HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mcpackieh

4,231 karma · joined June 18, 2023

submissionscomments
mcpackieh··on Piped – An alternative privacy-friendly YouTube front end
Skip that button and use BlockTube to blacklist channels instead.
mcpackieh··on Piped – An alternative privacy-friendly YouTube front end
> The worst is having a “Guest” mode on the TV app that you can’t turn off. It lets anybody completely bypass all restrictions. There is an open ticket on this dating back many years. Their best response to date has been ~ “it can’t be done - will share feedback with the team.”

This sort of thing is exactly why I roll my eyes when somebody suggests that it's the sole responsibility of parents to control what their children see online, and that anybody who complains about the state of things is just an irresponsible parent. The nature of tech products conspires to make this virtually impossible for all but perhaps an elite minority of technically inclined parents.. and probably still impossible even for them. Even the simple option of "no computers / internet in this household" is undermined by schools which give kids computers with leaky content blocking and require families to accept this.

mcpackieh··on Edinburgh couple are handed £17K bill by Tesla as they 'drove in rain'
"Problem that effects the entire fleet of cars" vs "they're lying" is a false dichotomy. Personally I think it's more likely that they're not lying and this particular car had a manufacturing defect.

But you seem to be very confident that it couldn't be a manufacturing defect with this particular car. How did you manage to rule this out?

mcpackieh··on Edinburgh couple are handed £17K bill by Tesla as they 'drove in rain'
Not surprising, Tesla is notorious for pulling this kind of shit.

> The thing is, Elon Musk could buy everyone in the world a Tesla if he wanted to.”

Is there a name for this kind of math error? For this to be true, a Tesla would have to cost something like $30.

mcpackieh··on Roundup herbicide ingredient connected to epidemic chronic kidney disease
Replicated research. Peer review is when journals ask other researchers to look at a paper and determine whether it's suitable to be published. Attempting to replicate the findings is typically not part of the peer review process, peer review is a sniff test.
mcpackieh··on LinkedIn is laying off nearly 700 employees
Surely this is just shitposting.
mcpackieh··on California to require firms to reveal carbon emissions in first law of its kind
> 3. Why do you add China to that list when it is widely considered by many diverse institutions to be state capitalist?

You mean China today? China today commits more than their fair share of human rights abuses, but the worst atrocities in the PRC were perpetrated in the past by staunch socialists, not those capitalist reformers who later introduced capitalist elements back into Chinese society. During the Cultural Revolution the Red Guard, a hard-line socialist paramilitary mostly comprised of students, were purging anything that vaguely resembled capitalism or tradition. They murdered millions of people for socialism.

mcpackieh··on California to require firms to reveal carbon emissions in first law of its kind
> How are you going to tax it if you don't track it?

This is a very good point, you should have stopped here instead of devolving into a purity spiral by attacking somebody who's obviously coming from a similar point of view: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purity_spiral

mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
> Teaching is a skill, which is why we don't ordinarily just let random people off the street start teaching kids.

We do in fact. Parents (what you term "random people off the street") are expected to take an active role in educating their children. Ask public school teachers in America what frustrates them the most and the two top answers will be their administrators and parents who aren't involved in the education of their children. Parents like the article author who think there is a "unspoken contract" that schools will handle all education are the bane of teachers. Teachers hate people like this. I have several school teachers in my family and they all rant nonstop about parents like this.

If a parent tries and fails to teach their child how to read before the first grade, that's fine. They can let the teachers know that and the teachers can start giving that child special attention right away. But a parent who doesn't even try because they think the education of their child is the sole responsibility of the school are the kind of parents that teachers hate. It's neglect, not legally actionable neglect but certainly neglect nevertheless.

By the time a child gets to the first grade they are already 6 or 7 years old and the window for easy reading acquisition is almost closed. The article author found this out too late and now her daughter still struggles to read. Incidentally...

> When it became clear that my daughter was also among the roughly half of all kids who will not read fluidly without explicit phonics instruction, I left my job, in part to help. [...] My daughter’s progress has been slower, perhaps because her tutoring took place online.

She left her job to help her daughter learn to read, yet her daughter is being tutored ineffectually on the internet. Why isn't she tutoring her daughter in person, if she left work to help? Because...

> I left my job, in part to help. I also embarked on a doomed crusade to persuade our school’s administration that—

Her idea of "leave work to help" apparently means leave work so she has more time to write angry emails at the school. The teachers must absolutely hate her.

Yeah I get it, not everybody knows how to teach kids to read, but she took off work for this so she should have the time to figure it out. She should go to a public library and tell a librarian that she wants to use the phonics method to teach her child how to read. Librarians can direct her to appropriate books and probably give her a ton of supporting material as well. But she's not going to do this because she's locked into the mentality that teaching her kid to read isn't a job for her. She wants schools or internet tutors to do it for her, and when that doesn't work she takes to writing articles complaining about the situation instead of doing it herself. Meanwhile the days tick away and her daughter becomes less and less likely to ever read well.

mcpackieh··on FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client
You can't copy an apple from an apple, they're not true breeding.

Even if that weren't the case, you couldn't copy an apple in a grocery store anyway.

mcpackieh··on FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client
It's like a bookstore that allows anybody to walk in from the street, browse the shelves and read books on a couch, but then says that you're only allowed to do any of this if you also make a purchase or politely listen to one of their employees give me a sales pitch. Well unless they get the cops to arrest me for trespassing, I don't care about their rule. I'll browse their books, read a few, and walk out without buying anything if I please.

If they don't like this, they can turn me away at the door. But they don't, they let me and I'm not signing any contracts with them, so fuck their rule.

mcpackieh··on FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client
> Not legally.

Call the police, nobody cares.

mcpackieh··on FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client
Normie-friendly projects like this are going to get yt-dlp ruined.
mcpackieh··on The largest dam removal in history stirs hopes of restoring tribes' way of life
> The only thing I think I know is not to blindly trust powerful voices advocating for a return to traditional values;

Stop being disingenuous, they're trying to save a river ecosystem, not legalize wife beating.

mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
You claim the PRC's imposed language changes are "to your private despair" as you publicly extol the supposed practical virtue of what they did and hold it up as a model for what you'd like done to English. You offer up token criticism of what the PRC did then lead immediately into "Nevertheless..." praise for the supposed benefits of what they did. I have seen this manner of duplicitous authoritarian apologia many times before, you aren't half as clever as you think.

Far from making things easier for children, you aim to make it far harder for them to access their cultural heritage by deliberately neglecting to teach them the language skills needed to access all extant English literature. I don't believe for an instant that this has escaped your consideration. You wish to deface the past so you can rewrite history; it's a form of book burning.

And structural racism? I guarantee you that any English speaking family with the means to do so would have their children privately taught to read traditional modern English, even if they had to do it themselves personally. You would create an underclass of quasi-literate English speakers, how is that supposed to address structural inequality? What you propose is not intended to promote equality, drop the bullshit.

mcpackieh··on The largest dam removal in history stirs hopes of restoring tribes' way of life
It's disingenuous to suggest that if the tribe tries to restore a river ecosystem that some other party is trying to force a lifestyle on them.
mcpackieh··on The largest dam removal in history stirs hopes of restoring tribes' way of life
Removing the dam is best for their welfare and the welfare of the river ecosystem, that's why they've fought for it. Or do you think you know better than them?
mcpackieh··on The largest dam removal in history stirs hopes of restoring tribes' way of life
Shitty logic, this tribe have electricity and want to restore the health of their river. Removing this dam is progress. They aren't being held back, they're moving forward. Complaining about this is idiotic. Do you people like dead rivers? Dead rivers are supposed to be something people accept and move on from, instead of problems to be fixed? What the hell.
mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
Here's realism: There is no authoritarian communist party of the English speaking world which may impose the kind of reform you proposed, so your idea is thankfully dead on arrival. You clearly covet that kind of power though, which is disturbing.

If the scope of the change you're proposing is limited to petty changes like color to colour or vice versa, then I'm confident that your changes would be ineffectual at improving literacy rates. There is no evidence that one spelling or the other is easier for children to learn.

But petty inconsequential changes like that are not what you're actually after. I think that you, with your obvious admiration for murderous authoritarian regimes and grandstanding against tradition, want to make 'traditional English' unintelligible to people who are only taught your new English. In this way you might hope to build a wall between young people and literature and other cultural materials from the past. Another Cultural Revolution is what you want, right? Tear down all that is old, purge society of traditional culture and probably murder millions of people along the way. Just as the CCP did. 枪杆子里面出政权 You admire and covet this kind of power, I can tell. Your little off topic mini-rant about tax policy tells me that you are not merely a would-be language reformer, but temporarily embarrassed head of state as well. Why not tell us about your agricultural policy too? I'm sure that somehow relates to the discussion just as tax policy does. Let me guess, step one is killing all the sparrows who eat our seeds.

You attribute to me a wish to forbid certain spellings, but which of us truly has this wish? Me, who has nothing but apathetic tolerance for the differences between American English and British English? Or you, who wishes to impose harebrained reform on the entire English speaking world and shamelessly uses the CCP as your model for how this might be done?

The English language will continue to change over time, as it always has, as all languages do naturally. What will not ever happen is a new system of writing being imposed on the entire English speaking world by fiat. Even if you became Supreme Leader of the People's Republic of America and forced your new system on the entire country, you would be dismayed to find that the overwhelming majority of English speakers do not live in America, nor any other single country. There is no single central authority for the English language, no governing body to capture. Imposing reform like you suggest is literally impossible so your proposal is beyond worthless. English is used by too many people in too many countries, you can't conqueror and subjugate them all.

mcpackieh··on Gnome developer proposes removing the X11 session
I'm pretty sure you're wrong. Looking over the part where you imply that the MacOS App Store is the standard way to install Applications on MacOS (opposed to dragging the application to the Applications folder), let's look at what the system you're referring to actually does:

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/xcode/configuring-...

Show me where it says a program installed from the MacOS appstore will be unable to read the user's files unless the user explicitly authorizes it. Here's how it actually works as far as I can determine: The application developer grants their app the entitlements to read user files. The user may see that entitlement before installing the application, but thinks nothing of it because of course the program operates on their files. This does not protect the user against a malicious program being shipped with those entitlements and a plausible pretext to justify it. Example: The user downloads a program to read some kind of unusual file for work, the program grants itself access to ~/Downloads because of course it needs that, then the program instead reads ~/Downloads/your-tax-documents

This system only protects the user if the application was legitimate, refrained from granting itself the relevant entitlements, then got compromised by an attacker.

mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
> We need a more rational alphabet tailored directly to English phonemes.

That would cause absolute havok for the billions of people who already know how to read English, but realistically you could never roll this out to the whole world... it would just become another teaching fad that cripples the kids subjected to it, by failing to teach them how to read English as the rest of the world writes it. You would be teaching kids to read and write using a system their own parents can't comprehend. It would be an absolute disaster.

mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
It sounds like the author didn't even attempt to teach their children how to read prior to entering 1st grade, due to the "unspoken contract between public schools and parents is that schools will teach their children to read."

Seems nuts to me, I thought the unspoken contract is that parents read to their kids at night and teach them to read at the same time. I guess the author thinks only rich parents can do that (come on now..)

mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
Is the lesson that we should switch to Korean? English may not be ideally 'designed' but how would you change how English is written without causing havoc for the billions of people who already learned it?
mcpackieh··on The Decades-Long Travesty That Made Millions of Americans Mistrust Their Schools
Three thoughts,

Is it really true that 1 in 4 schools stopped teaching kids to associate sounds with letters so they could sound out words? That sounds so insane it beggars belief. If that's true then no wonder people don't trust schools; trust isn't warranted. But the idea is so insane on the face of it that I have trouble believing it.

Secondly, if 1 in 4 schools did this and half of the students in these schools fail at reading because of it, then "and a large part of why more than half of our country’s fourth graders aren’t demonstrating proficiency on reading exams." seems a bit dubious. If school's adopted this program independent of school size and half of the students at those schools struggled to read for this reason alone, then I'd expect roughly 1/8th of all students nationally to be negatively effected, not one half.

Third, it would have been nice for this article to go more into the history of the idea. It pretty much lays all the blame on this Lucy Calkins and Teachers College Reading and Writing Project, but also blames this line of thinking for a 1973 SCOTUS decision. That was several years before the Teachers College Reading and Writing Project was founded, but the article doesn't go into this history.

mcpackieh··on Decline in independent activity as a cause of decline in child mental health
Sometimes people get so tangled up in half-baked theories and rationalizations that they need to be reminded that water is wet. It should be common sense that lack of autonomy will mess kids up, but some people just don't get it. A refusal to tolerate any risk or uncertainty ironically ends up doing more damage than whatever it is they fear.
mcpackieh··on Gnome developer proposes removing the X11 session
> The reality is that many users use untrusted applications that don't have access to home, ergo Flatpak.

I'd like to see this quantified. How many people using flatpack are afraid of their application reading their files, vs using flatpack simply because it's a convenient way to install programs? I don't mean "oh me me!" responses, are there any user surveys to support the premise that average users are afraid of their applications?

Quite frankly I don't believe this level of paranoia is the norm. On Windows and MacOS, applications installed in the normal way can read the files on your desktop. This is the way it as always been on Linux too, with few exceptions. Letting the most paranoid users set the norms is a recipe for irrelevance. How popular is Qubes? It's a pain in the ass.

mcpackieh··on Gnome developer proposes removing the X11 session
OBS is absurd bloat. What's the wayland equivalent of `ffmpeg -f x11grab`?
mcpackieh··on Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message
> Do you really think Google just set the price arbitrarily?

No, not arbitrarily. But that $14/mo bundles in the price of other services as well, namely Youtube Music. Youtube Music doesn't cost Google nothing, so obviously $14/mo isn't what they're getting from people in ad revenue. A comparable music subscription from spotify costs $11/mo, so subtract that from $14/mo. $3/mo is a fair estimate for what they expect to get for showing ads.

mcpackieh··on Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built on efficiency
Conventional wisdom says that people throw trash on the ground at a rate inversely proportional to the number of public trash cans. Japan has very few public trash cans (a response to the sarin gas attacks in the 90s) yet their streets remain clean.

Does the example of Japan prove the conventional wisdom wrong?

mcpackieh··on AI accurately predicted 70% of earthquakes a week in advance
If it technically predicts earthquakes but can't tell you which of the earthquakes will be strong enough to warrant evacuation, then will people heed the warning for the big one after they've had a few evacuation notices for imperceptible earthquakes? It's a "boy who cried wolf" problem.

The vast majority of earthquakes are very weak, so predicting the time and area of earthquakes seems worthless if they can't accurately predict the magnitude as well, with very few false positives.

← PreviousPage 16 of 34Next →