HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martingoodson

1,760 karma · joined February 6, 2012

martingoodson at gmail space com Chief scientist at Evolution.AI
submissionscomments
martingoodson··on Sleep regularity is a stronger predictor of mortality risk than sleep duration (2023)
Don't watch any kind of screen in the evening. Read a book instead. You'll fall asleep sooner.
martingoodson··on How to make buffet breakfasts less wasteful
"Conclusions: This meta-analysis confirmed that skipping breakfast is associated with overweight/obesity, and skipping breakfast increases the risk of overweight/obesity. The results of cohort studies and cross-sectional studies are consistent. There is no significant difference in these results among different ages, gender, regions, and economic conditions."

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31918985/

martingoodson··on Ordinary Lab Gloves May Have Skewed Microplastic Data
People seem to be misunderstanding this paper. It doesn't claim that any previous papers have overestimated contamination. That would only happen if scientists didn't routinely use blanks as a comparison, which they do. E.g. "A procedural filter blank was created during each sample batch and analysed alongside the samples, to enumerate potential contamination that could have been introduced during the extraction process."

https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/476076/1/1_s2.0_S014765132300286...

martingoodson··on People say they prefer stories written by humans over AI, study says otherwise
Title needs to be changed. It completely misrepresents this research. There was no comparison between human written and AI written stories.
martingoodson··on Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice
Honestly, I think if I wasn't there, she still would have loved it. She related to it like a person.
martingoodson··on Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice
I played with this last night with my four-year old daughter. We had fun with asking Miles to explain what bones are made of etc.

Today, she asked "where has that robot guy gone?". Crying now because I won't let her talk to Miles anymore.

She has already developed an emotional connection to it. Worrying indeed.

martingoodson··on Why LLMs still have problems with OCR
Written by someone who knows what they are talking about.
martingoodson··on Why LLMs still have problems with OCR
I've worked in data extraction from documents for a decade and have developed algorithms in the space. I've developed a product using LLMs for this purpose too.

This article is essentially correct.

martingoodson··on Ingesting PDFs and why Gemini 2.0 changes everything
I work in financial data and our customers would not accept 96% accuracy in the data points we supply. Maybe 99.96%.

For most use cases in financial services, accurate data is very important.

martingoodson··on A new type of neural network is more interpretable
We hosted Ziming Liu at the London Machine Learning Meetup a few weeks ago. He gave a great talk on this fascinating work.

Here's the recording https://youtu.be/FYYZZVV5vlY?si=ReoygVJMgY9oje3p

martingoodson··on Meta AI releases Code Llama 70B
Baptiste Roziere gave a great talk about Code Llama at our meetup recently: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_mhMi-7ONWQ

I highly recommend watching it.

martingoodson··on EU strikes deal to regulate ChatGPT, AI tech
Do you have any reference for this claim, or are you guessing? It was reported that the algorithm was a Gradient Boosting Machine by investigators who gained access to the code.

https://www.lighthousereports.com/suspicion-machines-methodo...

martingoodson··on Understanding Deep Learning
I think because it's a relatively 'younger' field, there is a bit more need to know about the foundations in AI than in programming. You hit the perimeters a bit more often and need to do a bit of research to modify or create a model.

Whereas it's unlikely in most programming jobs you would need to do any research into programming language design.

martingoodson··on Understanding Deep Learning
Not at all. It's something I've seen in practice over many years. Neither skill set is 'better' than the other, just different.

There is a need for people who are able to build using available tools, but who don't have an interest in the theory or foundations of the field. It's a valuable mindset and nothing in my original comment suggested otherwise.

It's also pretty clear that many comments on this post divide into the two mindsets I've described.

martingoodson··on Understanding Deep Learning
Most comments here are in one of two camps: 1) you don't need to know any of this stuff, you can make AI systems without this knowledge, or 2) you need this foundational knowledge to really understand what's going on.

Both perspectives are correct. The field is bifurcating into two different skill sets: ML engineer and ML scientist (or researcher).

It's great to have both types on a team. The scientists will be too slow; the engineers will bound ahead trying out various APIs and open-source models. But when they hit a roadblock or need to adapt an algorithm many engineers will stumble. They need an R&D mindset that is quite alien to many of them.

This is when an AI scientists become essential.

martingoodson··on We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to return to OpenAI as CEO
It's not about critical thinking: the employees were about to sell up to $1B of shares to thrive capital. This debacle has derailed that.
martingoodson··on Outperforming larger language models with less training data and smaller models
Sorry! Here's the paper https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10169
martingoodson··on Outperforming larger language models with less training data and smaller models
We discussed this at our meetup last night. See here for paper reference and subscribe to get an alert when the recording is uploaded: https://www.meetup.com/london-machine-learning-meetup/events...
martingoodson··on Goodreads is terrible for books – why can’t we all quit it?
The deeper problem here is that review sites don't work well for things as personal as books. I've read many books based on excellent reviews in amazon, and hated many of them. Most people don't have the same taste as me. Likewise many people hate the books I love, and give one star reviews to them.

What's the solution to this?

martingoodson··on Miles Davis: A candid conversation (1962)
This is to misunderstand Miles Davis. The point is that he treated the trumpet player with respect, as if he was taking to a trumpet player, not a child. He was engaging with a group of peers. The evidence for this is that he went on the hire the keyboard player, who was 16 years old, to play in his band a year later.
martingoodson··on Octopuses, crabs and lobsters recognised as sentient beings under UK law (2021)
This new law is irrelevant to these points. Vertebrate animals were already considered sentient in UK law. So sharks, dolphins, turtles, fish etc were already covered.

Your outrage comes several years too late.

martingoodson··on The Alan Turing Institute has failed to develop modern AI in the UK
Sorry for not being clear enough. The point is that this £100M is very likely to be spent on the Turing Institute since it seems to suck up all AI funding in the UK. It will therefore likely be wasted.
martingoodson··on The Alan Turing Institute has failed to develop modern AI in the UK
That's a good point. Thank you. Officially the open source model was released by the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich’s CompVis lab. I agree that's something of a technicality.
martingoodson··on The Alan Turing Institute has failed to develop modern AI in the UK
Of course there are pockets of good work, like in any research institute. It's difficult to point to anything really pushing the envelope in AI research though. You have any evidence to the contrary?
martingoodson··on The Alan Turing Institute has failed to develop modern AI in the UK
The failure to do any meaningful work related to the most important breakthrough in AI ever is objectively bad.
martingoodson··on The Alan Turing Institute has failed to develop modern AI in the UK
Because it's irrelevant to the point I'm making in the piece. Like I wrote, lack of infrastructure can be fixed with funding. The other issues can't.
martingoodson··on The role of meat in the human diet: evolutionary aspects and nutritional value
In case anyone takes this comment seriously:'There is strong evidence that processed meat and red meat intake increases risk of colorectal cancer.[31][32][33] The American Cancer Society in their "Diet and Physical Activity Guideline", stated "evidence that red and processed meats increase cancer risk has existed for decades, and many health organizations recommend limiting or avoiding these foods."[34]'

This is from Wikipedia. References are to solid science. Not to YouTube influencers.

martingoodson··on Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal
This isn't a particularly high quality study. Eg no Statistical power sample size calculation done beforehand.
martingoodson··on Twitter is censoring journalist critical of Tesla
The 'fuss' is probably what caused Twitter to change their policy on this. The 'fuss' is why people like you can now search the uncensored results, two days after the censorship was first reported.
martingoodson··on Twitter is censoring journalist critical of Tesla
Yes I checked. He doesn't appear. Someone with 15 followers appears instead. And Elon Musk. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eowMi0P84lXom3jAxzJwaDC7gfM...

Do you have a screenshot of your results?

Page 1 of 8Next →