HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nathan_compton

3,118 karma · joined November 15, 2019

submissionscomments
nathan_compton··on Anthropic tells staff to work from home due to possible security team strike
Why not all of them, you know?
nathan_compton··on How Universities Should Prepare Founders
I've got a PhD in Physics and I have to say that the quality of most "self published" physics is very low, which probably explains why people would not accept a self-declared PhD.
nathan_compton··on Thinking in Python
Honestly, the best thing about LLMs is that they can write the fucking Python code for me. Dismal language, 0/10.

You know we live in a fallen world because R4RS existed when JS was invented. Can you imagine a world where the browser was scripted in Scheme?

nathan_compton··on Scientists release biggest 2D map of the universe
Presumably because even if galaxies are just big things, there are probably things in them that do philosophy, play pianos (roughly speaking) and shit post.
nathan_compton··on The Religious Experience of Philip K. Dick by R. Crumb (1986)
"It's not possible, everything can be explained by science sooner or later."

I'm not sure there is a good philosophical reason to believe this. I think something like it is certainly true, but its not entirely clear what an explanation even means, for one thing. And then there is the possibility that certain physical outcomes do not actually supervene upon the physical systems which constitute them.

I do not believe in mystical experiences as being informative about the true nature of the universe, and I generally think "science" is a useful set of tools for (at least) predicting the future and designing machines and perhaps even for constructing ontologies, but I don't think "everything" can be explained by science. I can see no powerful reason to think everything has an explanation.

nathan_compton··on Malicious Rust crate Arrayref runs a build-time payload
This response seems disingenuous. It was never implied it was ok to have exploits in the compiled software, only that the blast radius is smaller if the compiled code is also sandboxed.
nathan_compton··on The Religious Experience of Philip K. Dick by R. Crumb (1986)
Give me an example.
nathan_compton··on Exercise intensity modulates interorgan communication and is associated with
I don't know. It happened in college when I got involved in an organized, highly athletic, sport. Never stopped. I guess six months wouldn't be a bad number to put on it.

Exercise feels good to me. I think it felt good immediately when I started? I like the feeling of pushing myself and I kind of like discomfort/pain I can control.

nathan_compton··on Exercise intensity modulates interorgan communication and is associated with
> It had nothing to do with motivation, but making exercise a part of my day like brushing my teeth.

So it isn't about discipline either, it's about habits?

I'm like you. Routine exercise for the last 25 years or so. I feel neither particularly disciplined nor particularly motivated. It is either just a habit I've formed or I happen to have the correct physiological temperament for exercise to be easy.

nathan_compton··on How to put 170 atoms in an atom
Large orbitals like this approach the classical limit, I believe.
nathan_compton··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
I cannot believe the markdown guy is this deranged.
nathan_compton··on uBlock Origin is giving up the fight to keep ads off Facebook
I think you mean progressive pricing in disguise. The problem is that they are also a psychological attack.

I believe that we should, generally, as a society, discourage communication in bad faith, and ads very, very easily fall into that category. So perhaps in a local sense it is worth it for the reasons you suggest, but I think the mass dependence of our society on advertising makes our lives worse.

nathan_compton··on Show HN: Lumabri – What if LLMs worked like Napster?
I'm a data scientist, software engineer, etc. I use AI all the time. But when I create something for human consumption, I write it by hand. When someone gives me something written by AI I literally think "I could fire this person and just ask AI myself."
nathan_compton··on The Future Is for Everyone – The Path to a Positive AI Future
I will literally never believe that Meta gives a shit about the future. Their reputation is so far in the toilet from my point of view that it is already in the sewer.
nathan_compton··on Show HN: Lumabri – What if LLMs worked like Napster?
Here is some feedback: don't put slop in your readme. It's unreadable.
nathan_compton··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
Facebook is a pox on civilization, so one possibility is just firing it into the sun.
nathan_compton··on Meta Ran Ads That Contained AI-Generated Child Sexual Abuse Imagery
Pretty sure this isn't what they are teaching at the best business schools.
nathan_compton··on Could psilocybin be the key to treating anorexia?
I think the main difference is that radium was new and people have been using psychedelics forever.
nathan_compton··on Could psilocybin be the key to treating anorexia?
> just living in some rural area with limited participation in real life

They might say the same thing about your lifestyle. The "reward structure of society" is highly abstract these days, arguably disconnected from "real life". You could say monks are disconnected from "real life."

This is a weird take, I think.

nathan_compton··on A Surveillance Treaty in Disguise: Canada Signs UN Cybercrime Convention
I think this is more of an example of what arguments you are exposed to. We typically only see the most superficial version of our opponents arguments and we see complex versions of our own. Its one of the simplest kinds of propaganda.

"Capital" is a big honking book. It has substantially more to it than "take their money and give it to us," and contemporary leftist thought has a huge number of different intellectual takes on how to right the world, from syndicalism to libertarian socialism, and the debates are vigorous (sometimes too vigorous, if you ask me).

I could just as easily characterize (eg) the Christian right as fundamentally only making one argument: "God wants it to be this way." That would be dumb. I've read CS Lewis and Chesterton, Ivan Illich. I happen to think that, fundamentally, there isn't anything like the Christian god out there, but I can see that its not just as simple as the cartoon I sketched above.

nathan_compton··on Google will expand age checks on Android worldwide till the end of the year
I sympathetic to this perspective, as a parent, but also, there are just a lot of kids out there with bad parents.

My personal philosophy is that parents have a duty to raise their children but that duty is on behalf of the society into which the children will eventually enter. Consequently, a just society may sometimes impose itself on parental freedoms (in the case of neglect, for example) because, in the end, the child's ultimate guardian and responsibility is the society itself, not the parents. The internet is full of material exposure to which, for children, could reasonably be construed as neglect or abuse, and it is insufficient to leave the entirety of the responsibility to the parents, in that case.

I don't know why Americans are so obsessed with freedom as if were the only social good that a society can pursue. There are many things which make life worth living, that contribute to flourishing, and freedom is high on that list, but its not the only thing.

All that said, I don't approve of age checks of the sort being proposed everywhere now. We can do a lot better at mitigating these problems without damaging privacy so much.

nathan_compton··on A.I. companies are recruiting electricians and carpenters by the thousands
I can't remember taking a worldwide vote on the subject.
nathan_compton··on A.I. companies are recruiting electricians and carpenters by the thousands
Who is the "we" who decided to go with it?
nathan_compton··on I Want to Leave the Internet
Yeah, but it used to be like a good drug and now its like a bad drug.
nathan_compton··on Show HN: HART OS – an open-source AI OS built so frontier AI needs no datacenter
I appreciate the attempt to hide the AI slop style of the documentation, but it still very difficult to read and understand.
nathan_compton··on Terence Tao's ChatGPT conversation about the Jacobian Conjecture counterexample
Yeah. I am a professor and I see a lot of other professors saying they are pivoting to "Teaching AI". I tell them I am pivoting harder to teaching fundamentals because using AI is easy. Its the knowledge which is hard.
nathan_compton··on Startup founders urge U.S. government not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
Not the west, just rich people in the west.
nathan_compton··on Terence McKenna's Mega Bad Trip (2025)
I'm an absolute atheist and philosophical nihilist and I have done psychedelics and I've never had a problem with them. Typically find the experiences positive. So we have at least one counter-example.
nathan_compton··on A Road to Lisp: Which Lisp
I find Lisp much easier to read than most other languages. It is highly explicit syntax with very little ambiguity, especially if you have a little discipline about macros.
nathan_compton··on A Road to Lisp: Which Lisp
R6RS.
Page 1 of 34Next →