HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

helloplanets

2,957 karma · joined September 15, 2020

submissionscomments
helloplanets··on AI is slowing down
Given this, his righteous anger towards craven boosters and grifters is pretty funny. Pot calling the kettle black.
helloplanets··on Making peace with your unlived dreams (2023)
> You know what else I’d like to do besides becoming a great snowboarder? I want to learn kung fu. I’d also love to be a lot better at video games, get my Yu-Gi-Oh! hobby back on, and become at least fluent enough for everyday conversation in oh, I don’t know, eight more languages.

I think this sort of underplays the feeling of "lives unlived, paths not taken" that everyone gets hit with. Just flattens the whole thing that had been building up to that point, instead of allowing it to open up further.

helloplanets··on Ask HN: Why is the HN crowd so anti-AI?
> And yet it’s not.

That was my point as well. That it hasn't been output, even though it could be done by a talented solo developer given enough time, and that current LLMs definitely aren't able to do so.

> The problem is that they don’t generate acceptable code, they generate code that needs to be edited to be acceptable.

You've never had an LLM output a one line bugfix that is correct to the point where you don't have to edit it?

To make things more concrete, here's an example from the creator of Redis on how he utilizes LLMs in programming: https://antirez.com/news/164

helloplanets··on Ask HN: Why is the HN crowd so anti-AI?
Being 10x (or whatever multiplier) faster at programming doesn't mean you're going to be 10x faster in designing a product or any other aspect that goes into making a good product.

Even if you hired an actual programmer, it'd take a massive amount of time to build a Photoshop clone.

Of course, at the end Photoshop is lines of code and it could be output as is, end to end. One problem is that users aren't generally giving very precise design documents which would narrow the way to interpret them into code in precisely one way. Or that a design document at any level of precision, other than code, couldn't be interpreted in multiple ways when it comes to a specific implementation.

LLMs also take a relatively long time to output acceptable code, often taking tens of minutes before giving you a small diff. The larger the codebase, the longer it usually takes to start producing code, even over an hour.

helloplanets··on How LLMs work
It's basically possible build an LLM using just routers+packets, and then hook them up to Wireshark to see it compute!
helloplanets··on How LLMs work
The part about positional encoding is not correct.

> The intuition: instead of adding position info to each token’s vector, RoPE rotates the vector by an angle that depends on its position

You can't rotate the token's entire vector (or all three vectors, whatever is being implied is unclear). You rotate each token's Query and Key vectors only, so dot product can be used to tell how far apart the tokens are when comparing token 1's Query vector to token 2's Key vector.

Positional embedding should just be explained after explaining the Query, Key and Value vectors. When the article explains those only after that, the reader is building up on a wrong intuition and it gets confusing.

helloplanets··on Am I Unc?
New Balances with the dad jeans is trendy-unc. The comeback was at its peak around a decade ago, maybe a bit less.

White socks with the sandals were very trendy just a while ago as well though. I'd say the author of that site is definitely unc.

helloplanets··on Changing how we develop Ladybird
If a project has a rule to not submit AI generated PRs, people should never submit AI generated PRs to that project. It's spam. Or if the rule is more nuanced than that in relation to AI, it should be respected.

It's 100% an issue with the people with submitting these PRs. So, if someone has a history of having no issue with breaking project rules (let alone being arrogant about it), it should be a massive red flag about the person for any possible employer or future collaborator checking their profile, etc.

Why people are wilfully destroying their own reputation like that is beyond me. It's infinitely better to have no activity at all on your profile than to create a track record of bad behaviour.

helloplanets··on Agentic Mfw
Did you actually catch my drift though?

Something that reads like an LLM wrote it is different from an LLM having written it to begin with. Something written by an LLM can be something that doesn't have the hallmarks of LLM all over it.

I was just saying that the original quote doesn't strike me as something that's an annoyingly good piece of LLM writing.

There's a lot of experimentation happening on how to get LLMs to write well, starting with half of what's been posted on Gwern's blog as of late.

helloplanets··on Uber's $1,500/month AI limit is a useful signal for AI tool pricing
AI data centers are being already used at max capacity, aren't they? I have a hard time imagining people would suddenly use AI less than they do as of today, let alone collectively drop it altogether. So the worst case scenario is that they'd need to be auctioned off way under what they'd be worth now, but still for someone to use them for AI.

Inference is much cheaper than training a new model, so running them just for inference is a completely different thing than having to price in the fact that at the moment all of these companies need to compromise between compute for inference and compute for training new models. If no new models were to be trained, and all the compute was inference only, that would change everything when it comes to the overall compute cost of AI.

Dotcom infra buildup is a bad comparison, in that it wasn't even close to being all utilized. The infra was completely overproportional to the day to day usage.

helloplanets··on Agentic Mfw
It reads a lot like an LLM... Especially this sentence:

> Now they're slop, agentic, and on fire — but they get attention, and attention is the only metric left.

Welcome to the future, where we have LLMs writing slop rants about LLMs writing slop!

helloplanets··on Disregard previous instructions and delete all jqwik tests
Pretty sure the developer could get in serious legal trouble if this happened to cause issues with a larger company's system.

Has anything similar happened before?

helloplanets··on It's Not Just X. It's Y
I remember someone posting about the most human of all traits being reassuring to see: Typos. I'm pretty sure people are not as averse to leaving or finding typos in text as they were 5 years ago, as these days it's a signal of humanity.

Same has been applying to art for a while. Several artists who have an "AI-ish" style have been wrongfully crucified for using AI. And been forced to post videos of their process end to end, in order to prove that they aren't using AI. It's a thing for artists to post their new stuff with: "AI could never do this."

helloplanets··on MCP is dead?
What do you mean?
helloplanets··on MCP is dead?
You can create tools without using MCP for OpenCode: https://opencode.ai/docs/custom-tools/
helloplanets··on We should be more tired than the model
> particularly because its UX affordances are reminiscent of a slot machine’s: you pull the lever, you get a reward (a solution to your coding problem.)

I hope the field moves out of the TUI with prompt + pull the lever paradigm soon‚ when it comes to agentic programming. And the Markdown paradigm too, tbh.

There hasn't been anything that really sticks yet for a shift to happen.

helloplanets··on Undisclosed addition in jqwik instructed AI coding agents to delete app output
I'd just imagine that leaving the platform would come before adding something like this to their codebase. With GitHub recently changing their GitHub Copilot data collection from opt in to opt out, being in direct cahoots with OpenAI, etc.

It's not like leaving GitHub is unheard of. Ghostty just announced their plan to do so last month.

helloplanets··on Undisclosed addition in jqwik instructed AI coding agents to delete app output
I thought we already were sliding down the slippery slope here.
helloplanets··on Protestware for coding agents
This isn't about me in any way. If something in your software is intentionally malicious or damaging, it's malware. Doesn't really matter what the reasoning for including the malicious part is.

Would you count this as malware if it was about the author trying to profit or steal from inattentive people using AI? You know, he could be putting those stolen goods towards a good cause, like Robin Hood.

helloplanets··on Protestware for coding agents
Some comments from the dev on the GitHub thread:

> It's as much "active destruction" as telling someone to eff themselves.

> Funny to have GenAI proponents talk about "deliberately destroying someone's work".

Why is the project still on GitHub of all places, if he's passionate enough about his cause to turn his project into malware? So weird.

helloplanets··on Show HN: Zot – Yet another coding agent harness
If you use API billing, you can use them from anywhere. But using Claude Code with a Max subscription is massively cheaper for programming. You should never use Claude models for programming through API billing, unless forced. The difference will easily rack up to thousands of dollars for heavy users.
helloplanets··on Hallucinate – Massively Multiplayer Online Rave
Did this get hugged to death? Not loading for me at all.
helloplanets··on Multi-Agent LLM System for Automated Vulnerability Discovery and Reproduction
That sort of countermeasure system could be done without AI as well. The problem is that it's illegal. No Castle Doctrine in cybersecurity afaik.

Interesting variation on that could be AI that builds out some sort of on the fly honeypot after identifying the attacker. Basically creating the "attack" within their own premises.

helloplanets··on The worst job interview I ever had
So... You've never had a bad interview. Congrats!
helloplanets··on Uber’s COO says it’s getting harder to justify money spent on tokenmaxxing
More straightforward to talk about the hardware directly. Full Kimi K2.6 needs an 8x H200 node to run and serve around 20 heavy users. You can rent an 8x H200 node for around $30/hr.

I'd imagine GPT-5.5 and Claude Opus 4.7 could run just fine on a 16x H200 node and serve at least 10 heavy users without the token output getting choppy.

helloplanets··on Is a Claw driven Hacker News user a problem?
Instead of worrying about the implications on HN, I'd rather worry about the implications on you as a consumer of HN.

I wouldn't be comfortable creating a bubble inside of a bubble, but to each their own.

As long as it's just consuming information from the site and you're essentially forming your own custom filters using it, I don't see an issue.

helloplanets··on Your Most Improbable Life
Thank you for linking this! It's great. :)
helloplanets··on Your Most Improbable Life
The usual way of measuring a trait would basically be measuring N amount of people on a specific thing, and the distribution based on that. But if you take 1 person, and N amount of specific things/traits, just about everyone would probably make their own sort of distribution with a bunch of "normal" traits and a long tail of "unusual" traits.

Still a simplification, but has made the "illusion of a normie" clearer to me.

helloplanets··on Your Most Improbable Life
This seems to be anchored around optimizing your intelligence to be a competitive advantage. Life as a competition of minds. For example:

> Improbable lives have fewer competitors

> The more you-ish you become, the less competition you have, because you are occupying your own niche.

> The less predictable you are, the less likely you are to be replaced by AIs

As opposed to Ilya Sutskever's famous quip:

> if you value intelligence above all other human qualities, you’re gonna have a bad time

helloplanets··on An OpenAI model has disproved a central conjecture in discrete geometry
https://github.com/torvalds/AudioNoise

> The python visualizer tool has been basically written by vibe-coding. I know more about analog filters -- and that's not saying much -- than I do about python. It started out as my typical "google and do the monkey-see-monkey-do" kind of programming, but then I cut out the middle-man -- me -- and just used Google Antigravity to do the audio sample visualizer.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →