HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

guard-of-terra

5,098 karma · joined April 15, 2011

submissionscomments
guard-of-terra··on NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments
Unfortunately, not much interesting happens outside of politics. CRISPR and exoplanets spring to mind as exceptions, but software field definitely stalled.

Politics seems to be the force that can bury any amount of advancements in other fields, hence interest.

guard-of-terra··on NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments
Doesn't make the issues not relevant. Do you argue that we're incapable of dealing with these issues for all eternity?

"Who voted this up?" is the community rift.

guard-of-terra··on NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments
Comments to most articles about Snowden, refugees or gender issues are like that.
guard-of-terra··on NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments
Disqus more or less figured out comment moderation around me. I'm yet to see a Disqus-powered comment system overran by undesirable content.

HN is failing at comments. During last years, the community deteriorated to the point where for many articles every single comment is grayed-out downvoted. That signifies quite a rift in community. HN used to be upvote-intensive excitement-driven but today it's downvote-intensive, annoyment driven.

guard-of-terra··on Jacob Appelbaum: What Has This Man Done?
> In Germany one should never (esp. after our latest reforms on sexual laws) have sex without written and videotaped consent of the other party

I wonder if they have that in uploaded form: cute German girls consenting to have sex. Would be an entertaining watch if you ask me.

guard-of-terra··on Jacob Appelbaum: What Has This Man Done?
Makes me proud for the Russian activist. She's not only acting as responsible person, but also has guts to go vocal against groupthink campaign.
guard-of-terra··on Jacob Appelbaum: What Has This Man Done?
Is there a criminal prosecution going?

If there is not, why are we calling person a criminal?

guard-of-terra··on This Is Your Life in Silicon Valley
Sounds like a character straight from http://wumo.com/wumo webcomics

Which I could not recommend enough, I'm having wumo flashbacks all the time just as with obligatory XKCD.

guard-of-terra··on For a Better Economy, Add Commuter Rail?
It's 100,000 people[1], how come they don't have a station for a rail that literally passes through? Of course they need to fix it right away.

[1] By European standards that could as well be a railway hub.

guard-of-terra··on Rock climber Alex Honnold doesn’t experience fear like the rest of us
Frankly I don't understand why people turn risk of falling into risk of death.

Why can't they make some device for him, say, a thick-ish belt, which will make him hang inside of a sphere full of compressed gas, after a second of free fall? Not unlike how car SRS work?

Why don't ships have inflatable balloons strapped to their hulls that would allow them to float indefinitely? We still have sinking ferries with hundreds dead that could perhaps been fully prevented?

guard-of-terra··on By 2030, 56 countries will have more people aged 65+ than children under 15
It's not solving any problem[1], and Canada is an extreme example as a country and can't be used as a model for (mostly) monocultural countries.

1: First people argue there's no problem with low birth rate, and then people tell that they're solving the problem. Pick one.

guard-of-terra··on By 2030, 56 countries will have more people aged 65+ than children under 15
"feel they are not entitled to their beliefs"

When there's polarization in a society where a majority of population out-vote a minority on every proposal, said minority has all motivation to withdraw from public politics and secede.

Imagine a country with 60% big-endians and 40% little-endians. Big-endians own every president, every senate and every vote they care to win. Little-endians have no sensible choice but to split into their own country where they'll be a majority, perhaps with civil war and ethnic cleansings in the process.

guard-of-terra··on By 2030, 56 countries will have more people aged 65+ than children under 15
It would be a good thing if not for a policy of covering losses by importing large number of people from struggling societies that many affected countries have adopted.

Which BTW makes no sense when you look closer at demographics, since most depopulating areas are rural, but immigrants usually live compactly in countries' largest cities (where also existing youth flocks to), increasing population imbalance in fact.

Yes they get total head count stable but at cost of getting everything else wrong.

guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
There's a lot of islamic regions which were never a part of Caliphate.

Their interpretation of what being Muslim means in practice might differ significantly.

guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
Having training camps and wrapping women in opaque blankets is two distinct things. Bosnians mostly did former and not latter.

> was able not to wear a headscarf in the presence of the rulers

There's a lot of things even I won't do "in the presence of the rules", but luckily I don't see much of them, so I'm free to do whatever I please. Wasn't same true for them?

guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
I have this idea that Abrahamic religions were the single worst thing that ever happened to humankind.

However, most of those countries are long islamic. They figured ways to have both islam and freedom of expression. Only in the later years did they become violently fundamentalistic to displayed extent.

Some didn't yet. Tatars are muslim for quite a few centuries but they don't dress their women like that.

guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
As far as I know, Bosnia was pretty secular and laid back for a long time (and is now).

What's "tradition" here? How widely were it practiced? Because I totally see this practice of digging in the past for some more obscurantist behaviors, and calling it "tradition" as if it is a good thing.

guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
In my eyes there's not many sins greater than inconsistency:

Enjoying something while trying to prevent others from enjoying it. Which he did. Searching for reasons to back it up makes it worse.

On related note, I've heard there's sentiment coming from smartphone-clutching young parents where they say they'll somehow restrict their children from visiting internet. WTF are they thinking? First they'll fail, then how do they think they'll look in the eyes of their children?

Too bad that many people are content both with arbitrary restrictions and with the people who force restrictions on them.

guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
Regarding Khomeini - dictators end up where they didn't expect. Tell Stalin of 1923 that he'll end up shooting all his buddies while calling them Japanese spies with plain face. Tell young Khomeini that his main achivement will be aforemendioned redressing. Tell Putin of 2001 that he'll turn out a longer-lived mummy than Brezhnev. They'd have a healthy laugh back then.
guard-of-terra··on Complex view of Islam found in poetry of Iran, Stanford researcher shows
That's to be expected that difference between "actual historic Islam" and "whatever fundamendalists now push as the only true thing" will be akin to this:

https://pp.vk.me/c635106/v635106753/217e/XWciycs1P1c.jpg

Also, fundamentalists just invented most of things they sell as eternal.

guard-of-terra··on Emperor Akihito of Japan Raises Possibility of Leaving Throne
Maybe we'll have a royal family and some princes for a change?

Right now we don't even know if he has wife or any children and what's they're up to, and also what happens next.

Him calling himself an Emperor is laughable, but having an Emperor with heritage and all the stuff instead of him now looks like an option.

guard-of-terra··on Ecological Wealth of Nations
These days people prefer to live either in suburbia in Mediterranean climate or in old capitals (think Paris and London). That's a definite trend - we no longer have colonization of new spaces, we instead have consolidation in known good places.

One can perhaps start a commune in a forest or on an island even today, with handpicked people, but it doesn't happen.

Wanting to flee from Earth with all its problems is understandable, but I fear that we'll repeat a lot of bad stuff in habitats. Think totalitarian cults, slavery, plain old totalitarism.

guard-of-terra··on Ecological Wealth of Nations
b) You will have to control developing countries mostly, which will righfully trigger discrimination cries.
guard-of-terra··on Ecological Wealth of Nations
Why would people want to live in a space habitat?

If not many, then how are we going to choose who to shove there?

What if it will turn out discriminatory?

guard-of-terra··on Emperor Akihito of Japan Raises Possibility of Leaving Throne
> There was not (and will never be) any egalitarian civilization on earth.

What about Switzerland?

guard-of-terra··on Emperor Akihito of Japan Raises Possibility of Leaving Throne
I was in strict opposition to a concept of Monarchy, but not anymore.

In many countries constitutional monarchs are replaced by de-facto for-life Despots (think Putin and his partner Erdogan), for whom nobody could explain who they are (parents, relatives, children?), where we got them from and what happens when they expire. At least for a Monarch we knew all that with high amount of detail.

Who have no legitimacy whatsoever other than a bit of popular support, a lot of police state support and constant twisting of the law.

Nobility used to be public, now instead of having no nobility we have private nobility behind tall walls.

guard-of-terra··on Ur-Fascism by Umberto Eco (1995)
> I don't think you can find 5% to support such position.

Why then this position is only thing we hear from liberal camp? Didn't hear them trying to solve the hard problem of "when deciding what to do with refugees, who is to let in and what to do with rejects".

It's not about sexual orientation, but public sexual orientation seems to correlate heavily with political views.

guard-of-terra··on Ur-Fascism by Umberto Eco (1995)
> If we would hold a poll, "should Poland accept whole lot of refugees from Middle East?", what response would you expect from "gays and leftists"? I would suspect they'll be at least 60% pro "Poles should definitely accept as much refugees as humanely possible".

Aaaand, in my book, that counts as "wanting to flood smbd with Muslims".

There's just notion that it's a respectable thing to want, and fighting it is not respectable. Even talking about this is frowned upon as you can see.

guard-of-terra··on Ur-Fascism by Umberto Eco (1995)
http://paulgraham.com/say.html
guard-of-terra··on Ur-Fascism by Umberto Eco (1995)
It had a nationality, did not it?
← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →