744 karma · joined August 6, 2012
Is it just me or is MCP a really bad idea?
We seem to have spent the last 10 years trying to make computing more secure and now people are using node & npx - tools with a less than flawless safety story - to install tools and make them available to a black box LLM that they trust to be non-harmful. On what basis, even about accidental harm I am not sure.
I am not sure if horrified is the right word.
At the time it scratched an itch for a simpler alternative to acts_as_versioned. It was even used in Github for a little while IIRC.
17 years later what I can't understand is why a steady stream of people are still forking it. It's a rare week that goes by that I don't get a notification. 2 in the last day or so.
What's the game here? I can't think of any legitimate reason to fork a 17 year old plugin for a truly ancient version of Rails. So… what's the payoff?
I'm looking for the evidence of "thinking" or "reasoning".
I'm not arguing that these models hold up against GPT 3.5 and I still use GPT 4 when it matters. But they work and it's more like the difference between Premier League & Division 1, rather than PL & a five-a-side team from Bracknell.
Even a few years ago I could not have imagined this.
Given the pace of work on optimisation and my assumption that the M3 Studio I buy next will probably have 256GB of RAM at much the same power levels as I use now, it seems eminently possible it's a year or two away.
Am I missing a way to jump from the photo preview to the photo in the Photos app?
And I tend to agree with you that we would be better off if companies could define “enough” and maybe disband at that point rather than stagnating.
The thing lurking in my mind that maybe makes this a pipe dream is the Red Queen hypothesis.
I think I wrote three macros in my time with Clojure and none with Elixir. That’s because mostly I don’t need to, I can solve it with functions.
However my work in both languages rests on a lot of macros included in the stdlib and other libraries. Those macros make my life much easier and, when you really need macro power yourself it is right there.
Writing good macros can be challenging and supporting them after even more so. So it’s a power I use sparingly. But I depend upon macros all the time.