HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

skue

1,445 karma · joined February 28, 2011

submissionscomments
skue··on Inside the Mind of Thru-Hiking's Devious Con Man
Prosecutorial discretion. Given the circumstances it’s hard to imagine someone thinking that the FB edits deserve prosecution. Can you imagine convincing a jury that this deserves a felony conviction, or a judge handing down any sort of meaningful sentence? (IANAL)
skue··on Swift: Accomplishing Dynamic Dispatch on PATs (Protocol with Associated Types)
The problem with this is that any time you add a subclass to Animal, you need to manually update AnyAnimal to handle it.

It’s possible to do this more generically, because you know the animal’s type in the AnyAnimal constructor and that’s sufficient to declare its subsequent behavior:

  struct AnyAnimal: Animal {
    let name: String
    private let walker: () -> Void
    private let eater: (Any) -> Void
    
    init<T: Animal>(_ animal: T) {
      name = animal.name
      walker = { animal.walk() }
      eater = { food in
        guard let f = food as? T.FoodType else { return }
        animal.eat(food: f)
      }
    }
    
    func walk(){ walker() }
    
    func eat(food: Any){ eater(food) }
  }
skue··on Give away your code, but never your time
> You expect me to both dedicate my time to writing the code for a PR, and then pay you for the privilege.

No, better yet it would eliminate PRs from entitled users who think this way — who believe they contribute value by writing up issues and submitting minor pull requests that address their own needs, while remaining blind to the far greater value they receive from the project’s much larger code base; the mammoth time investment of the people who have designed, developed, and maintained that code base; and the thankless job those leaders have done nurturing a community often comprised of far more takers than givers.

Basically, the proposal eliminates the takers. Whether it would work or not is an open question. But if you find yourself feeling indignant at the very suggestion, then maybe take a hard look at which role you really fall in?

skue··on Former Apple Employee: Touch Bar Shouldn't Be Forced on High End Users
> important buttons I use multiple times daily, like those for brightness and volume adjustments, now require the use of two-step touch-and-slide actions instead of my preferred key-mashing.

This is configurable. Just go to System Preferences > Keyboard, and on the first tab you can choose whether the touch bar shows (a) app specific controls plus an expandable control strip (the default), (b) the expanded control strip (the old default behavior), (c) function keys, or (d) app specific controls w/o expandable control strip.

Options (b) & (c) match the keyboard options without touchbars, and as before you toggle between them with the Fn key. The upside with the touchbar is you can see whether you’re in function or control mode. In any case, sounds like (b) is what you want.

Disclaimer: I’m running High Sierra so not sure if this is available on Sierra, but assume it is.

skue··on ARCore: Augmented reality at Android scale
Very curious how they pitched this to investors... “We’re building a platform geared to low end devices that will become obsolete within a couple of years. Invest now, and be part of our team’s amazing journey towards acquihire!”
skue··on Peter Thiel Funds ‘Unethical,’ Offshore Herpes Vaccine Trial
The issue here is the lack of IRB (Institutional Review Board), and what looks like an intentional effort to conduct trials in a neighboring country to avoid that requirement.

An IRB is not run by the FDA. They are independent bodies affiliated with research organizations like universities. The use of IRBs grew in response to research done in Tuskegee and Nazi Germany, and has been the standard for decades. Rather than make an organization like the FDA screen all human subject studies, IRBs are empowered to review and manage studies instead.

So no one is saying this research study needs to monitored by the FDA -- that's not how it works. There are also international standards for IRBs, this isn't just an American concept.

The investigator is at SIU, which has plenty of experience managing IRB studies [1]. It does seem odd that they would set this study up in this way, unless everyone involved is an extreme libertarian trying to thumb their noses at the notion of ethical review and monitoring, or the researcher has had past conflicts with an IRB at SIU. I wonder how many at SIU are aware of this study and if they will distance themselves from the study or the researcher, if this gets more press.

[1] http://ospa.siu.edu/_common/documents/human-subjects-forms/h...

skue··on This is how Netflix's top-secret recommendation system works
It's a shame they didn't bother to create a category for "Resists our suggestions and prefers to manage their own view list."

Every time I've tried using Netflix, I've canceled in frustration. Their movie selection is awful, and it baffles me that you have to hunt for your own curated watch list among rows and rows of uninspired TV shows they insist you might enjoy.

skue··on Privacy Respecting Services and Software
Brave was founded by Brendan Eich, as his next thing after departing Mozilla. Many of us may not agree with his views on marriage equality (or at least his past actions), but I believe over the years he has demonstrated a strong commitment to online privacy.

Personally, I'm glad someone is trying to figure out how websites can derive revenue through privacy-respecting microtransactions instead of the current ad model, and I hope they can make it work.

skue··on JavaScript TC39 implementing hashmark private class fields
Background for this proposal and discussion can be found in this repo’s README and additional docs:

https://github.com/tc39/proposal-private-fields

skue··on Show HN: Natural Atlas v2 – Coast-To-Coast Map of the Outdoors and iOS App
Maps are beautiful and easy to read. But I'm deleting the app and figured I'd share why...

* The Start Trip bar takes up too much of the screen for a feature I'll never use, especially when...

* All activities are public unless we pay $30 per year on top of the $6 app? That's not a premium feature, it's an anti-feature, and having those in a paid app is a fast way to turn someone who was already halfway converted into a pissed off 1-star reviewer.

* You limit non-pro users to 3 tiles but don't say how large the tiles are unless we buy the app to find out. Turns out they're approximately 15 by 15 miles, so 3 tiles won't even cover half of a small national park.

There aren't that many of us who still happily pay for apps knowing we may delete them immediately. When you find those users, you want to delight and reward them for taking a chance on you. Not offer a crippled app that only has practical utility with an annual subscription. Make this free or offer more features without a subscription. You can't have it both ways.

skue··on Why Germany Still Has So Many Middle-Class Manufacturing Jobs
> That along with the bombshell assertion without evidence that the inheritance tax is the greatest burdens companies face today removes any credibility from the rest of the article.

You disagree with one point [1] and question another, so for that reason you discount the entire article? If you can't align new information with your existing mental model, then the new information must be completely wrong?

This attitude has become so pervasive and so pernicious. Somehow even information has become partisan.

[1] BTW, do you have enough familiarity with Germany to make this comparison, or are you holding the author to a higher standard than yourself?

skue··on How Much Would You Put Up with to Avoid United Airlines?
No, it's really not about this one incident. United's customer service record has just fallen apart over the past several years, and many of us have had miserable experiences flying United. Every single one of my nightmare travel stories has been on United. Their CEO took as his mission to improve morale and build it back up, and ended up throwing gasoline on the smoldering fire instead.

So when we heard the news, we didn't just say "How could an airline do that?" Instead we said "An airline knocked out a passenger and dragged him off a plane so a stewardess could have his seat? Let me guess... was this on United?"

(Spirit would have an equally good guess, but at least they don't pretend to be on par with the other carriers.)

skue··on How Much Would You Put Up with to Avoid United Airlines?
How much? Well, those of us living in the Pacific Northwest just went through the wettest, cloudiest, gloomiest winter in our history.[1]

But if someone gave us perennial sunshine and all we had to do was become a United hub instead of Alaska? Pretty sure I wouldn't be the only one begging to bring the rain back instead.

[1] http://www.startribune.com/soggy-seattle-lives-up-to-name-br...

skue··on Amazon Echo Look
Seems pretty clear to me that this is just an intitial step. Echo Look as is may end up being very popular in its own right, but the end goal is probably to move beyond evaluating your existing wardrobe, and eventually making recommendations for clothing sold thru Amazon that you can try on virtually right at home. We've had that for glasses for a while, and believe some startups have already tried this for clothing.

Retail stores are shuttering at an increasing rate as things move online. But buying clothes online requires supporting lots of returns. Imagine you work at Amazon. You have an insane amount of computing power and very capable big data teams. You are tasked with building up clothing sales and minimizing returns. AR is on the horizon but not here yet.

So what could you release today to move towards your goals?

skue··on Would You Rather Have $1M or $5,000 Monthly in Retirement?
So many comments about the economics. Why is no one considering major medical issues from a quality of life standpoint?

Terminal cancer and hospice by 70? How do you want to spend those last 6 months, and what's the value in having an active role in directing what would be inheritance towards those people and causes that matter most to you?

Major unexpected medical issue with a spouse or loved one that requires support beyond basic govt coverage? Maybe you want the option to tighten your belt a bit more that last decade so you can make a difference now.

Have a positive experience with parents or grandparents at end of life? Or an unnecessarily difficult one?

How about the economic situation of other family members and cultural expectations and family history when it comes to caring for elders?

Sure, every financial possibility can be offset by another, and maybe annuity pricing equates $1M lump sum to $5k/mo. But reducing all the personal values that go into someone choosing one vs. another as an illusion of wealth or poverty seems so absurdly academic and out of touch with the basic humanity we each have.

skue··on CIA Declassified Coldwar Russian Jokes [pdf]
"All the time" isn't that far off. "All this time" is more idiomatic, but the parent poster's meaning is still quite clear.
skue··on A Woman Was Killed by a Superbug Resistant to All 26 American Antibiotics
Dup of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13391886 which has comments.

Mods can you merge?

skue··on A Woman Was Killed by a Superbug Resistant to All 26 American Antibiotics
Did you read the article? The only antibiotic that the bacteria showed sensitivity towards is not approved for use in the United States.

And how is this article "scare tactics?" Sure, we have known about increasing antibiotic resistance for years. But this is a sentinel event that absolutely deserves attention. Resistance isn't one of those things that simply disappears if everyone stops talking about it.

skue··on A Woman Was Killed by a Superbug Resistant to All 26 American Antibiotics
Not a microbiologist nor an infectious disease specialist. However in med school I had an attending who liked to say, "The main difference between me and my patients is I know what page it's on." In that spirit, these seem like decent reviews:

Short overview: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3400130/?report...

Somewhat longer (PDF): https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Sarah_Kuhl2/publication...

skue··on George Hotz cancels his Tesla Autopilot-like ‘comma one’
> I'd like to politely clue you in that...

If you really do want to be polite, then it's better to avoid expressions like "clue you in."

skue··on All Tesla Cars Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware
> It's strange to see this behaviour as someone living in Germany, where you are supposed to, by default, drive in the right lane if you are not overtaking another car or there is a traffic jam...

That used the be the norm in the US as well, but it has broken down over the past few decades. Some studies and motorist groups blame the nationwide 55 mph speed limit imposed in the 70s due to oil shortages. Slow drivers suddenly felt safe driving in left lanes and a whole generation has learned to drive like this. [1]

There are laws in many states against impeding traffic in the left lane [2], but they aren't that enforced. You also see signs occasionally on the highway, but my issue with these signs is that they say "Slower traffic keep right" (instead of eg, "Stay right except when passing"). I strongly suspect that very view people view themselves as "slow drivers" -- rather everyone tends to believe they drive the appropriate speed and everyone else is driving too slow or too fast.

[1] http://nytimes.com/2016/07/08/us/more-states-are-cracking-do...

[2] http://www.mit.edu/~jfc/right.html

skue··on Yahoo scanned customer emails for US intelligence
> > Mayer was probably too new and too scared to deal with this, especially when she had to think about her new baby.

> OK, I normally think misogyny claims are over-blown and people are way too sensitive. But your comment positively reeks of misogyny. Rather than go for a down-vote, because you're able to edit your comment, I think you should reconsider the phrasing and delete the misogyny.

Having newborn twins at home could certainly be a factor in any CEO's willingness to make an ideological stand in the face of jail time, regardless of the CEO's gender. Plus there's a wealth of feminist writing about the potential for gender disagreement when it comes to this very question, going back to Kohlberg, Gilligan, and an imaginary guy named Heinz.[1]

FWIW, I do agree that any privileged group should be conscientious when discussing others who might sometimes feel like or be seen as outsiders, and that this applies to guys in tech. But your comment seems a bit over the top and risks shutting down discussion about an important topic... whether the government took advantage of the fact that Mayer had newborns at home when they pressured her to comply.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Kohlberg%27s_stages...

skue··on Telegram App Vuln Recorded Anything MacOS Users Pasted
Wow. Shipping an extra NSLog statement in a privacy-focused app is an embarrassing mistake, but the response[1] from Pavel, Telegram's founder/CEO, should be the real story:

> @k_firsov This applies only to texts that were copy-pasted from clipboard, and such texts are open to all other Mac apps anyway (1).

> (2)... AppStore apps can NOT access syslog (starting 10.12 also true for unsigned apps). But ANY app can read your clipboard.

> (3)... AppStore apps are sandboxed and can only WRITE to syslog, not READ it

> (4)... Malware apps are unsigned/not from AppStore and so, of course, are not sandboxed. But it'd be a game over scenario.

> ...(5) So while copy-paste can not be secure anyway, I see such logging in the stable release redundant and will see it gone.

> ...(6) However, if you find anything really serious, let us know at security@telegram.org to claim your potential bounty. Thanks.

Basically, he's saying this isn't a problem because other App Store apps shouldn't be able to read syslog, and any malicious app already present on the machine could be reading the clipboard in real time. But he willfully ignores the fact that by saving clipboard data to the syslog, it can be accessed much later by a non-App Store app or someone with possession of the machine.

[1] https://mobile.twitter.com/k_firsov/status/75687561187282124...

skue··on Engineers can’t gauge their own interview performance
Dunning-Kruger actually accounts for both.[1] But agreed, this isn't specific to hiring.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning–Kruger_effect

skue··on Men at work
> for the record: I've done both. I've had a number of very physically intensive jobs when I started my career and to this day I'm grateful every bloody day that my life took a turn for the better and that I don't have to work until I can't stand up straight anymore. Being not the most physically strong person I realize that if I had continued down that path I would have been a physical wreck by now.

> Have some respect for the people that do the heavy lifting. And if you're unconvinced: go take a manual labor job for a year or so and re-read your comment here.

Jacques, why the rancor and assumption that the OP and other commenters (like the GP) haven't also had physical jobs? I certainly have… It's all I did the first several years of my working life. And like you, my life is now quite different.

You have a different point of view, but it's not because we haven't done physical work. In fact, in my case I'd say it was my experience doing that kind of work that leads me to identify with what the OP describes in the linked article.

skue··on Men at work
I think you're being unfair. The author is a sociologist. She's not criticizing working men's behavior. On the contrary - she's simply using it as an indicator to point out that there's something unique about how recent societal changes are impacting this group.

Working class doesn't mean that the work itself is more physical: the majority of these jobs have been taken over by automation and/or transferred abroad. A recent study in the US shows that mortality in white males has increased since the Great Recession. Not because jobs have gotten more physical, but because permanent joblessness has increased. It's increasingly difficult for men - especially those without the economic and employment flexibility that many of us enjoy - to find meaning in their lives according to the traditional roles under which they were raised. Long term maybe this turns out for the best as gender roles ultimately become less pronounced. But it's a hard transition and right this is a real issue that impacts everyone. Just look at current US politics.

skue··on Samsung to pay Apple $548M in patent dispute
> Samsung has already changed their design to avoid any more of Apple's patents, making any future litigation impossible.

All the comments about the dollar value of this suit are missing this point. I would assume Apple cares much more about sending a message to Samsung and others that they feel are simply copying their innovations. And if it gets their competitors to change their behavior and differentiate themselves, then the lawsuits are probably worth Apple's investment.

skue··on Tripdelta Finds Cheaper Flights Through “Secret” Airport Routes
This is a weak pitch... Kayak, Hipmunk, any almost any other site have an option to include nearby airports when searching.

I compared the route they screenshotted and apparently the only reason TripDelta come up with a $150 cheaper one-way option ($302 vs $455) is by flying Spirit from OAK to LAX with a 9 hour layover. Kayak probably assumes that layover is excessive and filters it out. Because really, if you're that desperate to save funds, just take Greyhound to LAX.

And if you book round trip, returning a week later, it's $779 on Kayak and over $1086 on TripDelta. Plus Kayak will also give you the probability that prices will drop in the next 7 days.

skue··on Parkinson's patients 'walk and talk again' after receiving cancer drug in trial
Regarding the first half of your comment, don't forget about Viagra, which was "designed" to treat angina. It didn't do so well during clinical trials, but there was this one weird side effect that kept coming up...
skue··on A scientist's decision to kill a bird he'd been searching for for two decades
Here's a link to the referenced Audubon story, along with a picture of the bird and the odd editor's note (at the bottom).

http://www.audubon.org/news/moustached-kingfisher-photograph...

← PreviousPage 4 of 12Next →