HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

foobears42

-18 karma · joined February 12, 2021

submissionscomments
foobears42··on Drug for treating obesity cuts body weight by 20 percent
Willpower is exactly why they eat more. They feel a pang of hunger in their grossly stretched out stomach and can't resist eating.

The drug does not remove fat. It removes the feeling of hunger. Assume both groups have little willpower (they are fat after all). The control group feels hunger and continues satisfying that hunger with food as they have no will power. The group with suppressed hunger from the drug also have no willpower, but since they feel no hunger they eat normal amounts.

foobears42··on Drug for treating obesity cuts body weight by 20 percent
They don't want the consequences of overeating. But yes, I do believe they choose to eat the amounts they do.
foobears42··on Drug for treating obesity cuts body weight by 20 percent
> There is more to weight gain than lack of willpower.

Is there? The study you quoted suggests the opposite. The drug doesn't directly cause fat to melt off. The fat is lost by eating less. Why is the control group eating more? lack of....