HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scoot

2,509 karma · joined March 29, 2011

submissionscomments
scoot··on 2026 Unslop AI-Written Fiction Contest Results
> producing the statistically most "correct" output

That isn't quite how they work - there's a degree of randomness depending on so called "temperature". And it isn't the output that's statistically modelled, it's the next token based on the prior output.

> This sounds a bit like you are saying LLMs are conscious

No more so than OP is implicitly asserting that human art is produced in cleanroom isolation. I don't believe either to be true.

scoot··on 2026 Unslop AI-Written Fiction Contest Results
> it’s not good immersion when every character is a chatbot that can inadvertently give you story beats you shouldn’t be aware of yet or you missed some crucial bit of information but no one talks about it anymore

What you're describing isn't bad dialog, it's bad interaction design.

I think your mental model might be of a single session with zero state, and no bounds on topics of conversation outside of the character's backstory. That isn't close to how this would work. A little understanding of how the game currently operates and some imagination, and you'll see how it could be improved further without degrading gameplay.

> those games would be made popular by people breaking the LLMs in funny ways

Because making the game do funny things didn't happen with RDR2, or any other game, device, or indeed humans (there are whole genre built around making people do or say "funny" things).

scoot··on 2026 Unslop AI-Written Fiction Contest Results
> I don't want to consume "art" that has been generated out the distillation of stealing all of the world's current art

It seems that you've fundamentally misunderstood art. I wouldn't personally call it "stealing", but T.S. Eliot would beg to differ (as would Pablo Picasso who "stole" that line)

> I want to read something that has intent. That has a purpose. A reason why it exists.

If the "allegories for the LLM condition" angle is accurate, then these stories do. In which case I believe what you mean to say is that you want to read something that has human intent.

scoot··on 2026 Unslop AI-Written Fiction Contest Results
> It's terrible and you'll find out quite fast you're not interested in everyone's background and scream to most NPC's to shut the fuck up and get to the point.

Many of the interactions in RDR2 are quite mundane, and despite thousands of hours of (high quality) voice acting, it can become quite repetitive.

I could very much see those micro-interactions being LLM generated, but the TTS would need to be a step above where even the best models are now to come close to RDR2s production quality.

scoot··on The bottleneck might be the air in the room
Apple watches already have a blood-oxygen sensor so it's covered, albeit indirectly.
scoot··on Single Dose of Frog-Derived Gut Bacterium Eradicates 100% of Tumors in Mice
Doesn’t that simply make this blog spam?
scoot··on Jolla Phone (October 2026)
Exactly this (when nitpicking the phrasing). Is putting the finished unit in the box "assembly" of the delivered product?

OTOH, I'm not sure how much it matters. Apple products are "designed in California" (which is a bit of a lie to begin with), and very much assembled overseas.

Of more interest is how few units they've pre-sold compared to mainstream phones. I wish them well, but I doubt they'll change history.

scoot··on Apple raises prices of MacBooks, iPads
The trouble with long-term contracts is that they have an end date. Looking at my 5 year fixed mortgage which will end in just over a year, and it isn’t going to be pretty.

Apple doesn’t get a pass just because their contracts are many of orders of magnitude bigger.

scoot··on I Stored a Website in a Favicon
Would have been more fun if the blogpost was rendered from the favicon.
scoot··on Sixty percent of US consumers say 'AI' in brand messaging is a turnoff
Funny, because my LG TV had Google Assistant (whatever that is) when I bought it, but it was removed. It was never in your face though, just a button on the remote.

It still has Alexa (it has both) but I never use it. I barely use the Echo that's next to the TV!

scoot··on There's still no point in gigabit broadband
Edit to recognise your edit, as you’ve clarified that were talking about downloads - a once a month experience.

That sounds more like a time management problem - buy your game, go to bed, and it’ll be there when you wake at 2:30 for your next gaming session. ;)

~You appear to be confusing latency and bandwidth. While they are to an extent two dimensions of the same problem, it’s latency that affects gaming regardless of bandwidth.

More bandwidth will not reduce latency, and gaming intentionally only uses limited bandwidth (notwithstanding streamed rendering, but that’s a minuscule minority).

You cannot defy the laws of physics.~

scoot··on UK government replaces Palantir software with internally-built refugee system
Millions of pounds wasted by using Palantir tech in refugee system

(FTFY)

scoot··on Today I've made the difficult decision to reduce the size of Coinbase by ~14%
To be "AI native" (a la digital native) you have to have grown up with the technology.

I'm not sure exactly which children they're planning to replace all their staff with, nor how they plan to get around the child labour laws.

scoot··on Show HN: Drive any macOS app in the background without stealing the cursor
And to think that ARexx was released nearly 40 years ago! Amazing that modern computing still hasn't caught on to some of the capabilities AmigaOS introduced.
scoot··on Google plans to invest up to $40B in Anthropic
> suddenly model quality is back up again

Is that not down to this? https://www.anthropic.com/engineering/april-23-postmortem

scoot··on Mr. Chatterbox is a Victorian-era ethically trained model
If training data of any kind violated copyright, every creator alive would be in breach of by virtue of any influence their “training data” (lifelong exposure to the work of others) has on their output.

The creators crying foul of AI are painting themselves into a corner, both literally and figuratively.

scoot··on 30 Years Ago, Robots Learned to Walk Without Falling
According to the article E0 was static, E3 was dynamic.

What none of them did, however, was “learn” (as the title suggests). They used hardcoded algorithms.

scoot··on Why did the chicken cross the road?
> Or Tian'anman

"Tian'anmen"

scoot··on Why did the chicken cross the road?
> It's Tiananman Square

"Tiananmen"

scoot··on A new Bigfoot documentary helps explain our conspiracy-minded era
I've always assumed that committed conspiracy theorists are just trolls rolling with it (because nobody could be so stupid as to actually believe in the conspiracy's premise). So no amount of evidence is going to "convince" them, because they already know the truth, and don't care.

But then perhaps over time, they somehow attracted people who genuinely are that stupid, and uncritically believe? That demographic is obviously going to be too stupid to critically assess any new evidence either.

scoot··on German police probe student poster slur against Merz
> According to Germany's Criminal Code, defamation statutes apply when someone knowingly asserts or disseminates untrue statements about another person

It seems more likely to be under the Insult clause of that statute:

> Insult (§185 StGB): Covers disrespectful, demeaning, or contemptuous statements made to or about someone, including public insults.

That's a pretty heavy handed law.

scoot··on Show HN: Respectify – A comment moderator that teaches people to argue better
> See how Respectify moderates comments in real time > Request timed out after 30000ms

Anyone working in real real-time computing would have a fit!

scoot··on Making Wolfram tech available as a foundation tool for LLM systems
LLMs use the em-dash excessively but correctly. This post is littered with them in places they don't belong which makes it look decidedly human, as if written by someone who believes that random em-dashes make their writing look more professional, while actually having the opposite effect.
scoot··on VTT Test Donut Lab Battery Reaches 80% Charge in Under 10 Minutes [pdf]
Fast charging, long life, low cost – pick two.

Actually, there are a bunch of other variables (energy density, stability, discharge current, etc. etc.), so the probability of a technology that improves one significantly without negatively affecting at least one other is vanishingly small. Hence the number of overhyped battery technologies that get reported but never productised.

scoot··on ReferenceFinder: Find coordinates on a piece of paper with only folds
“outside of the box”?
scoot··on Acme Weather
Going even further off topic, one of the things I love with Apple is having all your subscriptions in one place, and being able to cancel them easily.

The few zombie subscriptions I've had have all existed outside of the App store, one that I didn't even sign up for (looking at you Masterclass). I bought a one year gift subscription for someone else, and because it came with a "free" subscription for me (that I didn't use), I git hit with annual renewals until I noticed it on my credit card statement and cancelled.

Yes, I should check those more frequently, but who has time for that?

It rankles that you can can cancel a free trial before it's over with every app exept Apple's. I like the feature, but the double standard grates.

scoot··on Spell Checking a Year's Worth of Hacker News
> English being my second language, I curse it everyday

"every day"

Perhaps the author should check grammar while he checks spelling :D (Not the only issue I noticed, and I didn't read the entire article...)

scoot··on AI agent opens a PR write a blogpost to shames the maintainer who closes it
It's still live on the blog – there was an (otherwise identical) followup comment on the issue seven minutes later with the correct link:

https://crabby-rathbun.github.io/mjrathbun-website/blog/post...

That itself makes me think there's a human in the loop on the bot end.

scoot··on How London became the rest of the world’s startup capital
About the same as today then, although breakfast at home costs way less than the shortest fare on the tube.
scoot··on Exploring a Modern SMTPE 2110 Broadcast Truck
I'm amused but not entirely surprised to see that live video production hasn't meaningfully progressed since I was involved 30+ years ago.

Yes, the technology has evolved – digital vs analog (partly – for example analog comms here because digital (optical) "isn't redundant" (lol, what?)); higher resolution; digital overlays and effects, etc. But the basic process of a bunch of humans winging it and yelling to each other hasn't changed at all.

This is an industry ripe for massive disruption, and the first to do it will win big.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →