HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oh_well

26 karma · joined October 7, 2016

submissionscomments
oh_well··on RethinkDB needs a new home
Please list a few successful open source AGPL projects with a significant user base.
oh_well··on RethinkDB needs a new home
I agree. I think the AGPL license perceived risk played a significant role in RethinkDB's lack of user acceptance.
oh_well··on RethinkDB needs a new home
> it seems like you have misunderstood what the AGPL does.

I've read the AGPL license. I disagree with your interpretation.

oh_well··on RethinkDB needs a new home
> How many people using RethinkDB are changing its code?

That's not the point. If you're even using the software the other software components would also be bound by the AGPL license.

oh_well··on RethinkDB needs a new home
> I don't know if this is a sound legal interpretation of the AGPL though.

Exactly. AGPL was explicitly created to make all clients of the software be bound by its license. To say that the drivers have a different license makes no sense at all.

oh_well··on RethinkDB needs a new home
As long as RethinkDB is AGPL most will just stick with postgres.

Is it possible (or likely) to get the creditors of Rethink to change the license?

oh_well··on RethinkDB is shutting down
Affero General Public License is much more restrictive than GPL. People are not comfortable using it in a commercial setting.
oh_well··on RethinkDB is shutting down
KDB is not really a database as much as it is an RPN calculator with a lot of memory.
oh_well··on RethinkDB is shutting down
That's an unfortunate license choice. No one will use it.