HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michael_dorfman

10,764 karma · joined April 15, 2008

submissionscomments
michael_dorfman··on UK chemist on Elsevier's ban on textmining
What would happen if you actually did try to textmine it. surely this is a game of chicken because no company wants to lose tens of thousands of dollars a year for no reason.

Elsevier is willing to play this game of chicken; they are convinced that their customers (i.e., research universities) cannot do without their product. Hence the OP reporting that twice, they instantly and without warning cut off all access to their product to the entire university, because of detected scraping.

Telling people what software they can use to read text doesn't scale.

Unfortunately, I think it does. If individual users, even a large number of them, use a plug-in, they might get away with it-- but this would result in an incomplete data set. To systematically textmine the corpus (which is the task at hand) requires some kind of systematic access to the data, and this is where Elsevier steps in and shuts it down.

michael_dorfman··on Elsevier Publishing Boycott Gathers Steam Among Academics
Is there any reason to believe that this is the case?

I'm a member of the ACM and the IEEE, and a lot of other people are; it doesn't seem to me that the modest dues are significantly hindering progress in the field. If, due to some unexplained fortune, the ACM and IEEE were to drop their paywalls tomorrow, and grant free access to all, how much would really change?

michael_dorfman··on US bars friends over Twitter joke
I left in 1997, and haven't visited since.

You get used to it.

michael_dorfman··on Show HN: my database engine for GPU
Sure, but F and E and completely different letters, even if they are almost identical (except for the little bar at the base of the E that is missing on the F).

A and Å are different letters, and can't be substituted for each other.

michael_dorfman··on Making universities obsolete
Let's remember that there is a lot more to universities than undergraduate education.
michael_dorfman··on Piracy - You can't have your cake and eat it
Recording companies have a monopoly on the artists they cover.

And that's the artist's choice. The artist could choose to distribute their work in some other fashion. So, if you want the artist's product, you have to buy it via the means chosen by that artist.

michael_dorfman··on Supreme Court Says Congress May Re-Copyright Public Domain Works
This is not really circular at all, merely self-referential; the Constitution also provides a process for it to be amended, so any and all of it's provisions could be repealed or rewritten without having to get a foreign government involved in the equation at all.

Of course, all of the parties involved (President, Senators, etc.) have sworn an oath to uphold the Constitution.

michael_dorfman··on Supreme Court Says Congress May Re-Copyright Public Domain Works
The rights of US citizens should be the foremost concern of a US legislator and when it comes to satisfying a treaty compromising those rights the treaty or international precedence should be thrown out the window.

Article VI of the Constitution explicitly disagrees with you: "[A]ll Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding."

In other words, the sovereignty was explicitly sacrificed when the treaty was entered into-- and that's the way the Framers intended it.

michael_dorfman··on Supreme Court Says Congress May Re-Copyright Public Domain Works
Does this mean that any time you want to sidestep an actual examination of the merits of an argument in the Supreme Court you just need to ensure there's an international treaty in your favour?

That ought to do the job; Article VI of the Constitution plainly states that "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding."

In other words, if there is a treaty obligation, that trumps all other considerations.

How does the US become party to a treaty, in any case? I'm guessing it has something to do with Congress.

Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution spells this out: "[The President] shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur..."

This seems like a bit of circular reasoning.

How so?

michael_dorfman··on I got it, now what?
Your next idea should be to get some external validation of your idea. A co-founder is a good way to do this.

You seem to think that "changing the way advertising works" is something that can be done by 3 devs is 12 months, and success (large enough to "yank this planet") will come "with some marketing."

Based on this alone, I'd suggest a serious reality-check is in order.

michael_dorfman··on Extreme Minimalism: this guy owns just 15 things
Most Buddhist monks could easily get under the "15 things" limit-- the standard list of possessions is: three robes, an alms bowl, a cloth belt, a needle and thread, a razor for shaving the head, and a water filter.
michael_dorfman··on JSTOR Tests Free, Read-Only Access to Some Articles
Actually, I think it indicates a pretty good understanding of their target audience. Although DRM can be circumvented by cutting and pasting, the hassle of doing so on an academic article would soon reach the point where the average academic would rather just pay the damn fee to download a copy.

At least I know I would, and I've paid a fair bit to JSTOR this past year...

michael_dorfman··on Deriving the Y Combinator
The quickest way to get from point A to point B, in this case, is the SICP video lectures: http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.001/abelson-sussma...

If you can spare two hours a day for two weeks (or the equivalent) you're golden.

michael_dorfman··on Dot-dash-diss: The gentleman hacker's 1903 lulz
It's also now the dominant spelling, and can't really be considered "incorrect".
michael_dorfman··on I'd like to start a company that takes care of your trash
Well, in many regions, trash collection is a municipal monopoly, so your customers are going to be city councils, not people.

Also, in many places, "curbside sorting" of the type you describe already takes place. Here in Norway, I get three trash bins from the city-- one for regular trash, one for paper, and one for food trash. About 25 years ago I lived in Montpelier, Vermont and there we had two streams-- one for recyclables like paper, plastic, and metal cans, and one for everything else. Both of these are based on weekly pickups-- daily pickups would be prohibitively expensive, it seems to me, and would also enlarge the environmental footprint (in terms of fuel required.)

michael_dorfman··on In Memoriam: Christopher Hitchens, 1949–2011
I can't speak for others, but this atheist doesn't want one.
michael_dorfman··on Microsoft decides to automatically update Internet Explorer for everyone
The major reason for end users to still have IE6 around is that they use proprietary applications which were written with IE6 in mind, and they see no good reason to spend money to upgrade these applications (if the vendor is even still interested in doing so) if it still works.

So, as long as there is a way to opt out, I imagine there are a lot of corporate folks who will do so.

michael_dorfman··on Amazon.com just closed my seller account. No warning, no details.
And that might be a compelling argument if there was a competitor to Amazon who offered the same value proposition plus better service as a differentiator.

In this case, I don't think there's really anywhere obvious for the traffic to go, so the "increased business" is fairly minimal.

michael_dorfman··on The Scientific Revolution Of India Before Muslim and British Conquest
It's worth noting that a lot of the dates mentioned in this article are far from the scholarly consensus on the matter; to take one example, the attribution of the Puranas to Vyasa is roughly similar to the attribution of the Pentateuch to Moses; it's not a reliable foundation for dating the texts (which most scholars place far later than 1000BCE.)

Similarly, the claim that Pythagoras was acquainted with the Upanishads is not historically attested; there's some fascinating work (by McEvilley) on cultural diffusion between the Ancient Greek and Ancient Indian worlds, but much of it is conjectural, and there's no "smoking gun" to support blanket statements of the type "Pythagoras read the Upanishads."

Finally, in my reading of the secondary literature, most scholars reverse the chronology in the statement "Philosophical formulations concerning Shunya - i.e. emptiness or the void may have facilitated in the introduction of the concept of zero." The consensus seems to be the opposite-- that the concept of zero in mathematics appears to have influenced the philosophical formulations around emptiness.

michael_dorfman··on Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for children
How do you reconcile that position with the original article?
michael_dorfman··on Don’t ask me for advice; buy me lunch instead
Arlo Guthrie tells a famous story about being accosted after a concert in 1972 by a skinny short guy who wanted to play him a song. Arlo said "How about you buy me a beer, and as long as I sit here drinking my beer, you can do anything you want?"

The skinny short guy was Steve Goodman, the song was "City of New Orleans", which became Arlo's biggest hit.

"That turned out to be one of the better beers of my life."

michael_dorfman··on Ask HN: How to "clarify" your business
If you've been in a sector for 10 years, I imagine you know who within that sector has money to spend. There's no point in going after a segment without money, right?

Once the segment has been identified, I'd then think about the sales process-- how well are you poised to sell to the decision-makers in this segment? Keep adjusting until you have a good fit.

Then, you turn to the final piece of the puzzle: what do you need to do to get these people to put their money in your pocket? What products or services do you need to provide? Generally, this means looking at a problem they have that is currently underserved; not necessarily a problem that no one else is attempting to solve, mind you, but one where you see an opportunity for competition or disruption. Sometimes, this means solving a problem they don't know they have-- if you can find some way to cut their costs or increase their revenue that they haven't thought of, for example.

When in doubt, look inside their organizations for critical processes that are still being done by Excel spreadsheets, and build a better alternative to these.

michael_dorfman··on Inaugural Kalzumeus Podcast: Japan, Startups, A/B Testing, And More
Both good decisions-- getting the transcription done cheaply, so it actually got done, and adding the "editor's notes" to add further context.

I'd definitely recommend this approach to all podcasts.

michael_dorfman··on Inaugural Kalzumeus Podcast: Japan, Startups, A/B Testing, And More
Thank you, thank you for the transcript. It makes podcasts so much nicer...
michael_dorfman··on Amit Gupta hasn't found a marrow transplant match; today's your last chance.
This is not true for Smiths in any part of the world.

Sure it is. See, for example, Eleanor Roosevelt.

michael_dorfman··on [dead]
You've got a visible comment from 3 minutes before this post. Had you made more today that are not visible?

The karma on comments is hidden, so there's no way for you to see that your comment upvotes aren't having an effect.

I don't know if there is any logic to subtly munge the visible karma on articles here; I know that Reddit does this, so upvotes there are not always immediately visible.

michael_dorfman··on Even my grandmother got immutability
I don't think that referring to a single anecdote as a "nail in the coffin" of a position while complaining of the lack of "actual studies" in support of that position is terribly consistent.
michael_dorfman··on Even my grandmother got immutability
Actually, what grandmother got was something different: the problem of overloading the "=" operator with variable setting. If you instead use, for example, arrows (as Knuth does in TAOCP) the problem goes away, and grandmother is no longer confused.
michael_dorfman··on Developer Income Report #16
It's at #12 now. The ranking algorithm is very sensitive to early votes, so a few votes in the first hour or so can make a noticeable difference in where the story ranks.
michael_dorfman··on Ask HN: What will you do when you're 40 and still unsuccessful?
You're not going to reach your potential if you tire yourself out beyond repair.

Pace yourself. It's a marathon, not a sprint.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →