HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smelendez

2,654 karma · joined February 22, 2007

submissionscomments
smelendez··on CS240 AI Cheating Retrospective
Yeah, and sizeof and malloc are very easily things students could have been exposed to in high school or their own studies. I’ve seen C books that use them in the first chapter.

It’s fine to say solve this problem using the following tools, but not great to say “if you find another approach, I assume cheating.”

smelendez··on How often do you think about the 1893 World's Fair?
Yes, I was confused by the article’s claim there was no ragtime at the fair. Was his work not ragtime by that point?
smelendez··on Claude Opus 5.5
This is a more normal English meaning in my opinion — you picture a sentry patrolling a border.
smelendez··on Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in all subscriptions
Yeah, I actually canceled Netflix when they started making it impossible to look at the available shows without seeing previews of each of them. I am trying to leisurely decide what I want to watch, not have 15 different actors scream catchphrases at me.
smelendez··on Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in all subscriptions
Yeah, those kinds of ads are always aggravating to me because you’re not even making money by showing them to me. They feel like a display of power more than anything else.
smelendez··on Deodands put a price on objects that caused death
I think the author confused the concept of movable property — meaning personal property, as in not real estate — with a requirement that the object be in motion.
smelendez··on Astra for Law
Yeah, and you can already get fill in the blank legal forms for a lot of basic situations, including leases, wills, employment agreements, etc.

The interesting question is whether AI can fill a niche these can’t — or, alternatively, help a layperson evaluate a contract they’re asked to sign better than they could themselves.

smelendez··on iOS 27, iPadOS 27, and macOS 27
So many platforms with search have a variation of this problem now.

The other issue with Mac search is that it never tells you when it’s done, so you can’t tell if it searched and failed to find something or is still searching.

smelendez··on Apple's Siri AI Can Be Swapped Out for Claude, ChatGPT, Code Shows
> This was frustrating for me as it always prompted “who cares? Just turn off the lights.”

I guess you should be able to create a bucket of low-risk tasks that require zero authentication, like letting your guests turn off the lights. I do get why they are cautious, though, because in some cases this could be a security risk, like a burglar turning off lights from outside the home.

smelendez··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
I don’t think a train conductor would normally intervene if they saw someone escorting an intoxicated person.

Unfortunately taking someone somewhere to rob or assault them doesn’t look that different from taking a drunk friend to a safe place.

smelendez··on Waymo pulls over, calls cops on juvenile riders who had 'ghost gun"
I’m not sure the line is that clear.

Any gun shooting projectiles out of a moving vehicle is dangerous. Pellet guns and paintball guns are less dangerous than “regular” guns, but they’re not really toys.

smelendez··on What do Visa and Mastercard do? An intro to card networks
Yes, cash is also physically dirty!

Another advantage of credit cards is you normally don’t have to touch anything customers bring into the store, since they can tap their own cards. You probably still should wear gloves to handle food and take them off or switch them to work the computer.

smelendez··on What do Visa and Mastercard do? An intro to card networks
I use credit for the purchase protection (I believe many debit cards have this as well but it’s easier when you haven’t yet paid the charge, and seems better enshrined in law for credit), for the rewards (which including signup bonuses can be huge), for the float period, and for security — if somebody fraudulently uses a credit card versus a debit card, there’s no actual money missing while the situation gets resolved.
smelendez··on What do Visa and Mastercard do? An intro to card networks
Well, they still pay a fee, it’s just reduced.

They primarily don’t deal with cash because cash is a pain. It needs to be physically taken to a bank and protected from theft by both staff and random robbers with guns, it needs to be counted all the time, and you need to maintain the right denominations to make change.

I have reservations about businesses getting rid of cash, especially if they’re turning away people who don’t have alternative ways to pay, but I certainly understand why they do it.

It’s also always awkward when a coffee shop is like 95% credit, and you try to hand them cash and they look at you like you’re Rip Van Winkle.

smelendez··on Muse – Meta’s personal AI agent
I’ve heard this recently too.

It’s confusing because of the streamer convention of referring to their actively chatting audience as “chat,” which had also entered broader slang use.

I saw one online use that seemed ambiguous, but I realized it referred to ChatGPT and that the poster was the exact type of guy who would be totally unaware of streamer culture despite being my age.

smelendez··on Urban Congestion Pricing and the Response Times of Emergency Medical Services
Yes, or the train. All of these cities have a mix of public transit modes.

> Cities around the world, including London, Stockholm, Milan, and most recently, New York City (NYC), have adopted congestion pricing, charging drivers a fee to enter high-traffic zones.

smelendez··on Lawmakers added $1 to car insurance policies. That money paid for Flock cameras
First degree, etc. murder isn’t just a pop culture distinction. It’s in the law in various states, notably New York, from where it’s found its way into TV cop shows.

New York also has five degrees of arson: https://ypdcrime.com/penal.law/article150.php

smelendez··on Lawmakers added $1 to car insurance policies. That money paid for Flock cameras
> I feel like it's a mistake for the legal code to distinguish between what are fully interchangeable terms in the language the code is supposedly written in.

I’ve thought about this too. They often vary from state to state as well. But the alternative would be to create new legal terms, which would be more confusing, or use just use numbers, which would be hard for laypeople to discuss.

smelendez··on Zohran and the Short Link
That makes sense. You’d basically want to standardize/slugify the path on creation and each access.
smelendez··on Nvidia agrees to acquire Hugging Face for $13B
I think failing to take advantage of the charisma of both Lina Khan and Janet Yellen, and not making them public-facing economics gurus like Alan Greenspan or Larry Summers historically were, was a huge tactical mistake by Biden.
smelendez··on XCancel and Nitter are receiving C&D letters from XCorp
People really do not want to give up the reach once they have tasted it.

It’s a shame: I remember when people would be so excited to get 100 strangers visiting their blogs but in a month, but now someone blogging for an audience like that would seem a little crazy, maybe paradoxically even overly grandiose.

Also, the harm from using X is complex. It basically comes from endorsing the site and encouraging other people to come there where they’ll be exposed to a cesspit of bigotry and right-wing ideas. It’s easy to tell yourself that what you’re doing there outweighs the cons, and that other sites are just as bad, etc.

smelendez··on A brief history of federal lift ticket regulation
Yes, exactly. Same issue with cellphones: They’re more powerful and have better cameras, but many people are paying more to use the same apps they used a decade ago, even though inflation numbers say they’re getting a better deal.
smelendez··on A brief history of federal lift ticket regulation
This is an issue with all kinds of products and services, from residential university education to cars to restaurant food.

Expensive options with lots of extras that not everybody wants—and some may actively dislike—replace broadly affordable options with fewer bells and whistles. Everyone is catering to the whales and, thanks in part to our robust lending industries, trying to convince the minnows that they can be a whale too.

smelendez··on I like 'em thick: an apology to my English teachers
Twain can be tedious because he’s a humorist and we’ve heard those jokes a million times by now. Also he writes speech in dialect which now means nothing to us and makes him harder to read. I find him easier to read as an adult but he can still be a slog.

I think a lot of classic American lit is hard as an American kid because it’s removed enough from today that you don’t get the nuances and also so influential that the storytelling feels trite, even if it was revolutionary at the time.

smelendez··on Why Microsoft Entertainment Pack had a sticker announcing that it had Tetris?
The sticker part makes sense, but why did it say "now," which usually would imply it once didn't include Tetris? I guess "includes Tetris!" just sounded awkward on its own?

Or maybe they made stickers for the contingency where they would ship some without Tetris, get the license, and ship some more with?

smelendez··on Error by AI scribe during medical appointment leaves patient devastated
Yeah, I suspect the problem here is that computer transcription makes mistakes and then a summarizing LLM treats whatever it outputs as gospel.

Automated transcription for anything official is scary to begin with, because some noise in the background is all it takes to turn "I've never taken mushrooms" to "I take mushrooms," or whatever. And then the LLM will simply report "Patient reported using mushrooms."

smelendez··on How Bluesky draws its logo on screenshots
Yeah, health information is interesting in general because it needs to be kept strictly secret from unauthorized people, but people also often need or want to share their own information and have every legal and moral right to do so.
smelendez··on How Bluesky draws its logo on screenshots
Yes, it is very annoying. But I think they are already tracking you.

They want use to use the share button so your recipient is more likely to open Spotify (or whatever app) themselves.

smelendez··on How Bluesky draws its logo on screenshots
Yeah, I would rather see a warning in that case that the screenshot could contain sensitive information, with options to take a redacted screenshot or a normal one.
smelendez··on How Bluesky draws its logo on screenshots
I want those things included, at least by default. A screenshot normally captures the user’s screen size, brightness, zoom level, font choices, etc.

It is often important to people that the screenshot is an accurate record of what was on the screen.

Page 1 of 23Next →