HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

krger

262 karma · joined March 5, 2023

submissionscomments
krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
Exactly.
krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>Completely missing point of what I said and making a straw man out of it isn’t the gotcha moment you seem to think it is.

Okay, so what's the point of what you said? For reference, you said:

>Good, switch to it for a couple of years, use multiple vendors and then let everyone know how Android is a viable alternative to iOS.

What, then, is the point of what you said? You seem to believe that Android is not a viable alternative to iOS. What specific actions do you believe Apple should be required to take here?

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>I’m not so sure that “I can choose” to stay in the walled garden, if, for example, Spotify decides to only be available through another App Store that I don’t consider trustworthy.

Sure you can. You can decide which is more important to you: "Having an iPhone" or "Using Spotify on my mobile phone."

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>Good, switch to it for a couple of years, use multiple vendors and then let everyone know how Android is a viable alternative to iOS.

"I want Apple to be forced into making the same choices that its competitors made because those competitors' devices are, collectively, a miserable hellscape," isn't the winning argument you seem to think it is.

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>That still doesn't solve the issue that to get a blue bubble you must give up control over your mobile life to Apple.

...and if you "want the blue bubble" you must give up control over your messaging to Apple.

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>This is a false choice - there's no reason the iPhone can't be both a walled garden-type device and support alternative OSes/software, just like a computer.

Correct. There is no reason the iPhone cannot be both.

There is also no reason why Apple should be required to make it both simply because that's what a vanishingly small number of vocal malcontents wish for.

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>In the case of epic it was not about the privacy settings but about the percentage they had to pay for on every transaction which is a different issue.

The claim wasn't that nobody was sideloading for privacy settings. The claim was "Facebook doesn't use sideloading on the android platform, neither does any of the other big companies."

>I kind of agree that less privacy protection this is a concern, but I think that should be solved by additional privacy laws.

Oh, that's a great idea. We should definitely rely on laws alone for this. VC-backed technology firms are well-known for willingly abiding by the spirit of laws—especially privacy laws. They definitely aren't filled with people whose entire job is finding the slimist things they can get away with.

Or—and I'm just spitballing here—we could have both the additional privacy laws and also a competitive marketplace where at least one vendor decides to use privacy as a market differentiator while leaving people free to choose to buy from other vendors with other priorities.

You should have multiple options, but third parties should not be required to provide you with an option that gives you 100% of what you'd like to have.

"I get to choose" does not mean "I get to have a bespoke solution."

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>Facebook doesn't use sideloading on the android platform, neither does any of the other big companies.

1. Epic. 2. Unlike Google, Apple each year pours thousands of hours of developer effort into making it harder for Facebook to track users without their consent. The difference between "what is allowed in the store" and "what is possible on the device" is greater on iOS.

krger··on My 24 year old HP Jornada can do things an iPhone still can't do
>I want a phone that is as fast as a flagship phone like an iPhone, with a keyboard, daylong or better battery life running fullblown Debian. What shall I buy? It doesn’t exist.

Have you ever paused to consider why your mobile unicorn doesn't exist?

krger··on Blocked from Amazon Alexa for a week after racism accusation by delivery driver
>Amazon has no right to disable an account or services unilaterally like that with little recourse from the user.

Tell me you haven't read the TOS without telling me you haven't read the TOS.

Some Amazon employees certainly overreacted too quickly by disabling this guy's services, but Amazon certainly has the right to disable an account and discontinue service for any reason not expressly prohibited by law (and this isn't one of them).

krger··on Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
>You do realise you're describing 99% of the iOS app store here right?

I do. And I also realize how much worse it'd be if Apple didn't gate user data behind OS-level user consent dialogs.

krger··on Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
>Yes, yes, we know some Apple users are unable to see past the "you can't be trusted" that Apple keeps violently stabbing in your brain, you'll live in a company town with company stores and company credits and you'll be happy about it.

Apple isn't telling me that I can't be trusted. Apple is telling me that it's a stupid idea to trust third-party developers with unfettered access to my data, and they're not even a little bit wrong. This has been happening at least since the "Foursquare is uploading and storing every user's contacts" fiasco well over a decade ago.

> Now can the adults use their devices?

Of course. Feel free to bring to market your wonderful headset that allows VC-funded startups to create a never-ending torrent of privacy hellscape diarrhea apps you can enjoy until they implode.

>The Vision Pro does not provide foveated rendering if you do not go through the Apple renderer. There's some extremely vague wording regarding Metal supporting it, without any API documentation out.

That's because the API has yet to be released to developers. Perhaps you can wait until it is to get your mouth all frothy, sunshine.

krger··on Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
>Of course it isn't, they want you to buy a MacBook alongside, that's my entire point.

Hardware company entices consumers to buy more hardware. Film at 11.

>If it were a Surface-like product instead, with full macOS, I'd have bought an iPad in a heartbeat.

Ah yes. The Surface, the device that showcases the appeal of running an OS designed for mouse/keyboard input with a thin veneer of touch support spackled on top. It's amazing Apple isn't sprinting to release a product along those lines.

krger··on Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
>Apps will not have direct access to the cameras

A restriction for which I am thankful.

>Vision Pro is destined to keep being a toy fully steered by Apple.

I trust Apple a lot more than I trust the "let's figure out how to fingerprint users based on how they scroll and other metrics and use it to sell ads" crowd.

>You can't access eye tracking,

A restriction for which I am thankful.

>so say good bye to foveated rendering.

Vision Pro does foveated rendering.

krger··on Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
>That's great for those people but yes, for devs, it's not a real replacement for a MacBook, even though it literally has the same chip inside.

Good thing Apple isn't marketing it as a replacement for a MacBook then.

krger··on SimulaVR's Reaction to Apple
One main difference is that you could order a computer with an M2 Ultra last week, but you won't be able to order Reality Pro until next year. Apple doesn't talk about numbers until they finalize exactly what will be shipping.
krger··on SimulaVR's Reaction to Apple
I watched the event. Timecode for this specific claim, please.
krger··on SimulaVR's Reaction to Apple
>that was how apple justified the cost of the device, so I think its a fair critique.

[Citation needed]

krger··on Why sqlite3 temp files were renamed 'etilqs_*' (2006)
>Every decent OS in 2023 should provide a method for this.

Yes, that's rather the problem—there isn't just one way to do that, which makes it a portability issue.

krger··on Debian GNU/Hurd 2023
>The rest of your points make sense but I don't understand fully how this is an argument for monoliths? Isn't recovery from an unknown state an equally hard problem in both cases?

He's not saying that monolithic kernels make recovery easier in this case. He's saying that microkernels don't make these failures easier to recover from in practice, so you may as well take the performance gains that you will get from the monolithic kernel instead of giving up those gains for theoretical recoverability advantages that you won't actually usually see in practice.

krger··on Mark Zuckerberg on Apple’s Vision Pro headset
>It was said that they would replace laptops.

By who?

The iPad introduction explicitly presented the iPad as a complementary device situated between the smartphone and the laptop.

krger··on Lawyer who used ChatGPT faces penalty for made up citations
The Court of Public Opinion can't suspend or take away your law license.
krger··on An LSFMM development-process discussion
Gatekeepers clinging jealously to their gates.
krger··on Apple Introduces M2 Ultra
I, too, would like to pay Ford prices for a Rivian.
krger··on Apple Introduces M2 Ultra
>Even though macOS is more polished than your average Linux desktop environment, it's really very hard to ignore the unjustified markup.

It's justified if people pay it.

>Nowadays I can buy a miniPC with a Ryzen5 and 32GB of RAM for around 400€, but the cheapest Mac mini nowadays sells for over 700€ and comes with 8GB of RAM and an absurd 256GB SSD.

So what's the problem?

If you like running Linux on your Ryzen5 miniPC with 32GB of RAM for 400€, you're more than free to do that. Apple's not stopping you.

krger··on OpenAI Employee: GPT-4 has been static since March
>It is the second most intelligent thing on the planet at creating text, even with its flaws.

This also puts it in last place.

krger··on A police officer's first 45 words are a portent of what's to come
>It happens to white people too and it's bizarre to think that it would not?

I do not doubt that it also happens to white people. The point is that it happens to white people at a disproportionately lower rate than it does to non-white people.

krger··on A police officer's first 45 words are a portent of what's to come
>If a cop walks up to a car with the engines still running, they're right to be wary.

Over the past 25 years, I've been pulled over maybe a dozen times or so for various things (speeding, headlight out), etc.

Not once have I turned off the engine. Not once have I been instructed—or even asked—to turn off the engine.

I'm white, but you probably guessed that already.

krger··on Meta announces its Quest 3 VR headset
>I think Mark knew he had to get away from Apple as they are a horrific partner

Facebook is the company that almost single-handedly gutted the media industry over the past ten years with such smash hits as "just post all of your news stories directly on Facebook" and "pivot to video based on these absolutely fabricated numbers!" so I suppose he does indeed have some insight on what makes a horrific partner.

krger··on .zip is now available as a TLD
>if you don't use it for X amount of time, then it's lost

Okay, now come up with a definition of "use" that effectively eliminates squatting-for-profit that doesn't also eliminate legitimate uses for having multiple domains that don't look like they're "being used"

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →