HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gnaffle

1,632 karma · joined July 4, 2010

submissionscomments
gnaffle··on Microsoft CEO Candidate Elop Said to Mull Windows Shift
In other words, he was unable to anticipate that Apple would be able reduce the price of the iPhone, like they did with the iPod?
gnaffle··on Microsoft CEO Candidate Elop Said to Mull Windows Shift
I'm not too sure about that. A lot of Microsofts dominance in business comes from the ubiquity of its operating system, while IBM has _always_ been big in enterprise / mainframe computing and research regardless of their "foray" into PCs.

Giving up the consumer market to focus on business puts this dominance in danger (even more so than the mobile/tablet threat), because someone might very well and up doing to Microsoft what Microsoft did to the minicomputer makers, and eat their business "from the bottom up".

So I think the interesting question is whether Microsoft could survive and thrive on enterprise software/services in an environment where neither Windows nor Office were dominant.

gnaffle··on The Surveillance State Puts U.S. Elections at Risk of Manipulation
My slightly pessimistic view is that the ones with resources would be able to keep their privacy and use that to their advantage, while the less fortunate would not.

Popular opinion might change, but as we've seen laws can change much more quickly, and even things that most people would consider normal could become a punishable offense.

At that point, for the people who already have the data on their lives out there, it will be too late to do anything about it, while the people who have been smart enough to live "perfectly normal" lives with the correct political and religious views, or those who can hire people to cover their tracks, will be better off.

gnaffle··on The Surveillance State Puts U.S. Elections at Risk of Manipulation
I think the biggest problem with this idea is the question of who gets to decide what the social norms and what is "acceptable". Our social norms are influenced by the media, the politicians and laws that they pass, so certain people in power positions will have an advantage. You can see this in a lot of countries (latest with gays in Russia, but countries like Iran and Germany are historic, extreme examples).

If for instance gays and atheists are exposed as "deviants" in the media, but corruption and hiring prostitutes are downplayed as something "every politician is doing", then it doesn't really matter who shares what: The openly gay, atheist politician will have a hard time (and perhaps be put in prison) while the corrupt ones walk free.

gnaffle··on Flojack Dead on Arrival
The DigiSpark seemed to live up to expectations, and it shipped only a little bit late. That made me back the DigiX, even though it's a more complicated product.

I think the more ambitious the project is, and the less actual production experience the founders have, the more likely they are to run into problems. So that should be a big consideration when backing a project.

gnaffle··on New FAA Guidelines Permit More Device Use
Would say that a company would be equally well protected by having all computers on their network with reachable IPs, with no filtering whatsoever?
gnaffle··on New FAA Guidelines Permit More Device Use
Yep. At least some HN members will get the same attitude back at them in the form of their users bragging to others about how smart they are since they managed to bypass the company firewall or some such thing, and saying "so far, I haven't caused any security breaches, so it can't hurt"..
gnaffle··on New FAA Guidelines Permit More Device Use
Agreed. Not to mention, those low wage, low skilled attendents have quite a bit of training that can save your life if you are ever in an airplane accident. They may not know about the latest gadget from Amazon, but they do know their stuff.
gnaffle··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
So 14 days and still "pending analysis". I don't know where he lives, but it can't be that difficult to find someone with an oscilloscope and the knowledge of how to use it?

Again, sounds very fishy. I would expect a more methodical approach from a security researcher.

gnaffle··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
With many (most?) desktop motherboards, the flash chip is desolderable and can usually be taken out and read on a dedicated flash reader if you have the equipment. There would be no way for the rootkit to bypass that.
gnaffle··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
Yes, especially coupled with the "been going on for 3 years" and yet no actual analysis of the virus, no oscilloscopes, digital signal analyzers or spectrum analyzers put on the task, no third party researchers confirming this. Sounds very odd indeed.
gnaffle··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
If not impossible, at least very strange that he has not done more research to verify this (would be easy to do with an oscilloscope attached to the speaker output).

Seems like trolling or some form of paranoia.

gnaffle··on Toyota's firmware: Bad design and its consequences
I think the biggest problem with software is that it can be perfectly safe and work OK in 99.9999% of all cases, and still contain deadly bugs that strike in very specific and difficult to reproduce circumstances. That the software works very well most of the time only adds to the belief that there must be another explanation for what happened (I think even Woz could reproduce the runaway accelerator bug in his Prius?)

That a piece of software is widespread and works good most of the time simply can't be used to say whether the software is "safe". To say anything about that, you have to look at the process used to develop the software, and see whether that process has a good success rate of predicting and uncovering software bugs.

If Toyotas code is as bad as this article makes it out to be and the certification standards are so poor, I won't be surprised if we see more cases like this in the future, although they will still be rare.

gnaffle··on Toyota's firmware: Bad design and its consequences
Even in the 787, the spoilers and horizontal stabilizers can be operated electrically independently of hydraulics and flight computers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly-by-wire.
gnaffle··on Mavericks – power use / service battery
For me, so far no. Even after the Spotlight indexing, I've noticed a very significant decrease in battery life after upgrading. I don't know why, and the Power tab in Activity Monitor doesn't give any hints. It doesn seem that the fans are also running more frequently than they used to, even on battery power.
gnaffle··on Apple shows us the amazing process of making the Mac Pro
The processes in and of itself aren't amazing, I think what's amazing is the scale that Apple operates on. Not many other PC manufacturers use CNC milling as extensively as Apple. Here's an interesting video with Jony Ive talking about the process: http://youtu.be/nUHROAtyGIg?t=2m29s
gnaffle··on The inside story of Bombardier’s $4-billion gamble on a super quiet jet
Do you seriously believe that the government subsidies of Airbus/EADS and Boeing in the 60s and 70s have been a net negative benefit to their home countries economic and employment wise, now that those two companies dominate the jet airliner market?
gnaffle··on Why Does Windows Have Terrible Battery Life?
That might be true, but doesn't the whole "vertical integration" argument get thrown out the window when he describes the problem on Microsofts own hardware, the Surface Pro?

Certainly Microsoft should have the ability or money to optimize those drivers for maximum battery efficiency.

gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
Yes, but I don't know of a way to give one Linux instance several desktops, and enable super fast and seamless switching between them.
gnaffle··on Should we stop believing Malcolm Gladwell?
Here's at least one: I've read some rebuttals to the "ethnic theory of plane crashes" here: http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/foreign-airline-safety

and here:

http://askakorean.blogspot.no/2013/07/culturalism-gladwell-a...

Put it simply, Gladwell seems to form a theory, then find enough facts to support that theory. But that's not the way to do proper research.

In this case, had he actually consulted with pilots, koreans, and finally korean pilots, he might have ended up with a different conclusion (let alone now have made so many trivial errors in the text).

He could also have compared accident statistics and looked at how many accidents could be attributed to poor CRM in different countries. But again, he didn't do that.

He mentions that CRM training is used nowadays in all airlines (to improve crew collaboration) but fails to mention that the accident that sparked the focus on CRM (the worst airline accident of all time) was caused by a Dutch captain, from a country with a low power-distance index (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenerife_airport_disaster)

gnaffle··on How to Become as Rich as Bill Gates
I think it's easy to forget how ruthless Bill Gates and Microsoft actually was, never mind the fact that they were convicted for antitrust violations. The history is littered with casualties from what started as well-intentioned partnerships with Microsoft.

So I think the feeling was not so much jealousy, but more that they didn't compete fairly. Especially in the Linux world (where Greenspun was from), and more so after the Halloween documents leaked.

That feeling was even more pronounced in 1998, when Microsoft dominated computing and it seemed like _any_ attempt to do it big in software would either have to mean getting bought by, or killed by the sheer hugeness of Microsoft.

Nowadays Gates has set up a huge charity, and Microsoft has stumbled on so many things that we kind of feel bad for them instead.

gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
I think it's possible do to so, I remember seeing this ARM USB/HDMI board, which apparently can mirror the screen over USB: http://www.fxitech.com/technology/any-screen-ip/

Not sure how well it works, though.

gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
I think most MacBooks are good for running Linux as well, if you like the build quality and features of the Mac. The Ubuntu Wiki has a good rundown of how well the different models are supported.

That said, I think Apple has done a pretty good job of being respectful of privacy. You are asked explicitly whether to share information (location services etc) and you can always say no. Compare this to the latest Ubuntu release where your local file searches are being sent to Amazon as a default feature.

gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
I meant virtual desktops, mostly because I like to be able to take my laptop anywhere. I actually used Synergy at one point for my desktop setup (and also because the OSX mouse acceleration profile was broken for me for quite some time).

A cool hardware project might be to take a micro Linux ARM board with LVDS display output, mount it inside the CD bay in my laptop and make an internal LVDS switch to quickly switch between OSX and the Linux board. That would be pretty much ideal. :)

gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
Can it also show inline previews of PDF files and search emails?
gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
I think if you're a very basic user, you can get a consistent experience just because you can use the included desktop in Ubuntu or some other distro and not run into many problems. However, your experience will still be inferior to that of OSX since Apple has put more efforts into applications like Mail, iPhoto and iTunes.

If you're an advanced user (as all of the readers here would probaby be), you'll quickly end up in the situation you describe.

gnaffle··on Ask HN: Have you considered switching from OS X to Linux?
I used Linux exclusively for many years but switched to OSX for work some years ago. I still feel more productive in Linux, but it's because of a few tricks that I so far haven't found a good replacement for in OSX:

- Focus follows mouse without auto-raise - Instant switching between virtual desktops (not possible to disable the animation in OSX last time I checked) - Instantly open a new terminal window with intelligent window placement in the currently active virtual desktop.

Since these turned out to be a hassle in OSX, I've just gradually stopped using them, and resorder to a single desktop paradigm with more mouse clicking for navigation. All in all I feel like I'm working slower in OSX than in Linux.

However, the major problem with Linux is the looks and a host of small nice details that OSX just gets right. Instant search in Spotlight including Mail, I've grown accustomed to the Mail app (Thunderbird search is ridiculous compared to Mail.app, for instance), Time Machine, and a few other apps like 1Password.

If I could get a virtualization scheme where I could have one desktop with OSX and 3-4 desktops of Linux, that would be ideal. But I don't think that's possible with Parallels or VMware, and I'm not sure how well OSX would run virtualized under Linux.

gnaffle··on Should we stop believing Malcolm Gladwell?
It's not a very good comparison. First, it's not presented as funny, it's presented as science, complete with links to studies. If you ask most people reading Gladwell, they will believe his theories.

Second, it's not that he exaggerates something, but often he's flat-out wrong. The fascination he sparks is the "oh, that's an unlikely fact I wouldn't have believed was true, had it not been for the fact that these science studies cited here proves it."

gnaffle··on Children aren't born smart. They're made smart by conversation
This is at least one of the studies I've heard of: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6872627
gnaffle··on Gartner tells IT shops that it's 'game over' for BlackBerry
No, but the outlook is uncertain. There's a history of solid mobile platforms being abandoned much more quickly than most would expect: Symbian, WM6, Palm, Sidekick (including the spectacular Microsoft data deletion screwup), so to not make contingency / transition plans now when BlackBerry is officially up for sale would be irresponsible.
← PreviousPage 6 of 22Next →