HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

marstall

982 karma · joined July 16, 2009

submissionscomments
marstall··on 90M people. 118 hours of silence. One nation erased from the internet
what are you referring to? Amnesty International, to take one example, has a huge banner supporting Iran's protestors on their homepage rn

https://www.amnesty.org/en/

marstall··on Self-driving cars aren't nearly a solved problem
Waymo has a blog post here about how humans help the computer driver with various challenging situations like lane closures with ambiguous cones, etc.

https://waymo.com/blog/2024/05/fleet-response?utm_source=cha...

marstall··on Novo Nordisk launches Wegovy weight-loss pill in US, triggering price war
How long did those effects take to come into effect? I have been on 2.5 for a week and haven't noticed a change in my appetite, though I have lost 2 pounds.
marstall··on Travel agents took 10 years to collapse. Developers are 3 years in
>Opus 4.5 has really startled me - it genuinely can do complex software engineering tasks which I'd expect a proficient developer to take hours in minutes with very few defects.

I don't use Opus, but I use Sonnet 4.5 and ChatGpt 5.1, which are only a bit down the chart.

in my daily experience, these tools can help with many tasks - scaffolding crud, writing tests, explaining how this or that part of the code works, are three that come to mind.

But a mature piece of software has usually graduated to a point that it has numerous subsystems, layers and integrations that crosstalk with each other in often hacky ways. And my work is smack dab inth middle of that. Writing a feature or fixing a bug in that soup, I have found, is something that the best AIs will slow you down with as often as they speed you up.

And that doesn't even take into consideration that a very large part of my job is just defining what the bug or feature is, before I can even begin to code. And when I'm done with the coding, lets keep in mind the fun, time consuming processes known as "code review" and "deploy to customer"

marstall··on Backing up Spotify
they also offer a bunch of stuff like

- searchable website

- incredible well thought out postgres database that differentiates, for example, a recording from a release (and much, much more)

- ability to replicate changes to said database hourly to your own environment

- workable system for schema updates

- cover art archive

- refined interface for submitting/moderating listings

- etc.

marstall··on Backing up Spotify
the top 10,000 songs seem to be 99.9% top-40 corporate pop, which suprised me. thought a list that broad would pick up more that was outside the maintream ...
marstall··on Show HN: Hacker News, but every headline is hysterical clickbait
some of these are better headlines tho
marstall··on Oliver Sacks put himself into his case studies – what was the cost?
yup, me too.
marstall··on Show HN: Epstein's emails reconstructed in a message-style UI (OCR and LLMs)
brilliant. feel bad asking for something more - but an inline annotation of who these people are would take it over the top.
marstall··on Marble Springs (1993)
this captures the early of excitement of hypertext in a cool way. seeing the technology through Deena Larsen's eyes is a trip. To her it was a way to be more experimental in expressing her research, and a new way of writing poetry. Must have been quite exciting to make Marble Springs in 1993.
marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
What kind of area were you talking to it about?
marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
i guess i'd rather have the understanding it's offering me, with a smudge of, sure, call it bullshit, than not know it at all.

If you think about it, there is no source out there that is unimpeachable, and there is a need to consult many sources to get closer to the truth. triple all that for a rare disease.

marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
I have the sense overall, from talking to it about aspects of his condition that I understand well, and also using it as a coding assistant in work, that by and large it's on point.
marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
sorry, i didn't even read the article because I have everything blocked. From the comments, whatever it is it sounds terrible.
marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
I am using it mostly to try to understand and get context about what the professionals tell me, the treatments they are offering, etc.
marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
i quiz it often on aspects of my son's condition that I understand, and it gets things right most of the time, with the occasional glaring bit of misinformation.
marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
> You guess it is a small percentage?

Well I am operating within a space where his doctors are setting the parameters in terms of the pathways targeted, the therapies offered, etc. And I'm asking, how does this therapy work? How is it related to X and Y? How strong is the evidence? Questions like that. I think I can throw the appropriate grain of salt on it, but yeah, some fake facts could creep in. It's stuff that will be validated, but super valuable to just synthesize the lay of the land and give me context for understanding what the docs are saying.

> Curious why do you think you not have gotten these insights that too even from textbooks no less?

Partly just how tailored and conversational ChatGPT is. It gets right at my needed level of explanation. It knows how much education I have. It remembers salient details about my son and his condition. It really explains things well. It knows so much. It's quite remarkable.

[note, i didn't read the article so am not opining on its content in any way. An AI college education sounds terrible in many ways]

marstall··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
I just had a pretty amazing 4 hour session with gpt 5.1 going over my son's rare disease. Chat broke it all down for me in a really deep and clear way in the back and forth. Insights I've never gotten to from talking to docs, reading papers, reading bio textbooks etc.

I guess some small percentage of it was hallucinated, but if you want to call it a teacher/student relationship, it was pretty amazing.

marstall··on Google Antigravity
I don't get how these agents can work when even Claude Sonnet 4.5 (for example) needs a lot of hand-holding for basic, simple bugfixing stuff. Wouldn't the agents just be huffing and puffing their way off the rails all the time?
marstall··on My stages of learning to be a socially normal person
really identify. especially with the early yearning to connect and not having the skills. Learned sooo much over the years by being brutally rejected and eventually taking stock of what happened and extracting a rule or two. but then, yeah, next phase, rules don't matter (except when they do) and change moment to moment anyway.

funny to read this here on hacker news of all places, where I let my carefully managed, almost always inhibited, childhood nerd self fly free in the comments.

OP has definitely gone beyond me in many ways, with his talk about embodiment, and being able to be so empathic that he has elicited tears of gratitude. Enviable.

marstall··on Fighting the New York Times' invasion of user privacy
> infamous for promoting authoritarianism

what are you referencing here?

marstall··on Palantir CEO Alex Karp calls his company the first to be 'completely anti-woke'
It's not the opposite, it's kind of both. It stands for good things (awareness of inequality) - but it has landed in a place where it is perceived by people as having a prescriptive or condescending tone. This is largely because of the way the right has twisted and co-opted it.
marstall··on Palantir CEO Alex Karp calls his company the first to be 'completely anti-woke'
What twisted logic from him. A woke perspective on Fentanyl would be to be aware of its effects on marginalized people, and try to do something about it. Which it sounds like he would be in favor of? So he's woke?
marstall··on Palantir CEO Alex Karp calls his company the first to be 'completely anti-woke'
totally. woke means awareness, being aware of unfairness based on race, gender, sexual preference, being different, etc. So if you're "anti-woke" - you what, want to maintain all the prejudice and inequality in our country?

This guy is smart on so many levels but maybe needs to check himself out on this one.

marstall··on Solarpunk is happening in Africa
yeah it's a crazy trend. suspicion that everything is AI is a poison to forums. have no idea how this moves forward. secretly hoping it destroys the entire internet, and rapidly. so we can go back to conspiring in smoke-filled rooms.
marstall··on Solarpunk is happening in Africa
people saying this is AI-generated: why? It seems voicey, pacey, individualistic ... and contains new-to-the-world info. And it's good. None of these being qualities I associate with AI writing.
marstall··on Enjoy CarPlay While You Still Can
Actually, whether it's texting, talking on the phone, or yes, troubleshooting a connection, tech-distracted driving is a big risk for drivers, causes tons of accidents.
marstall··on Enjoy CarPlay While You Still Can
I love CarPlay, but I do feel like I'm risking my family's life when it fails to connect and I'm left fiddling with it while driving. It seems like what GM's doing would at least eliminate that risk factor.
marstall··on The Case That A.I. Is Thinking
Unless the idea of us having a thinking self is just something that comes out of our mouth, an artifact of language. In which case we are not that different - in the end we all came from mere atoms, after all!
marstall··on Facts about throwing good parties
my rules of throwing a good (house) party:

1. good music with a beat. play records if you can, it's fun.

2. no food. people already ate.

3. hit the liquor store pre-party and get a few cases of booze.

4. if there's something a girl wants to listen to, let her. she'll dance with her friends.

5. be super high energy.

6. whip-its

← PreviousPage 2 of 22Next →