507 karma · joined May 29, 2012
Whether or not this is true, Twitter definitely needs to start having multi-user functionality. Beyond TweetDeck Teams.
For storing TOTP keys on your YubiKeys, those must be the same, so you probably have to add them at the same time, or take a picture of the QR-code before you complete the registration.
I like having TOTPs stored this way, as you can use them with any device, including over NFC on Android, just by installing the Authenticator app.
Additionally I had pointed that their statements on XMPP security were factually wrong. No useful response or changes were made.
That all said, I really like a bunch of things about Slack and have repeatedly pointed out in discussions in the XMPP community that there is a lot to be learned from Slack in terms of features (and how they work technically), UI consistency, and usability. As JC points out, this is surprisingly hard to achieve in open source projects. Even harder to pull off for a very diverse community around a set of protocols, rather than a single software product.
There are also things in Slack that I think would be a lot better if they were modelled after recent protocol proposals in XMPP. For example we are working on something called MIX, an evolution on group chat, based on Publish-Subscribe. This allows for orthogonal streams of information bound to a channel, besides just chat and presence, like merge request notifications, Twitter mentions, etc. that could be displayed in a side-bar or ticker, instead of (annoyingly) interleaved with chat messages.
I would have welcomed Slack interacting with the community, but they didn't.