HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rester324

310 karma · joined September 29, 2022

submissionscomments
rester324··on Ask HN: Why is "Tea" still on the App Store after so many data breaches?
But didn't you just do exactly that by calling the parent's thoughts preconceived notions?

Edit: parent changed his/her comment after I posted my criticism. Originally it was much shorter and only wrote that the parent's comments are preconceived notions. No context, no nothing.

We really need a see history feature on HN

rester324··on Ask HN: Why is "Tea" still on the App Store after so many data breaches?
I don't think that Jordan Peterson is toxic. Although I haven't watched any of his videos for years now, so that might have changed. What makes him toxic in your opinion?

On the other hand I believe what you wrote can be summarized as toxic feminism.

rester324··on Ask HN: Why is "Tea" still on the App Store after so many data breaches?
Because there is no punishment for handling data with so much carelesness. If there was a law which seriously punished them, the app would be long gone. That's what you get when the tech bros dictate how the legislation should work
rester324··on Someone made a 128k line PR to OpenCut
Proof needed, otherwise it didn't happen. And I secretly hope that this is some kind of low quality satire
rester324··on NPM stylus package contained malicious code and was removed from the registry
Which is a wrong conclusion if I understand you correctly.

You can just host your own package repo and run your own verification to confirm if a package is indeed vulnerable or not. If it's not, you can just continue your operations as usual, regardless of what NPM (the company, the host provider, not the CLI tool) does in the background.

rester324··on NPM stylus package contained malicious code and was removed from the registry
I think this would be a fair assessment, if the security advisory would be true.

Since it's most probably false, the implications you refer to remain hypothetical, while the cost of cleaning up after npm's decision are measured in real M$s. And I think that's the real issue here.

I am not saying that we should give up on security altogether, but now there is so much toil attached to managing security, compliance and such aspects of the development lifecycle, that at some point managing all these aspects will outweigh all productivity a dev can bring to the project.

It's admittedly a hyperbole, but at that point the whole development procedure would simply become a pointless exercise without any benefit to anyone.

rester324··on Tokyo's retro shotengai arcades are falling victim to gentrification
That page is very outdated. More than 4 years old! Not even close to the current prices!

Also, just for your information, the japanese yen was continuously deflated in US dollars in the last 2 years or so. So even if it might seem from the US that this is cheap, the prices were soaring during the last 2-3 years in japanese yen.

So if you were unlucky enough to have a japanese salary in the last few years (as the locals mostly do), chances are that your real wages got continuously deflated.

Tokyo is actually much more expensive than other huge asian cities like Shanghai or Bangkok (denominated either in JPY or Remnibi, Thai Baht). That was also largely the reason for the LDP's abysmal election results this last Sunday.

rester324··on Tokyo's retro shotengai arcades are falling victim to gentrification
I think this largely depends on the size of the flat. So how large of a flat are you referring to?
rester324··on Tokyo's retro shotengai arcades are falling victim to gentrification
I am not sure what do you mean by forward looking? There are huge shopping districts under construction even right now in very central locations in Tokyo, basically building office towers and shopping malls.

What's forward looking about that? Other than that, the japanese tend to build roughly the same kind of low-riser/high-riser condominiums with varying quality literally everywhere. So it's not very easy to find and buy truly livable areas in downtown Tokyo right now, unless you are highly above the 80th-90th wage bracket.

Also, I find it odd to say that it's a society which only looks forward right now, when a right-wing populist party has just become tenfold stronger in the last parliamentary elections by propagating the idea of "traditional family values" (as in women to stay home instead of working).

While it's true that there are aspects of life which are more advanced than in other countries, but after living here for a decade, I can confidently say it's a mixed bag.

Just a silly example: when I came to the country, front loading drum type washing machines were a rare sight here, while that had been the norm for decades in many European countries. Also, the idea of insulating the houses from cold and heat and condensation was not at all considered until the government started pushing some tax breaks and whatnot to make the idea catch on and make housing more energy conscious. Etc, etc. Japan in many aspects were/is behind the times.

I wish people would stop idealizing japan as some kind of wonderland...

rester324··on From engineer to manager: A practical guide to your first months in leadership
You are generally wrong, but minimally true. If what you wrote was true, these people would be titled leaders or officers. But they aren't. Because they aren't. It's not that complicated. And yes, rarely some people show leadership, but that's rarely a requirement to be a manager
rester324··on Context Engineering Guide
Yeah, and wikipedia also states that engineering is a decision making process (often iterative) in which the engineering sciences, basic sciences and mathematics are applied to convert resources optimally to meet a stated objective.

So which scientific principles do context engineering apply?

There is none. So yeah. It's not engineering at all.

rester324··on Preliminary report into Air India crash released
These are not facts. These are mostly speculation.
rester324··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
I am not convinced.

If what you write was true, then the rate of bugs of those incredible devs would simply fall to zero at one point, and at that point they would become a legend who we all would have heard of by now. So the whole story sounds too fishy to my taste.

It's OK if you want to manage your team this way. Everyone needs some external feedback to confirm their own bias. It seems you found yours and it works for you.

It's just not a good argument in support of AI or AI assisted development.

It's too anecdotal.

And since you are the one who are telling me that you are right, and not others, it makes me even more skeptical about the whole story.

rester324··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
> Honestly, I don’t care about the “best coders.”

> Interestingly, the best AI assisted devs have often moved to management/solution architecture

Is it just me? Or does it seem to others as well that you pretty much rank these people even at the moment and your first comment contradicts your second comment? Especially when you admit that you rank them based on velocity.

I am not saying you shouldn't do that, but it feels to me like rating road construction workers on the number of potholes fixed, even though it's very possible that the potholes are caused by the sloppy work to begin with.

Not what I would want to do.

rester324··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
> Interestingly, the best AI assisted devs have often moved to management/solution architecture, and they find the AI code tools brought back some of the love of coding

This suggests me though that they are bad at coding, otherwise they would have stayed longer. And I can't find anything in your comment that would corroborate the opposite. So what gives?

I am not saying what you say is untrue, but you didn't give any convincing arguments to us to believe otherwise.

Also, you didn't define the criteria of getting better. Getting better in terms of what exactly???

rester324··on Everything around LLMs is still magical and wishful thinking
Feeling triggered? Feeling afraid? And yes, every claim needs to be proven, otherwise those who make the claims will only convince 4 year olds.

>People who understand their domains well and are excellent written communicators can craft prompts that will do what we used to spend a week spinning up. It's self-evident to anyone in that situation, and the only thing we see when people demand "evidence" is that you aren't using the tools properly.

You have no proof of this, so I guess you chose your camp already?

rester324··on Everything around LLMs is still magical and wishful thinking
But you just confirmed everything the blogpost claimed.

You didn't share any evidence with us even though you claim unbelievable things.

You even went as far as registering a throwavay account to hide your identity and to make verifying any of your claims impossible.

Your comment feels more like a joke to me

rester324··on Radio Garden
Interesting, I haven't heard of this station before, but most of the Shonan area has the vibe of a surf village so the music pretty much matches that vibe. Sounds like a station I'll visit more often.
rester324··on Dull Men’s Club
Maybe, but you forgot to write what's the benefit...?!
rester324··on Dull Men’s Club
I am a dull man by every measure. I don't have interesting hobbies, I am not an influencer, I don't post interesting posts on social media and I don't travel a lot, I don't do extreme things, I barely have any money at the moment, I bore others, in fact when I try to amuse my colleagues or the opposite sex, my jokes regularly fall flat and even my voice is dull I believe.

But after my kids were born I noticed something: my kids loved my voice, they listened to every sentence I made, they laughed at my quirky jokes I made and they loved when I sang to them or I brought them to the park or to the nursery and when I sat them on my neck. My wife took all that from me though, so now I need to fight to get my kids back.

But the moral of the story is: dullness is a matter of perspective. Even if you think you are dull, chances are you are not. It's just the world such a place now that the bar is raised too high that most ordinary people can't cross even by jumping over the moon.

So I don't care any more what others think of me. I came to accept my dullness and embraced it. If it bores others, I don't care.

rester324··on Japan Post launches 'digital address' system
Without knowing anything about the technical details, this sounds like a new type of URN to me
rester324··on The copilot delusion
Well that might be true, but I think the reason why they are blatantly acting like that because stakeholders and decision makers are detached from their decisions timewise.

That's why I bring such topics as maintenance and stability very early on into the discussions and ask those stakeholders how much system downtime they can tolerate, so that they can feel the weight of their decision making, and that gives me an opportunity to explain why quality matters.

Then it's up to them to decide how much crap they tolerate.

rester324··on The Future of Junior Software Engineering Roles
Interesting. I wouldn't have thought that.

I have an MS in CS from a small Eastern-European state run university, but the curriculum looked very differently: a ton of applied math yes, but also assembly programming, graphics programming, networking, databases, programming intro I-I, advanced programming I-II, project management, artificial intelligence, all kind of specializations, algorithms and data structures I-II, etc.

Is this not how it is in the US?

Edit: and most of those courses had practical lab sections with hands-on programming

rester324··on Too Much Go Misdirection
Yeah, they copied that too and the smugness of the early java community.

One example below, although I frequently bump into conversations in the golang community in the same vein just don't bother to save them: https://github.com/golang/go/issues/29461

rester324··on Airbnb is in midlife crisis mode
I don't think this is true. The proportion of short term rental places in some districts in European cities are as high as 8-10% and it's growing.

IMO it's meaningless to cite this 0.1% non-sense, because nobody will rent an AirBnB on the outskirts of huge cities far from tourist hotspots, so whoever comes up with these numbers, they probably try smearing the data by selecting an unreasonably wide area for comparison

rester324··on Clean Code vs. A Philosophy Of Software Design
Why would you not focus on writing OO code in an OO language for example? Would you start writing OO code in a functional langugage? No you wouldn't, because it would be pointless. There are programming paradigms for a reason
rester324··on Clean Code vs. A Philosophy Of Software Design
Uncle Bob is one of the core contributors to Fitnesse, which had moderate success in the Java popularity era back in the day.

Also, you do understand that people worked as software engineers even before Github became popular, or open sourcing to begin with, do you? So if someone is 60+ year old, chances are that most of his work has never been open sourced, and his work was targeting use cases, platforms, services which have no utility in this age any more.

Which have all nothing to do with how good a software engineer someone is.

And finally, do you have any proof that he never shipped any code into production?

rester324··on Waymo will bring autonomous vehicles to Tokyo
I guess the biggest challenge is gonna be not to get stuck in those narrow alleys that they call streets in Japan. Some of them can hardly take a kei car, let alone a sedan

I can already see in my imagination all the jijis swearing when they see those cars stuck :)

rester324··on Katakana, Hiragana, and Unicode
Something which surprises me is that these full-width and half-width formattings are still enforced sometimes even these days in new Japanese web services.

Considering that there is a seemingly easy lossless transformation path from/to these full-width/half-width alternatives, it would suffice to only support the full-width form one would think (and do some transformation as necessary without the user being involved).

← PreviousPage 4 of 4