HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scottlegrand2

551 karma · joined July 10, 2016

submissionscomments
scottlegrand2··on How to recognize AI snake oil [pdf]
Totally should have trademarked it along with "IGlasses" in the very same pitch. The patch was apparently rejected because our level design ideas were better than the actual episodes of the show upon which it was based: "Poltergeist: The Legacy."
scottlegrand2··on How to recognize AI snake oil [pdf]
20+ years ago I used to refer to this is as artificial artificial intelligence (AAI) specifically as part of a pitch to MGM for an MMORPG to run their non-player characters. Not surprisingly, it didn't catch on...
scottlegrand2··on Ex-FDA Advisor Says of Lasik Eye Surgery: ‘It Should Have Never Been Approved’
So this quote isn't in the article or the person who wrote the article is a liar? Gotcha.

"Even though the FDA had already made up its mind to ban IOLs, the directive came down from Congress that you can study IOLs, but you can't ban them."

scottlegrand2··on Some users say they're getting rid of Fitbit because they don't trust Google
Got rid of mine too after using Fitbit devices since 2011. And I'm an ex-googler and a former Amazon employee. I don't want to supply extraneous information to Amazon, Google, or Facebook. No good would come of that.

And I will add that in the last year of owning a Fitbit ionic I wasn't syncing anyway because there was some sort of bug that would randomly subtract 100 or so calories every hour or so. Fitbit continued to deny the bug existed and it was never fixed.

scottlegrand2··on Ex-FDA Advisor Says of Lasik Eye Surgery: ‘It Should Have Never Been Approved’
And the FDA had already decided to ban them until there was a public outcry that drove Congress to override the FDA. That's in the article too.
scottlegrand2··on Ex-FDA Advisor Says of Lasik Eye Surgery: ‘It Should Have Never Been Approved’
Reminds me of the time Ralph Nader tried to ban cataract surgery...

https://www.eyeworld.org/article-marcus-welby--md--knew-best

scottlegrand2··on The father of the modern frozen food industry
It's generational. I grew up with Clarence Birdseye commercials so I immediately knew who they were talking about from the article title. Who says you can't learn anything from TV?

https://youtu.be/HM65j-w0uYw

scottlegrand2··on Alphabet in bid to buy Fitbit
I bought a Fitbit ionic two years ago. It was great for the first year. Then it started behaving oddly and now it doesn't work at all with Huawei phones (which I rely on now because they seem to be the first brand that doesn't effectively brick itself after 6 months from metastasizing updates and enhancements).

My solution for the past year has been to leave the device unsynced. Strangely, it still somehow manages to upload data occasionally and I have no idea how it's doing it. about once a month it just gets stuck and I need to restart the thing. I'm going to guess those two things are somehow related but I don't know quite how.

I was planning on switching to a cheap Chinese device anyway. This is the kick in my keister that will get me to do it.

scottlegrand2··on IBM casts doubt on Google's claims of quantum supremacy
I think the problem is that perfectly wonderful science has been put in the hands of marketing people. And those are the same marketing people that kept telling us L5 autonomy was right around the corner. Or more lately that we couldn't discount the possibility of a near-term AGI. Great science, lousy PR IMO.
scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
I think the turning point for him was his excellent presentation in the first youtube broadcast of cs231. If I remember correctly he was getting seven-figure offers before he even graduated from Stanford. I do not know him personally and I doubt I will ever meet him but we did compete for the same position at Tesla and I lost to a very worthy opponent. my only regret is that the final interview would have been with Elon Musk himself and I would have loved to meet him.
scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
That he turns out to be a scumbag seems orthogonal to his compensation. He would have gotten that money if he had delivered, no?

That said, my exiting salary at some companies was dramatically higher than my salary when I joined because the stock had appreciated and so had my compensation. And if someone wants to hire me away that's the compensation they have to deal with, not my initial comp.

scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
Whatever you do don't look up what Uber offered him to leave waymo...
scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
I think you are embodying the notion "You miss all the shots you don't take." You're right that most fresh PhDs cannot do this (I did say top 5%). But I think we disagree as to why. You seem to think these positions do not exist and I know otherwise because I've been on both sides of the very same hiring process for which they do exist. The reason most new PhDs won't get them is because they lack the career experience to navigate the interview process to such a position. I'd love to see a world where someone teaches them those skills while they're still in academia. I sure could have used that.

I also know because the day I left academia myself long ago was a major payday for me. Finally, I know because people like Andrei Karpathy pulled it off because of his excellent communication skills, intelligence and the right background. And people like Mu Li pulled it off by associating themselves with an academic who who helped found AWS AI and in his case he landed a principal engineering position straight out of school. That's the sort of position one usually only gets after one to two decades of job experience.

Can we just agree to disagree here?

scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
What's amazing to me is the same people who write articles like this don't blink at the salaries in Hollywood. A top-tier performer can get over a hundred million dollars per movie. A bottom-tier character actor or below the line talent barely gets by.

The difference in compensation here is nowhere near as bad as what happens in Hollywood.

scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/04/03/waymos-uber-lawsuit-reveals-...
scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
Then the people who come to your company could probably do better elsewhere if money is all they care about. You work at Cruise am I right? I know someone personally who worked at Cruise who was making 7 figures. That sort of compensation is just not that unusual anymore.

But I've learned that money isn't everything the hard way. However, if you're whining about being underpaid, there's something you can do about it. There are plenty of solid reasons not to however especially if you enjoy your current gig and they're paying you sufficiently that you have a promising future. Money truly isn't everything.

scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
The first thing you need to do is convince yourself you're worth that kind of money. Then when they ask you how much money you want during a job interview start talking about your peers in the industry making that kind of money. Finally make sure you're talking to multiple potential employers so you can play them against each other. Elon Musk gave that money to Ilya Sutskever because Google was probably paying him at least $1.5 million. Even if not, his share from the $60M DNNResearch acquhire (that's what got the whole ball rolling here) was probably worth far more than that.

Sadly, you're really only worth what you can convince another person to believe you're worth. But then the USA is suffering through someone convincing an electoral majority of Americans he was the best and only choice to lead the country and that's just working out splendidly right?

scottlegrand2··on A.I. researchers are making more than $1M, even at a nonprofit
7-figure salaries have been a thing for quite a while at Facebook, Google and definitely at hedge funds. Right now, you can make a half million a year or more if you're willing to optimize the low-level code in any of the major AI frameworks.

If you publish a major conference paper, 7 figures is pretty easy to attain. You don't have to be in the 0.001% just the top 5%. That's hard work but it's doable.

The only thing that's remotely fungible in AI is python-based data scientists who can do little more than port new data to existing models open sourced on GitHub. And even then they do pretty well because of the huge demand.

I don't see that changing anytime soon. I believe expecting automated systems to replace data scientists is the same level of naivete as believing we'd reach L5 autonomy in a few years in 2014.

Anthony Lewandowski was making 120 million dollars a year when he left Waymo. If you're an AI expert in the valley and you're not making at least $500k, you are one job hop away from doing so if you play your cards remotely right.

scottlegrand2··on At Tech’s Leading Edge, Worry About a Concentration of Power
As a nuclear physicist who left academia for Disney once told me: "Academia... The competition is so intense because the stakes are so low..."
scottlegrand2··on The Dark Side of Techno-Utopianism
IMO they need to come together and build the equivalent of Netflix for this content. I'm happy to pay $10 a month to eliminate all paywalls. I'm not happy with individual subscriptions to every newspaper and newsletter in existence. And yes I know disabling JavaScript gets around a lot of these paywalls. I'd like to just pay one fee though rather than a cheat.
scottlegrand2··on WeWork’s Adam Neumann Steps Down as CEO
A friend interviewed there and they dismissed him as overqualified for DS.
scottlegrand2··on The Dark Side of Techno-Utopianism
I think one of the subtle problems here is all the pay walls on the more reputable news sites. Yes I know they need to make money but by closing themselves off to people unwilling to pay for their material, that increases the chance that sites like Twitter and Facebook become their only source of news. Nothing good comes from that. That's not blaming Facebook by the way.
scottlegrand2··on Ask HN: What Have You Learned at Google as a Software Engineer?
It's bigger than that IMO. I can switch managers at a big company. But if the entire division is inept, it's time to jump companies because it's a tell that the culture is decaying.

For me, the only reason I will never go back to GOOG is blind allocation. IMO that's a bug, not a feature.

scottlegrand2··on Ask HN: What Have You Learned at Google as a Software Engineer?
And at the end of that cycle job hop to get promoted and begin another round.
scottlegrand2··on Workers Are Fleeing Big Cities for Small Ones, and Taking Their Jobs with Them
Not the person you're asking, but orthogonal to where I live, penny-pinching on open office floor plans ended my ability to do productive work in an office nearly a decade ago.

And no I'm not going to put on headphones. IMO my work environment should naturally be conducive to getting s* done. But that seems to have become crazy talk.

scottlegrand2··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
Clearly all it needs is a blockchain component to succeed.
scottlegrand2··on Cities Are Saying ‘No’ to 5G, Citing Health, Aesthetics, and FCC Bullying
I download entire seasons of TV series with my Android Netflix client all the time. It's fantastic for travel.
scottlegrand2··on In effect, Seattle is decriminalizing the use of hard drugs
That's pretty much Santa Cruz California and it hasn't happened yet.
scottlegrand2··on House Prices Drop Again in San Francisco and Silicon Valley
I get the appeal of the Bay area if you don't have to drive far. And I get the appeal of San Francisco if you never have to venture out of Pacific Heights and The Presidio so to speak.

But damn, the sheer number of homeless people pooping on the streets is dystopic. And I've been all over the world. The garbage on the streets of New York City smells better. The tent cities all over the mission blow my mind. I used to really want to live there but when I go up there these days it's only because I have to be there.

scottlegrand2··on The Horror of Microsoft Teams
Reminds me a lot of the horror show that is Amazon chime, Amazon's alternative to slack.

That said it had some half implemented good ideas, but whenever you found a bug in it, its AWS-based team pretty much told you where to shove that bug report.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →