HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

krisgee

483 karma · joined August 28, 2013

submissionscomments
krisgee··on The Life of NHL Dentists
>There's also a fighting culture in North American professional hockey which would be destroyed by mandatory full face protection.

Having grown up playing hockey in a pretty rough league that's not true. You just hook your hand under the back of the helmet and pull, it'll pop right off.

krisgee··on Why is Middle School so hard?
>Based on my experience, nothing quite kills the joy for exploration and learning like school.

I thought I hated Math till I got to university. I had to take a bunch of remedial courses on high school level math but ultimately ended up with a math minor in addition to my CS major because I enjoyed the subject so much.

The K-12 school system is fundamentally broken but I don't know what the solution is.

krisgee··on Severely deficient autobiographical memory in healthy adults (2015)
Final Fantasy 4 and Stairway to Heaven are inextricably linked in my mind for a similar reason.
krisgee··on Disney Bans Netflix Ads as Streaming’s Marketing Wars Intensify
We'll have another "piracy epidemic" where streaming services have hysterics and try to ban piracy. This will predictably not work as it hasn't the last few times. Someone will make purchasing content easy again and everyone will use that.

Corporations will get involved, jack the prices up, throw in ads and try to invent cable again.

Repeat.

krisgee··on iOS 13’s privacy pop-ups of Facebook data grabs
I replaced Messenger Lite with Disa which is a (when's the last time you heard this) multi-protocol instant messenger platform. Works pretty well for those of my friend who can't get off messenger.
krisgee··on No-deal Brexit opponents defeat government
>It's hard to believe that a one-year suspension in modern times would stand, but resolving it would be messy.

It'd be a pretty much immediate constitutional crisis but I don't doubt at all that it'd end up with the head of state getting changed to an elected position. Definitely messy though which is why the tradition stuff works fine for now.

krisgee··on No-deal Brexit opponents defeat government
>But it can't be as simple as that. If a prime minister asked the Queen to suspend parliament for a year, she wouldn't approve it.

It is actually though. We had a similar situation in Canada a few years back where the PM prorogued parliament for an extended period of time and the Governor-General (our representative of the Crown).

The procedure for formally ratifying a bill is called Royal Assent[1].

An exerpt from the wiki article on it kind of sums up your issue

>Under modern constitutional conventions, the sovereign generally acts on, and in accordance with, the advice of his or her ministers. However, there is some disagreement among scholars as to whether the monarch should withhold royal assent to a bill if advised to do so by her ministers. Since these ministers most often enjoy the support of parliament and obtain the passage of bills, it is improbable that they would advise the sovereign to withhold assent. Hence, in modern practice, the issue has never arisen, and royal assent has not been withheld.

So it's all a matter of tradition and stuff. Theoretically the Queen could go and put her foot down in England or in any other Commonwealth realm that she still technically rules.

That said the common consensus on what would probably happen there is that parliment would essentially immediately have a vote on tossing the queen as head of state, probably write in some elected presidential position or something to do all the stuff that the Queen or her representative used to do then go back to arguing about whatever they were before and the main consequence would be a wasted voting period and having to remove "Royal ____ of ______" from a lot of organizations.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_assent

krisgee··on No More Cheap Shipping for Chinese Sellers
Universal Postal Union is a UN body that manages the relationships between different national post offices. They set standard rates and stuff for all member countries so that each country doesn't have to negotiate a treaty with any other country it wants to send international mail to.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Postal_Union

krisgee··on Smartphones Are Toys First, Tools Second
They don't. The biggest thing people on HN tend not to realize is that they aren't the target market for this kind of stuff. Alerts drive engagement, otherwise devs wouldn't waste the time to put them in. Same with ads and analytics stuff, they are a nightmare to put in and maintain but it's the surest way to make money.
krisgee··on Ask HN: Do you like/use Reddit's redesign?
The third party reddit apps are a lot better. I prefer Reddit Is Fun on Android but I know there are several good options besides that on both mobile platforms.
krisgee··on NY Man Arrested for Cutting Wires to Red Light Cameras (2016)
I'd argue politics has probably always been just as corrupt, if not more corrupt than it is now. We just know about it because they found out that when exposed the average person just doesn't care.
krisgee··on Do the Rich Capture All the Gains from Economic Growth?
Firstly as pointed out in other comments they were measuring income. People at higher incomes in the 80s were probably more likely to retire early or "on time". A more representative number would be wealth which I would imagine is probably horrifying in the vein that the parent and grandparent meant. People living hand to mouth in the 80s were probably doing the same in 2014. People who could save probably weren't.

Even just from the numbers presented imagine the lower percentile person who was making say 10k in constant dollars in the 80s. They're making 20k (100% increase) in same dollars in 2014.

Imagining the person in top was making 1,000,000 dollars in constant dollars they dropped 29% so they're now "only" making 750kish.

I know which group I'd rather be in.

krisgee··on GoPro Hero 7
I've had good experiences with my SJCam alongside my GoPro and I know they have a Session sized/shaped format. You could try those out.
krisgee··on Ask HN: Best hard scifi AI novels?
Really good story. I didn't really agree with the eco-primitivistic moral when I read it but I finished it all the same which should say something about how fundamentally good it is.
krisgee··on How a Man’s Bad Math Helped Ruin Decades of English Soccer
I posted in a sibling comment to this one about how this argument reminds me of one that happened in hockey.

Specifically I claimed that one of the big reasons that possession became more prized is because of Hockey Canada changing their developmental programs after missing gold at the Winter Olympics three times in a row. Specifically they started to do serious analysis on teams that were winning, both in the NHL and international level teams.

I was lucky enough to have parents well off enough that I got to play organized travel team hockey through my entire childhood (age 5 - 18). I'm 27 and I caught the beginning of the shift in thinking near the middle of my developmental "career". You could tell the difference immediately (and it wasn't incredibly kind to a physcally large forward like myself). Even more so, if you went and watched some of the high level younger teams though, the ones that got coaches from away and got taught the latest theory you could see the way the game was re-shaping itself even if at the top current level the stats were just showing that "good teams are performing well".

So that's why I think that dismissing theory and statistics as just saying that the other team is "better" in a roundabout way is missing the point. Quantifying which team is better and why allows changes to the developmental programs that produce players. If you look at the kids that came out of the developmental shift you can see the results of the statistical analysis, the 90s and early 00s was not kind to North American international hockey but as the kids that were taught with the new statistically informed program started moving up to the professional level you can see the level of play increasing and now it's Canada and the US that are the dominant teams on the world stage and all of that happened because the people running the programs started to look at the statistics of what actually worked and implementing them into the training and development of the next generation of athletes.

krisgee··on How a Man’s Bad Math Helped Ruin Decades of English Soccer
Not really up on Football (soccer) but this reminds me of the puck possession vs dump and chase zone entry debate from hockey.

For a lot of reasons (up to and including global geo-politics) North American teams for a long, long time over-emphasized dump and chase The basic tactic is that you carry or pass the puck up until it will no longer cause an icing call then throw it into the other teams defensive corner and send your forwards in to generate a turn over.

Until reasonable statistical analysis this was thought of as the "right" way to play the game. Actually it was long AFTER the statistics showed it because politics was playing a role in what the statisticians wanted to find. They wanted to prove that the NA way of playing was "right" so they went and found stats to prove it. It wasn't until a combination of the NHL rising ascendant, the fall of the Soviet Union and I would argue the fact that Canada missed Gold in the '92, '94, and '98 Winter Olympics that forced Hockey Canada to look at their developmental programs and do some honest analysis.

Today though, much like in this article short quick passes and maintaining possession through zone entry is preferred and the statistics back that up. I'd imagine that if what you say Liverpool has been doing it true it's for similar reasons, maintaining possession allows you to generate more shots, shots are important if you want to score, ergo keeping possession is important for scoring.

krisgee··on The Paradox of Doping in Mountain Climbing
>you can use equipment that will make it easier for you, but then others might not feel as impressed.

Put another way if do something in a non-orthodox way (free ascent w/o oxygen) that might be MORE impressive than a traditional ascent with O2 assistance but that doesn't mean the traditional ascent isn't impressive on it's own.

krisgee··on The Complexity Barrier (2003)
>and have it only be valid if you or the computer can prove that it meets that specification (and have the specification be complete and correct of course

Hasn't this just moved all the issues with writing code over to writing the specifications?

krisgee··on The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your Own Backyard
Sort of except instead of one person being responsible for each of their plots all of the plots are tended by a small number of farmers with electronic assistance.
krisgee··on The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your Own Backyard
> i.e planting crop x and y in rotation, or interrow with crops a and b.

I think this will be the real win of this technology eventually. Most if not all first world farmers understand that over the lifetime of their farm doing proper crop rotation increases yields but there is still a very reasonable instinctual reluctance to give up the short term profit of a high yield crop in order to plant a rotation crop of less profitable plants to keep the soil up correctly. Evening out that profit per field would probably be a great boon to operations that are too small to rotate entire fields.

It would also probably be an excellent way to get non farmers involved in the food production chain, especially in semi-rural areas. I grew up just in front of a community pasture which served as a grazing ground for three or four different farmer's herds and a couple of people who kept a couple of milk cows for local cheese making and stuff like that. Extending that concept to plants would be great, a giant community garden where people could plant crops that they are interested in and receive the yields at the end of the growing period. Larger farming outfits could plant around the regular people and ultimately keep costs down because of subsidy. Round out five or six gardens with some cash crops like wheat, soy or corn while locals use some of the field to grow their own grocery vegetables.

krisgee··on Astronomers Indirectly Spot Neutrinos Released 1 Second After the Big Bang
To make it clear we're on the surface of the sphere, not inside it. I misunderstood this analogy for a long time.
krisgee··on Google Is Developing Its Own Uber Competitor
>It's interesting to note that we're expected to lose our minds over the first human death with New Technology Y, when Old Technology X is typically killing humans all the time.

Exactly, call me when they're killing 1.2 million people a year[1].

The number of people killed by automobiles is completely fucking insane and the only reason we're cool with it is it mostly doesn't happen to someone a large number of people care about and if it does we can hum, haw and then lay blame on someone (who is probably dead).

1 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-re...

krisgee··on America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane
>Is the USA likely to go to war against anyone with sophisticated weaponry any time soon?

A military is like a parachute. It seems pretty useless until you need it.

krisgee··on On Pins and Needles: Stylist Turns Ancient Hairdo Debate on Its Head (2013)
Could you share any examples? I'm really interested in this.
krisgee··on Autumn
They're real time, that's the whole point of demos.
krisgee··on Sony SmartWatch 3
Another boring black square. I want someone to innovate on the Moto 360 already.
krisgee··on Moral Judgments Depend on What Language We’re Speaking
In the context of the thought problem it works 100% of the time.
krisgee··on When Patients Read What Their Doctors Write
As a complete outsides I don't see why anyone would be surprised, going to the doctor is quite often an expression of powerlessness, you have no idea and no control over what is going on in your own body and you need this powerful semi-stranger to do some divination on you and tell you what's wrong. Of course giving someone even a semblance of control over the proceedings helps them feel more engaged and more knowledgeable about themselves.
krisgee··on An amateur linguist loses control of the language he invented (2012)
To be fair there are lots of "snack food" articles around these days but few three course meals. I try to appreciate the long form articles that I find interesting for what they are.
krisgee··on Ten Thousand Years
Yes and as a person in a culture with technology comparable to ours it seems like, miners for instance would be pretty ticked off if they were falling into old pits of unmarked radioactive waste all the time.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →