HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pixcavator

396 karma · joined February 27, 2007

My name is Peter Saveliev. I am a mathematician working in image and data analysis. The site I run is called Computer Vision and Math (http://inperc.com). It contains over 800 articles with 2100 illustrations. Feel free to contact me: last name @inperc.com.

My relations with HN are complicated and are described here: http://inperc.com/wiki/index.php?title=Hacker_News.

http://www.hackernewsers.com/users/pixcavator.html

http://hnofficehours.com/profile/pixcavator/

submissionscomments
pixcavator··on 13-Year-Old Makes Solar Power Breakthrough by Harnessing the Fibonacci Sequence
Well, the Calc 1 version isn't good enough because there are several variables here. You have to consider a continuous function defined on the sphere -- to capture all possible orientations of the panel. In fact, it could be a closed subset of the sphere -- to take care of all possible shadows, obstructions, etc. This is nice, you don't see a lot of direct applications of pure existence theorems...
pixcavator··on 13-Year-Old Makes Solar Power Breakthrough by Harnessing the Fibonacci Sequence
>If there is an unqiue optimal orientation for a single static panel (which under realistic assumptions there is)...

If you have some kind of “continuous function attains its max” argument here, I think you should elaborate. Because it’s interesting but not really “trivial”.

pixcavator··on Ask HN: Suggest features for a Virtual University Project
>>What should be the unique features that will motivate you to join and participate either as a teacher or as a learner.

On behalf of all teachers in the world, how about paying them?

pixcavator··on Eureka: A New Era for Scientists and Engineers
Q What is I-Corps?

A NSF Innovation Corps (I-Corps) is a public–private partnership that provides grants to determine the technology disposition of concepts developed by previously or currently funded NSF grantees.

pixcavator··on Offer HN: Free Maths Lessons
>>many a time i have to rely on wikipedia solely.

As a more readable alternative, try this http://inperc.com/wiki/index.php?title=Category:Courses.

pixcavator··on When Patents Attack
I wonder how Google would have looked at this idea 10 years ago, or even now: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-4-big-problems-with-googl....
pixcavator··on 30kloc and $0 revenue. Lessons from my failed startup (& code release)
The problem with how seasonal this is seems exaggerated. Just rename it hwbuff.
pixcavator··on Show HN: Compare your perception of female attractiveness to that of others
I think it might be a good idea to do pairwise comparison instead.
pixcavator··on PageRank is bad math: discussion
Ok maybe you do know. However, it's odd that you bring up that you work at Google and then add nothing new to the discussion (everybody knows about the 200 metrics). How about: "You're wrong, PageRank has never been the foundation of Google search"?
pixcavator··on PageRank is bad math: discussion
Initially it was the foundation and currently let’s just admit that neither of us knows.
pixcavator··on PageRank is bad math: discussion
You are saying, I think, that we won’t ever need to know π beyond some accuracy. By saying that you, if you are right, are doing good math.
pixcavator··on PageRank is bad math: discussion
They found time to publish this in 1998 but have been too busy since? I don’t think so. The reason is that they decided to keep all new development secret. That’s why we have to speculate.
pixcavator··on PageRank is bad math: discussion
Google was successful then with PageRank, but maybe now they need something better? It is my personal opinion but building something as huge (now) as Google search on such a shaky foundation as PageRank is dangerous.

I don’t think physical constants are made up and they certainly aren’t hidden.

pixcavator··on PageRank is bad math: discussion
Is manually penalizing the ranks of spam sites solid engneering too?
pixcavator··on The Pi Manifesto
Does this help: f_a (x) = a * x? Is this a function of x in your opinion?
pixcavator··on Illustrated Calculus Textbook
This isn’t really a book but rather lecture notes. That’s what students see as the lectures are being written on a tablet. Usually, what’s said is just as important as what’s written, so it’s not surprising that it may be hard to read if you go too fast.

I saw him do this a couple of years ago and it inspired me to try it myself. My handwriting isn’t nearly as good as his so I have to transcribe the lectures into TeX. Here’s Calc1 http://inperc.com/wiki/index.php?title=Calculus_1:_course, unfinished.

pixcavator··on How to Read Mathematics
I agree “Then x = y/2” is fine. However, your reasoning why this is OK (“=” is “equal”) is incomplete. Consider “Then the answer = y/2.”, which is grammatically correct but improper.
pixcavator··on Google Search By Image
Actually, TinEye is pretty good at partial matching.
pixcavator··on PageRank is an abomination (mathematically) -- discussion
>>PageRank, like almost all machine-learning algorithms, has some knobs which you can tweak to get various results.

PageRank is a machine-learning algorithm?

"You can tweak" means Google can tweak not the user...

pixcavator··on PageRank is an abomination (mathematically) -- discussion
Updated.
pixcavator··on When Will I Use Math?
I am more recent in applied math (coming from pure) but my impressions are very similar. For the last few years I keep discovering the same thing over and over again: the level of math in “technology” is abysmal, nobody understands it, nobody needs it. Incidentally, I am writing a blog post about PageRank right now. Short version: mathematically, it’s very unsatisfying.
pixcavator··on You can increase your intelligence
>it's hard to know what to infer when comparing a giant, multicultural country with a small, much more homogeneous one such as Singapore.

That's nothing. I remember a few years ago at this forum someone put forward a report that compared the US with a list of contries with the Vatican at the top.

pixcavator··on Intuitive explication of Fourier Transformation
I agree, this is the best way of looking at the issue. However, this approach requires one to learn a more advanced material first. It’s probably inevitable, but it may be a good idea to start with something more elementary. I’d suggest to start with a loose analogy with Taylor series (calc2).
pixcavator··on Google penalizes original content site because of scrapers
Hell with Facebook’s replacements; it’s Google who needs a replacement! (Note: I am currently thinking about possible alternatives for PageRank.)
pixcavator··on Conway's Game of Life Extrusion
>universe could be a type of cellular automata itself

The problem with this idea is that the universe, unlike any grid, is isotropic (or appears to be). That must be the reason why you don’t see examples of, for example, circular waves here.

pixcavator··on Khan Academy: the bad
It’s not a bad approach. However, the lectures are the only results I can see right now. I criticize the results that I see. And you don’t refute my points. You just see “the sign of weak criticism”.
pixcavator··on Khan Academy: the bad
I remember winging teaching as a TA. After 10+ years I know I stunk, no offense.
pixcavator··on Khan Academy: the bad
>I got rave reviews from students.

How many of them did you fail?

pixcavator··on Khan Academy: the bad
This book has taught me a good deal of algebra. It's self-teaching.
pixcavator··on Khan Academy: the bad
OK, how about a practical example? In all Khan’s lectures on linear algebra find an explanation of how it contributes to calculus.
← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →