HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jerheinze

2,631 karma · joined March 20, 2017

submissionscomments
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
What's going to be lost?
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> By passing this on to Mozilla and discontinuing Tor Browser, you're going to inherit the innumerable issues in their code base.

What issues exactly? Tor Browser = Firefox ESR + some patches + some other stuff and tweaks. Before the release of the next ESR TB devs rebase and submit these patches to mainline Firefox, that's why you have prefs like privacy.resistFingerprinting and privacy.firstparty.isolate in mainline Firefox, see: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Tor_Uplift

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> Are you referring to third-party login services and comment systems (such as disqus and similar)?

See the full list of bugs of breakage when privacy.firstparty.isolate is enabled: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/FirstPartyIsolation#First_...

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
So the solution is to grow Tor usage, or use bridges with pluggable transports.
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> Most forums ban all Tor exits.

So running an exit at home to coverup for posting on a forum that bans all Tor exits, that makes no sense.

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> I more meant that Google offers a captcha service for others that is quite good, them implemented a really terrible one for the internal services.

They're identical now, I rarely got the awful one that you're talking about when searching on Google.

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> The main reason I've never used Tor is the fear that it would make me look like I had something to hide (instead of just a general desire for privacy).

1. You can hide the fact that you're using Tor by using pluggable transports which are already built-in the Tor Browser (such as meek-azure, obfs4, snowflake, ...).

2. That's the biggest reason as to why one must use Tor as much as possible even if they don't care about privacy. More people using Tor = the less interesting it is to be a Tor user.

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> You also get encryption while your traffic looks just the same as everybody else’s. You don’t stand out like when you’re using Tor.

Detecting WhatsApp usage is trivial. With Tor you can use pluggable transports to obfuscate your traffic.

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> They can't just take control of the traffic in the middle, which absolutely can be done in Tor with enough gov controlled guard nodes, as the arms race of patching has proven.

I think you're misunderstanding something here, with onion services traffic is e2e encrypted and self-authenticated, as Matt explains:

> When you connect to an onion service, how do you know no one is MitM'ing you? Easy. It's impossible. The bad guy would have to be in your browser (more accurately: between the browser part of Tor Browser and the Tor process it runs in the background) or between the Tor process the onion service operator is running and the webserver it's pointing at. If you assume your Tor Browser hasn't been compromised, and you assume the onion service is being run intelligently, then a MitM attack is impossible. (And if the onion service isn't being run intelligently, can you really trust its operator to do HTTPS intelligently?) > > https://matt.traudt.xyz/posts/dont-https-your-o44SnkW2.html

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/GoodBadISP...

(Also check the new relay guide: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/TorRelayGuide)

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
That has no relation to the cases above which were of people running Tor exit nodes from their home. If one wants to hide their Tor usage then that's something else and there are pluggable transports that are already built-in the Tor Browser to obfuscate Tor traffic to look like something else--no need for a VPN.
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
Why take that trouble when they can do it directly using Tor without running any exit at home? Also for instance Bogatov had an alibi when that happened.
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> I know many of my own frustrations came from the fork that is Tor.

What are your frustrations with the Tor Browser?

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
Google has always been showing captchas when using their search engine for quiet a long time (even for VPN users). In fact they were even straight blocking users from using that very same captcha: https://bugs.torproject.org/23840
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
> Without HTTPS, you are relying entirely on the transport for assurance of who you are talking to.

That's not the case, even with a SecureDrop setup, a Gov can compromise your SecureDrop machine and listen directly.

jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
It's a fork based on Firefox ESR, see for the details: https://www.torproject.org/projects/torbrowser/design/
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
All of them from people running their exit from home, which has always been warned against.
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
Google isn't a GPA. Also having a low-latency anonymity system that isn't affected by a GPA is an open problem. The important thing here is that using Tor is better than not.
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
Well HTTP/2 is disabled in the Tor Browser (for now), and it has a positive impact on speed, so they do matter: https://bugs.torproject.org/14952
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
https://matt.traudt.xyz/posts/dont-https-your-o44SnkW2.html
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
Brave is already working on Tor private tabs though it won't have the same fingerprinting/first-party isolation guarantees as with a Tor Browser, https://github.com/brave/browser-laptop/labels/feature/tor Should be shipping soon https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/984231250104733696
jerheinze··on Mozilla Project Fusion: Tor Integration into Firefox
https://www.torproject.org/docs/faq.html.en#CanExitNodesEave...

Yes, the guy running the exit node can read the bytes that come in and out there. Tor anonymizes the origin of your traffic, and it makes sure to encrypt everything inside the Tor network, but it does not magically encrypt all traffic throughout the Internet.

This is why you should always use end-to-end encryption such as SSL for sensitive Internet connections.

```

Fortunately HTTPS adoption is much better now :)

jerheinze··on FIrefox USIng ONions
Wouldn't more Tor 3rd party integration (soon Brave, Mozilla in the future, ...) lead to greater incentive for website operators to allow Tor? (FWIW Cloudflare captchas are mostly a thing of the past now as they've been allowing Tor users as long as they come from the Tor Browser)
jerheinze··on FIrefox USIng ONions
For some more details: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/meetings/2...
jerheinze··on Google shuttering domain fronting, Signal moving to souqcdn.com
> Is this related to Russia blocking a ton of google IPs to enforce the telegram block, or is that a separate thing entirely?

Completely separate.

jerheinze··on Google shuttering domain fronting, Signal moving to souqcdn.com
> This will possibly affect the Tor project's Meek pluggable transport as well which is used for many bridges.

Not the case since meek-google was discontinued long ago, meek-amazon and meek-azure don't rely on Google as a front. It does affect however Moat and Snowflake, all of them are still only available in the alpha releases.

jerheinze··on EU to force tech firms to hand over terror suspects' messages
Here we go again.
jerheinze··on Sunsetting Tor Messenger
Github link is easy to remember without sending an email or twitter DM: https://github.com/TheTorProject/GetTorBrowser
jerheinze··on Sunsetting Tor Messenger
Which OS are you using? FWIW Tor Browser doesn't require root and it's portable.
jerheinze··on Sunsetting Tor Messenger
> I wish the page had screenshots.

The Github page has one: https://github.com/ricochet-im/ricochet/

> As far as I can see currently the only widely used, secure protocols are Matrix and XMPP with OMEMO.

secure != metadata free

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →