HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gydfi

60 karma · joined February 13, 2017

submissionscomments
gydfi··on ‘The American dream is not working out here’
If childcare costs that much why not just hire a full-time nanny?
gydfi··on ‘The American dream is not working out here’
Journalists love writing this same article over and over again. Find some humble bragging buffoon willing to get quoted as talking about how hard it is to get by on some large amount of money, then farm the sputtering outrage of the readership for clicks.

I've never seen it done with a seven-figure income though.

gydfi··on ‘What Do You Think Is the Most Important Problem Facing This Country Today?’
It strikes me that the people who crow about "facts" the loudest are the ones most likely to be conflating facts with their own opinions.

I'm a scientist. I don't believe in facts. I believe in models, explanations, measurements with appropriate error bars, provisional theories and educated guesses, but never facts. When somebody comes to me claiming that they know "the facts" I put up my defences.

Perhaps what people really need is not a better appreciation of facts but a more realistic appreciation of uncertainties. Perhaps if we could all stop arguing about whether the probability of disastrous climate change is 0 or 1, and instead accept that it's somewhere between 0.01 and 0.99, then we could make some progress on the issue.

gydfi··on DHS Quietly Testing Mandatory Facial Recognition of Passengers Exiting U.S
I guess this is some kind of trial. My point is that exit records are neither novel, useless, nor in most countries the least bit controversial.

Not sure why the US needs to make a big deal out of it with biometric scans instead of the tried-and-true option of a little man in a box stamping your passport.

gydfi··on Even good bots fight: The case of Wikipedia
"I feel the same about the wait but pretty good about my own time estimation abilities!"
gydfi··on SpaceX to Send Privately Crewed Dragon Spacecraft Beyond the Moon Next Year
Great, so with good timing we can both get a great view and set a record simultaneously.
gydfi··on SpaceX to Send Privately Crewed Dragon Spacecraft Beyond the Moon Next Year
But practically speaking there's also not much the US can do in that scenario if Russia or China ignores US sovereignty over Mars and sets up their own base. The US's only recourse would be to start a war, and would that be worth it? Sovereignty is more of a practical concept than a legal one: you own what you are both able and willing to defend.

See also the Russian bases in the Australian Antarctic territory. Australia asserts sovereignty over a third of Antarctica, Russia ignores it and sets up bases anyway. Australia has neither the ability nor the desire to fight Russia, so we studiously ignore it.

gydfi··on Data on the uselessness of LinkedIn endorsements
I fucking rule at HyperCard.
gydfi··on SpaceX to Send Privately Crewed Dragon Spacecraft Beyond the Moon Next Year
Just looking up records: the furthest anyone has ever been from Earth is Apollo 13 who passed 158 miles above the lunar surface.

I imagine that would be a pretty easy record to break, if you're doing a translunar flight anyway then getting a bit higher doesn't take much more energy (source: played a lot of Kerbal).

On the other hand the passengers might prefer a close-up view of the Moon to a record.

gydfi··on SpaceX to Send Privately Crewed Dragon Spacecraft Beyond the Moon Next Year
Hey, you're right. First flight of the Saturn V was November 1967. First trip around the moon was December 1968.
gydfi··on DHS Quietly Testing Mandatory Facial Recognition of Passengers Exiting U.S
But, so-called “exit controls,” where documents are checked as travelers are leaving the country, were popularized last century by Nazi Germany as a great way to ensure that they could control, round up, and exterminate the Jews and other “undesirables.” It can obviously serve no purpose of keeping terrorists out, because it only affects those who are already in.

Or to put it another way, they're standard in practically every country apart from the US. Because what's the point of issuing someone with a fixed-term visa if you have no record of whether they left at the end of it?

gydfi··on Will Democracy Survive Big Data and Artificial Intelligence?
A lot of people seem to conflate "a threat to democracy" and "people I dislike getting elected".

I'd say those people are the real threat to democracy.

gydfi··on Will Democracy Survive Big Data and Artificial Intelligence?
And was the other survey a comprehensive survey of everybody?

The divergence in poll results seems to suggest we should put even less credence on polls here than usual.

gydfi··on Why is there ancient Greek text on Afghan banknotes?
Ancient Greek Buddhists?
gydfi··on Why Ever Stop Playing Video Games
I think the difference is just in status: being an excellent chess player gets you respect from a more respectable-looking crowd than being excellent at Street Fighter. Neither gets you quite as much widespread adulation as being good at golf or Formula 1 car driving, while both get you more than being good at Candy Crush. But ultimately they're all just games.
gydfi··on An Open Letter to the Uber Board and Investors
That is the way I think... not that the story is necessarily bullshit (though like most conflict stories of which we've only heard one side it may have other factors) but that it's a fairly normal story from a rightfully disgruntled employee (there's always rightfully disgruntled employees) which has been elevated to the level of some unique crime against humanity.
gydfi··on An Open Letter to the Uber Board and Investors
Why?

In what sense is it off-topic?

gydfi··on Math Professor Fighting Gerrymandering with Geometry
>Distortions of the kind labelled gerrymandering are fundamental to the exclusive use of independent single member districts (and exacerbated if you use plurality or majority-runoff elections in those districts.)

Not so much. In Australia we have single member districts but not really gerrymandering because our districts are set by an independent non-political body using an algorithm and some common sense. Look at an electoral map of Australia and you'll see that our electorates are reasonably sensible shapes, they haven't been set up to favour one party over another.

gydfi··on Math Professor Fighting Gerrymandering with Geometry
To put it in terms people here understand: suppose you have a big legacy code base written in C. It works fine but it's not perfect. And every time a bug comes up, there's a bunch of guys who say "hey, let's just rewrite the whole thing in Scala!"

No, we're not rewriting the whole code base on a production system just because you think Scala is neat. The existing code is fundamentally fine, let's focus on this problem today.

gydfi··on What Happens to Your Body on a Thru-Hike
I'm embarrassed to admit how many times I've eaten that while not on a hike.

"Sure, I could boil some water. Or I could just sprinkle seasoning on the top and eat it now..."

gydfi··on Inside Uber’s Aggressive, Unrestrained Workplace Culture
Which is a fair complaint. But lots of people seem to be overreacting. I imagine any number of large employers would have much worse stories than that out there somewhere.
gydfi··on Seven earth-sized planets discovered circling a star 39 light years from Earth
That actually sounds pretty achievable. Difficult, but all within the boundaries of known physics and existing human lifetimes.
gydfi··on Seven earth-sized planets discovered circling a star 39 light years from Earth
Maybe but I like to think there are creatures living in the temperate rim of a tidally locked planet somewhere debating whether life could possibly evolve on a rotating planet.

"I mean, there'd be temperature fluctuations of tens of degrees every day! It would be dark half the time! How could life survive in such an unstable environment?"

gydfi··on Seven earth-sized planets discovered circling a star 39 light years from Earth
Would they? I mean, we can see geological features on our moon, and our tides are orders of magnitude away from being rock-tearing events. I mean, the moon is small, but... how close do these planets approach, anyway?
gydfi··on Just 4 miles from Center City, a heroin hellscape hidden in plain sight
It seems to me that most of the problems with prisons can be solved by eliminating contact between prisoners.

A cell, a treadmill, some books and movies, and Skype privileged with your family on the outside. That's all you need. It's constraining enough to still be a punishment that you want to avoid, but it doesn't send you crazy like traditional solitary (which is more like sensory deprivation). You don't make contacts with other criminals, you don't risk getting shanked, and you sit out your sentence in an annoying yet humane state of boredom, like a waiting room.

gydfi··on Just 4 miles from Center City, a heroin hellscape hidden in plain sight
Exactly. Which is why you need to stop it somewhere before they get addicted.

I've always wondered what goes through the head of someone when they think "Hey! I think I'll try heroin for the first time! That seems like a good decision!"

gydfi··on Just 4 miles from Center City, a heroin hellscape hidden in plain sight
Argument from authority? Is that the best you can do? Those "professionals" don't have a great track record, which is why drugs are still a huge problem.

So I repeat my question: how are things working out in the Philippines? Are the harsh policies being pursued doing a good job of decreasing the drug problem? If they are, perhaps we can think about adopting aspects of those solutions while leaving out some of the more problematic aspects such as extrajudicial executions.

gydfi··on Just 4 miles from Center City, a heroin hellscape hidden in plain sight
I'm just asking whether the Philippines' policies are sufficient to deter people from taking drugs. You're the one who is inferring anything on top of that.

It seems to me, however, that the overwhelming priority of our heroin policy should be ensuring that people who aren't already taking heroin don't start. Those who have already got hooked are pretty much doomed already, they should be a lower priority than those who can easily be saved. It seems to me that many people advocate a "softly softly" approach to drug users that fucks over the first group to help the second, and thus ensures that our drug problems continue instead of being wiped out.

gydfi··on Just 4 miles from Center City, a heroin hellscape hidden in plain sight
What about Manila? Do people take drugs openly in Manila?
gydfi··on [dead]
No, I think that this coordinated attack has been going on for at least a month (remember #deleteuber?) and that this is just the latest salvo in it.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →