HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shkkmo

5,895 karma · joined March 29, 2014

submissionscomments
shkkmo··on 4k NASA employees opt to leave agency through deferred resignation program
Artemis and SLS have many problems but I would look elsewhere than that article if you want an understanding of what they are and why they exist.
shkkmo··on 200k Flemish drivers can turn traffic lights green
> It might be true, but that's not the same as "accurate". Let's imagine the same thing but for cyclists:

I don't understand the disctinction you are trying to draw here. The statement itself is both accurate and true? At best the implication might be slightly hyperbolic but definitely not a "cartoonishly evil caricature."

> There's probably some far more innocuous explanation out there, like that the cyclist thought the way was clear (because there were no cars in sight).

Except your explanation is also not innocuous. Not wanting to be behind a bicycle is non an excuse for dangerous passing and especially when you are approaching a red light. The fact that you think this is an acceptable reasoning for that behavior is why you're being called out and downvoted. None of your excuses for how this might cause a light cycle to trigger sooner make this acceptable behavior.

shkkmo··on 4k NASA employees opt to leave agency through deferred resignation program
It's not complete nonsense, but it conveniently leaves out key relevant details and includes key pieces of misinformation needed to make the talking points make sense (as you would expect from rage bait.)

> Early on, SLS designers made the catastrophic decision to reuse Shuttle hardware

The law that mandated that NASA built the SLS also required that they re-use that hardware. This wasn't a choice made by NASA designers but by a bipartisan congress and it wasn't designed so much to advance our space program so much as a way to keep funneling money to space contractors with the end of the Shuttle program.

Any article that proposed to discuss the "lunacy" of Artemis without ever mentioning Congress's role in that lunacy is pretty clearly rage bait.

shkkmo··on 200k Flemish drivers can turn traffic lights green
> While milking their data with gov backed incentives.

Again, the whole thrust of this article is that people aren't incentivized yet to use or switch navigation apps.

> But it is not.

Yet. If that is something you want, go fund some opensource mapping apps to add the feature.

Without detailed technical information, this seems like a reasonable approach to solve a hard problem that isn't well solved now. Opt-in traffic data collection via an open standard api seems like be best case scenario here.

I'd be interested in specific criticism about how mapping apps are given access to the API, what exact data has to be shared to enable or other specific aspects of this program.

Your knee-jerk reactionary talking points aren't interesting though.

shkkmo··on 200k Flemish drivers can turn traffic lights green
> just that the cartoonishly evil caricature of the driver's reasoning that OP dreamed up isn't accurate

"Cartoonishly evil"?!?

I'm pretty sure it is accurate for some subset of the driving population, which was the claim.

> Unfortunately, judging by the downvotes it seems like people are interpreting my opposition to OP's claim that "Some people apparently just can't stand to have anyone driving before them" as me arguing that it's fine for drivers to mow down cyclists to save 5s.

You didn't actually provide any evidence or argument to dispute that claim and completely ignored the key "risky" part of comment.

The way it reads is that you had your feelings hurt by having your bad behavior called out and felt a need to rationalize that behavior.

shkkmo··on 200k Flemish drivers can turn traffic lights green
> these are apps of commercial data-sharing/selling businesses, not some 'official' gov app for the benefit of the citizens.

While there are a few of commercial apps that can integrate now, The goal is to have every navigation/gps app have the ability to do this. This can also be done by privacy friendly apps.

> Why do these commercial entities get to influence public traffic lights?

The commercial entities don't influence anything, they provide a tool for their users to influence the lights.

> And due to the inherent red-queen arms race

What arms race is inherent here? Traffic isn't (or shouldn't be) a competition but a cooperation.

Your whole comment seems weird because the main point of the article us that most people seem unwilling to change navigation apps to take advantage of this feature so widespread adoption will wait till the apps people are already using (and which already get all that data) support the standard.

shkkmo··on 200k Flemish drivers can turn traffic lights green
> Seems like the far more plausible reason is that drivers don't want to be held up by a cyclist traveling at 10mph in front of them?

You sound like one of thos drivers who believe it's OK to put other people at risk to save themselves a couple of seconds.

I see this all the time in my large truck that I'm very good at coasting into red lights. Even when there are already vehicles stopped at the light, people will not only stay on the gas way later than necessary and then brake unnecessarily hard but will also pass me to be sitting one car length further ahead at that light. Often it is done dangerously, without turn signals or proper blind spot checks. I know this because I've also almost been hit repeatedly on my motorcycle by cars doing this.

shkkmo··on Wife of ICEBlock app founder speaks out after DOJ fires her
AFAIK, ownership interest in a company doesn't violate any of the Hatch restrictions, even on the "further restricted" category of employees. So unless she took specific political actions while on the job, using her authority, or using federal resources, this is not a Hatch violation.
shkkmo··on Mary had schizophrenia, then suddenly didn't
I'm guessing that "organic screen" doesn't currently usually include antibody testing of CSF from a lumbar puncture since the article implies that only a limited number places do that screening currently.

> To find psychiatric patients who might benefit from immunotherapy, researchers have set up centers, roughly similar to the one at Columbia, at Baylor University Medical Center, in Texas; King’s College London; Uppsala University, in Sweden; and the University of Freiburg, in Germany, among other places. Some of the best research into the phenomenon has been conducted in Germany, where it’s more common for patients in a first episode of psychosis to have lumbar punctures to access their spinal fluid, which can reveal the presence of antibodies.

shkkmo··on Employee – CEO pay gap historically wide
The gap is atypically wide, perhaps "Employee – CEO pay gap rises" would have the same intent without the factual inaccuracy?
shkkmo··on Employee – CEO pay gap historically wide
The edited headline "Employee – CEO pay gap historically wide" here is wrong. The Employee - CEO gap is higher (ratio 295) than last year (ratio 268) but lower than in 2021 (ratio 324).

If you're gonna make up a headline, don't make up one that is factually false.

shkkmo··on What went wrong inside recalled Anker PowerCore 10000 power banks?
Acknowledging cultural differences is different from assuming that cultural differences are determined by genetics and not life experiences.

Saying that someone grew up in a culture that values a certain type of academic education and achievement is different than saying they have those characteristics because of their racial genetic heritage.

It's also one thing to be aware of cultural trends and differences when designing multicultural systems to function well. It's another to project cultural trends onto individual people since the variation between people in a culture easily dominates the variation in the averages between cultures.

Of course, nuance like this rarely makes it into common discourse, which often does end up just being racist.

shkkmo··on CSS's problems are Tailwind's problems
It took a sec but I parsed "a minimal local maximum" as "from the set of all local maximums, this local maximum is near the bottom." Thus it is a local maximum, so any small change produces a worse result, but it is one of the worst local maximums you could have found.
shkkmo··on Mary had schizophrenia, then suddenly didn't
I think the article is far more interesting than you make it out to be.

There is pretty clear evidence that some subset of schizophrenic diagnosis are due to autoimmune issues. If we can use antibodies in the spinal fluid to detect when autoimmune treatments can be effective in treating schizophrenia, that alone will be huge.

However, the even bigger insight to be drawn from all of this is the potential for other psychological problems that psychiatry has struggled to treat, to also have autoimmune causes. When you try to treat something that has multiple, quite different causes, with a single treatment, it makes sense that it would be hard to find that treatment that works reliably (as is the case for many psychiatric medicines.)

I predict we may eventually see immune antibody tests (or some functional successor) become a standard part of all mental health care.

shkkmo··on What went wrong inside recalled Anker PowerCore 10000 power banks?
I don't know, assuming all cultures should be functionally equivalent seems pretty imperialist to me.
shkkmo··on Five companies now control over 90% of the restaurant food delivery market
> Just because Americans have an obesity problem doesn't make every food vendor a drug dealer.

Not all, just some of them. It's pretty obvious which ones when you actually look at how they design and market their products.

shkkmo··on Apple vs the Law
I'm sure you could look that up for yourself pretty easily if you were actually curious and not trying to make some unknown point by asking the question.
shkkmo··on At Least 13 People Died by Suicide Amid U.K. Post Office Scandal, Report Says
> No software rolls out without any bugs and it's really reasonable to ask why so many post offices had missing funds and if they were sure if it was real or not.

It would be reasonable, but that also assumes the ass-covering started post rollout rather than pre rollout.

shkkmo··on Recovering from AI Addiction
> Trauma only appearing in super-deep going therapy sessions can often be False Memory Syndrome, which is an entirely different can of worms and extremely problematic

It is problematic, but not in the way that you think. While memories can be suggestively altered or created by questioning, the evidence for doing so for traumatic childhood sexual abuse is anecdotal and those anecdotes were pretty heavily cherry picked by the clearly biased FMSF, which was run as a support and advocacy group for parents accused of abuse.

That said, my understanding is that in general, dwelling on traumatizing experiences isn't beneficial to recovery. There are times they may need to be confronted and processed, but generally if it isn't causing a problem, don't go digging it up and spending a lot of time thinking about it unnecessarily.

shkkmo··on Apple vs the Law
Apple has <60% market share in the US. It's pretty dominant, but there are definitely still real competitors.
shkkmo··on Bear-Sized Giant Beavers Once Roamed North America
> If it were not for beavers evolving beside us, the Eastern US and much of the world would very nearly resemble the driest American Southwest of today, with rain being gathered after a brief overland wash into deep river gorges, with little water left behind close to surface.

The rainfall patterns are very different in those two areas. I don't doubt that beavers have important erosion and sediment retention impacts that over time do have a massive impact on the ecosystem and landscape. However, sediment rention is far from only reason why the american SW looks so different from other parts of the country.

shkkmo··on A Virginia public library is fighting off a takeover by private equity
A non-profit like this literally cannot be owned and thus no equity to be public or private. It is a legal entity controlled by its board and there are no ownership shares which can be bought, sold, or transfered.
shkkmo··on How to prove false statements: Practical attacks on Fiat-Shamir
I don't believe the "this work" that the article is talking about here is GKR, but work that is referenced earlier in the article:

> In the early 2000s, computer scientists showed how to do just that, contriving interactive proof protocols that were specifically designed to fail when they underwent Fiat-Shamir

Indeed, the artcile points out that targeting GKR was the idea of the Ethereum Foundation researcher.

> Soukhanov had the idea to target a Fiat-Shamir proof system based on something called the GKR protocol

shkkmo··on A Virginia public library is fighting off a takeover by private equity
You seem a bit confused. Samuels Library Inc is a tax-emempt 501(c)(3) non-profit, which is kind of the opposite of private equity.
shkkmo··on Linda Yaccarino is leaving X
"lost money due to inflation" (or even "lost money compared to an equivalent investment is a basket of similar stocks" is very different claim than "lost 80% of value". Currently the stock is down less than 10% from the purchase price (41 billion vs 44 billion).

Down 10% vs 80% is the kind of egregious factual "error" that gets made so frequently around Musk, that it is hard to take any criticism at face value. You don't like the guy and want to call him out? Get your facts straight or you're being counter productive.

shkkmo··on Making Explainable Minesweeper
The exclusion of patterns that involve more than 2 numbers is a pretty huge caveat that should be mentioned earlier and more clearly. When I was playing a lot of minesweeper, larger levels tended to require solving larger patterns most of the time. If you exclude those solutions, your estimate of how often you are required to guess is going to be pretty inaccurate.
shkkmo··on New sphere-packing record stems from an unexpected source
I mean, it says it directly in the article:

> His result has also revived a debate in the field about the nature of the optimal packing in arbitrarily high dimensions. For a while, mathematicians considered highly symmetric, lattice-based packings to be the best way to arrange spheres as densely as possible. But in 2023, a team found a packing that didn’t rely neatly on a repeating lattice; before Klartag’s result, it was the record to beat. Some mathematicians saw it as evidence that more disorder was needed in the search for an optimal sphere packing.

Clearly, this improvement doesn't apply to the few dimensions for which we already proven optimal packing, but the proof was general.

shkkmo··on Sleeping beauty Bitcoin wallets wake up after 14 years to the tune of $2B
> So similar story as with Tesla? Existing opinion nicely confirmed.

How is that similar?

Tesla was 2 dudes and an office with no IP and no product when Musk became the lead investor and chairman of the board.

Whereas when Cofinity and X.com merged it was as two functioning companies operating in the same market.

What similarity do you see?

shkkmo··on New sphere-packing record stems from an unexpected source
> For some dimensions the densest known irregular packing is denser than the densest known regular packing.

I thought that was one of the important results from the paper, the most efficient packing for all dimensions is symmetrical again and this increase was significant enough it seems unlikely that existing non-symmetrical methods will be able to beat it.

shkkmo··on Game publishers respond to Stop Killing Games claim it curtails developer choice
That announcement is about BG4 not BG3.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →