587 karma · joined February 23, 2007
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jm3; my proof: https://keybase.io/jm3/sigs/nrbwUxRe4ie110jlT18E46Z44QmQ1MjdMap0eX0FHHY ]
jm3% dig news.ycombinator.com | grep IN news.ycombinator.com. 424 IN A 174.132.225.106
jm3% dig hackerne.ws | grep IN hackerne.ws. 932 IN A 174.132.225.106
Then I thought, look what's telling me that.
(emo philips)
In 1999, when i started making sites, the sort of nav was considered "boring" because everyone was using it, and our designers often created weird (poorly performing) nav just to buck the trend.
The only way that would make sense is if beta testers don't have Twitter accounts, since OAuthing with an existing account reduces friction. Twitter's been around for four years and seems fairly well established among early adopters like HN readers, so counting on a critical mass of beta testers to have Twitter accounts hardly seems a stretch, even if those users aren't very active tweeters.
i for one was very glad not to need to enter an email address, pick a login name, etc; the oauth process handled that for me. ymmv
i believe you're genuinely trying to be helpful with your suggestions, but comments like this reminds me of the vocal 0.1% of users who exercise troublesome preferences like disabling javascript, or installing ad-blocking plugins that break half the web, (which is fine!), but then complain that their (pathological) preferences prohibit them from enjoying the experience (which is not so helpful).
feedback like, "i can't be bothered to log in to give you feedback because i don't like your login" isn't great feedback. it might even be viewed as a sign to you that you're not the intended user. yet.
1. i could get the notice as a tweet (DM) instead of an email. since you're using oauth, i'm betting you're facile w/the twitter api.
2. you offered a fuller range of hours for the reminder. the first task i added to streak.ly was, "cook breakfast", but 10am was the earliest reminder i could pick in the list, which is too late for me ;)
"But is this really MY problem?" In presenting design ie. communicating its value, the roles/responsibilities are not unlike that of a teacher and students: successful delivery of information is the responsibility of the sender. To say eg. "I taught it to them but they didn't learn it" is a contradiction in terms tantamount to "i sold it to him but he didn't buy it." You as the designer are responsible for 1. understanding the problem landscape well enough to deliver a working solution 2. building a decent relationship with the client (internal or external) that you have a good communication channel.
What are the best ways to sell design to non-designers? Clear objectives you've agreed upon and stuck to. Compelling storytelling. Competitive benchmarks. Pure visual WOW factor. $10 usability tests. Man-on-the-street impressions. Rote logic. Brute force. These are the techniques that I've used successfully. They can of course be combined, and there must be many others. ymmv
If "selling" design is problematic and you're not able to push work through to some kind of test environment where real customers can connect with it to PROVE the design works (via sales / leads / engagement, whatever the objective may be), then you might consider joining forces with a fellow writer or designer, or agency, to watch how designers and creative directors successfully bring clients on-board to sell innovative designs.
CAVEAT: There are always critics and naysayers of any sufficiently innovative solution or design. To those people, I say http://purplejesus.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/haters.gif Let them do better, and prove it.