportation, where even a small line of greenery reduces noise levels quite nicely.

Finally, even perfectly self flying cars (and obviously, I wouldn't want to have the average car driver handle a 3 ton flying machine over my head) would need a big amount of space around them in all directions. I doubt that there's enough air space to handle the amount of car traffic that even smaller cities currently have.

There's a reason we only see helicopters used in a small niche, and I don't think flying cars or the currently worked on drones are ultimately that different from helicopters.

stby··on UK 2022 rail station flow images
The complicated part (visualising the number of passengers on the correct paths) was done well, but I'm really missing the simple part: Placing a little marker where the initial station is located.
stby··on Windows 12: Savior of PC makers, or just an apology for Windows 11?
Does 10 really have less ads and telemetry, though? 10 is still getting updates and a lot of annoying "features" seem to get back ported (like the "fact of the day" thing in the search bar that always opens Bing), and I've never seen any proof that 11 actually does collect even more data than 10.

Not defending 11 here, it's just that 10 was pretty ill received here an hn and ever since 11 came out, the opinions suddenly changed, which seems a bit weird to me.

stby··on Why do programmers need private offices with doors?
I can only second this. I honestly had the best time of my (professional) life when I had a little room with the rest of my team.

Asking quick questions in such an environment is also not that much of a disturbance because most people are working on similar features at the moment and there's a high chance that they don't need to do the whole context switch to assist you. It's really highly productive.

For the times where you really needed some time for yourself, headphones work just fine. I wouldn't want to wear them all the time as even the best ones become uncomfortable after few hours, but that's also not really needed in a small shared room.

stby··on Trains were designed to break down after third-party repairs, hackers find
npm add block-repair-shop. It can happen so fast.
stby··on Desktop GUI Is an Efficient and Fulfilling Way of Human-Computer Interaction
So, how are desktop apps supposed to solve any of the identified downsides of the app?

> Too much bloat as one software must cater to everyone’s needs.

Yes, maybe, but especially web apps are usually quite focused on a limited feature set, in my experience. Isn't the usual prime example of bloat (Microsoft Office) a desktop app?

> Open invitation to authoritarian software like DRMs, Adware, blobs, etc.

So there's no DRM or Adware in desktop apps? Surely the author can't be serious about this one. At least a browser gives me simple tools to control them, for installed desktop applications it becomes much harder.

> Use of Internet as propaganda tool.

Sure, but on the other hand I would argue that Twitter works well as a website and there's no need for a desktop application. It's actually great that I don't need to install anything to access it.

> Inefficient and bloated JavaScript.

Fair enough. I do however think that, by now, there are many "time-tested and efficient best practices" in the world of web development. The web world isn't moving half as fast as critics like to pretend, and the underlying technologies have stood the test of time remarkably well. I think time-tested is actually one of the main reasons that web technologies are as popular and successful as they are.

stby··on Show HN: A JavaScript function that looks and behaves like a pipe operator
I had a hard time reading the example until I applied the "normal" JS indentation, that would also likely be applied by Prettier and the likes.

  V(greeting,         // initial value  "hi"
      V(capitalize),  // custom function call  "Hi"
      V.concat("!"),  // String method `concat` call  "Hi!"
      V(send),        // custom async function call  Promise { <pending> }
      V.status,       // automatic promise chaining + getting property  Promise { 200 }
      V(console.log), // automatic promise chaining + global function call  logs 200
  )

It's certainly a nice usage of JavaScript's Proxy object and the resulting syntax is simple to grasp. Also glad to see the TS definitions in there. Well done!
stby··on Remove Taiwan flag – Taiwan is not a country
As someone who has worked a lot with geo data and delivered them to end users, this here is just the tip of the iceberg.

Languages are already quite political, but maps and all their borders and city names are much worse. Some borders are disputed and both sides have made the distribution of maps with the "wrong" borders illegal, the Catalans hate to see the Spanish names of their towns used in the Spanish version of the website, sometimes borders are moving fast and the inhabitants of newly founded countries usually feel really strong about the correct representation on every single map in the world, and even if you use maps without borders or labels at all, it could be illegal to plot some kind of harmless data on it, like wind speeds that have not been published by the country's authorities.

Stuff like this inevitably floods the inboxes of a lot of companies, so I'm not surprised at all to see it happen on GitHub.

stby··on Remove Taiwan flag – Taiwan is not a country
It's just a service for the Swiss to warn them about the occasional use of "ß".
stby··on Apple Vision predictive bio-feedback
This quickly becomes creepy beyond my wildest imaginations. Kill it with fire, please.
stby··on Is it OK to recline your airplane seat? Some travel experts say no
What the article doesn't mention, maybe because it's not a global thing yet, is that non-reclining seats have been introduced in the last year. On flights within Europe I haven't had a reclining seat in ages, no matter whether flying on an LCC or flag carrier. I don't think there was any uproar about that change.
stby··on US iPhone market share up, in declining market, as people switch from Android
No, that's really not the case. Facebook's reputation is not good at all here (in Europe), whereas people are shilling for Apple all the time. It's just really nice to have a messenger that is not tied to a hardware platform, and WhatsApp became popular before it was bought by Facebook.
stby··on Microsoft: Windows 10 22H2 is the final version of Windows 10
I don't know why everbody keeps bringing this up. They could have called Windows 11 Windows 10 Gold Edition or whatever to keep the "10" in the name, but frankly we should all be thankful that they didn't.
stby··on Lego breaks ground on first US manufacturing facility
The factory in Switzerland was closed shortly after that in 2002. Lego really struggled in the late 90s / early 00s.
stby··on Microsoft tests Windows account menu error badge when Microsoft Account not used
Ironically, macOS already shows an error message when an account is not using iCloud.

Using both macOS and Windows 11 on an almost daily basis, they are really not that different when it comes to nagging users. Both show full-screen displays on startup from time to time where they want to change some settings (activating Siri, using Edge as default browser, ...), try to sell additional services, make you use an online account, and come with a lot of bloatware.

stby··on Microsoft tests Windows account menu error badge when Microsoft Account not used
Pretty sure this day is today. It probably doesn't matter much on a personal device, but my company-issued test and dev iPhone has several "unread" suggestions that I can't seem to remove.
stby··on Windows 12 Plans Reveal a Bold Redesign, Tighter Security, AI-Powered Features
If the screenshot in the article is any indication of what is to come, they at least didn't change the design language again and there is no indication of a new UI framework.

Applications that work and look good in Windows 11 are likely to look good in Windows 12. It doesn't look like a reboot at all and more in line with the regular changes that we have seen within Windows 10 between the larger updates.

stby··on Stack Overflow is a cacheless, 9-server on-prem monolith
This one: https://twitter.com/sahnlam/status/1629713961951330304?s=20
stby··on Tell HN: Windows 10 might have tricked you into using a online account
You do need an Apple account to use the App Store on macOS, unlike on Windows. With the App Store being the only place to download XCode, which in turn is required to use all the good stuff like Homebrew, the result for me and probably most people on HN is roughly the same.

Also, the macOS system preferences nag the user until iCloud is activated.

stby··on Widening highways doesn’t fix traffic
You may want to read the article then, it's full of examples to prove that the concept is not silly.

> No one's like "there's a new lane on the 5 and it's not moving any faster than it was before, I think I'll start taking it".

The point here is that the new lane does actually "solve" traffic immediately after it has been opened. The improved travel times create the demand and eventually this leads to more congestion.

stby··on Widening highways doesn’t fix traffic
You may like this article [1] from the Financial Times about how the urban sprawl of cities in the UK makes them unproductive.

[1] https://www.ft.com/content/a45e028d-4b81-4bef-9546-970838ab9...

stby··on Does the world have enough lithium to move to electric vehicles?
I agree with anything you said. At this point I'm already happy when the media doesn't try to praise drones (Volocopter, Lilium, Joby, ...) as the ultimate solution to our traffic problems, unfortunately.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →